Diagnosed with an aggressive cancer of the right lung on my 58th birthday (14th July) So not really ...
Diagnosed with an aggressive cancer of the right lung on my 58th birthday (14th July) So not really in the humour for writing much at the moment, although I *WILL* be back before too long...Ken
Member since:06.12.2000
Reviews:678
Members who trust:869
(UPDATE AT END OF ORIGINAL OPINION)
~ ~ To anyone who is a motorist the Automobile Association (or AA for short) will probably need no introduction. It seems to be part of our motoring heritage, and to have been around as long as cars themselves.
~ ~ In the days before massive breakdown wagons, capable of lifting and carrying complete cars, the old AA patrolman, on his distinctive motorbike and sidecar combination, was a familiar sight on our highways and by-ways. The AA, and motoring in general, has come a long way since then, and nowadays it is an enormous organisation offering the motorist far more than just the basic “breakdown” service of old.
~ ~ I have been a member of the AA ever since I began to drive, some 33 years ago, but a recent “run in” I had with them over the Christmas period prompted me to have a closer look at the service as it is today, and what exactly it is offering for our yearly subscription.
THE SERVICE ~~~~~~~~~~~
Breakdowns
~ ~ The basic function of the AA is still, as it always has been, to assist members in the event of a breakdown. Since joining back in the 1960’s, I have used this breakdown call-out service on more occasions than I care to remember, and overall it has been of an exceptionally high standard. The patrolmen (I think they still call them that) are very efficient and extremely courteous, all being highly trained mechanics in their own right. They are even able to call on the assistance of more expert knowledge, in the rare cases where they are stumped for an answer, by radioing in to their head quarters and asking for assistance on specific problems.
~ ~ I have broken down in the wilds of Scotland in the middle of blizzards, when even an Eskimo would be loathe to leave the warmth of his igloo, and the intrepid AA man has still managed to come to my rescue. On one occasion
I deposited a rear axle of my BMW 525 in the middle of a French motorway near Cannes. (at about 110mph I might add; NOT a pleasant experience) This could have proved a real holiday killer in terms of cost and inconvenience, only for the fact I was covered under the AA’s “Europe Assistance” programme. I think they called it “5 Star Cover” in those days. Not only was I towed to the nearest BMW main agent, but supplied with a replacement car until my own was repaired, and all at no extra cost.
~ ~ So what is this run in I had with them over Christmas, as I mentioned in my introduction. As regular readers of my opinions are aware, I now drive a taxi for a living here in Dublin, Ireland. On the 23rd December of last year, I was taking a fare from the city centre to an outlying suburb, when I was flashed by a fellow taxi-driver while sitting at some traffic lights. My rear lights had decided to give up the ghost, so I immediately pulled in to the kerb, and after organising another taxi for my passengers, (and checking my fusebox) got on my mobile phone to the AA. On being informed that there would be a delay of some two hours due to them being very busy, I told the fellow on the phone to forget it, and that I would make my way home and then telephone again from there. This wasn’t as dodgy or dangerous as it sounds, as I still had my number plate lights, and was able to turn on my rear fog lights as well, so I could still be easily seen by other motorists. On reaching home, I called them again, and after supplying my membership number, was then informed that I wasn’t eligible for assistance, as I only had basic cover which didn’t include “Home Start”. This means you must be a minimum of a quarter of a mile from your home address before they will attend a call out.
~ ~ So what is my “quibble”, you may well ask? Firstly, my yearly subscription to the AA is paid by direct debit, and ever since I became a member I have ALWAYS opted for the highest level of cover available. I even have the “Home Start” stickers on the rear window of my car to prove it!! Secondly, I had opted to drive home rather than hang around at the side of the road, where I would have been eligible for assistance, and no one had bothered to mention to me at the time that I “wasn’t covered” for home assistance.
~ ~ I very forcefully pointed this out to the fellow on the telephone, asked them to check their records again, and to provide me with the help I required. I also let him know I was a member of 30 plus years standing, and that I wasn’t happy with his explanation. But there was no moving this guy. The “office was shut” for Christmas, so there was no way he could check my claim that I actually was covered, and my (polite) request to speak to someone more senior was met with a blank refusal, as was my request for his own name. (In fact, he hung up on me at this point)
~ ~ The end result of all these shenanigans was that I ended up off the road on one of the busiest nights of the year for a taxi-driver, and some £250 or so out of pocket as a consequence. I got sorted out the next day with the assistance of a mate, and it later transpired that I was, in fact, covered for “Home Start”, and that it had been some sort of glitch in the AA’s computer records. I got an apology, both verbal and written, but I didn’t get what I had actually paid for and badly required, namely the roadside assistance at the time I needed it.
~ ~ That said, and the “rant” over, I am prepared to give the AA a second chance despite this incident, as it has been a one off in all the years I have used the service.
~ ~ As I mentioned earlier, the AA offers their members far more these days than just the basic breakdown service. One of these that I have personally used to great advantage is their “Car Checks and Inspections” service. This is where a qualified AA mechanic will inspect a car or vehicle that you are thinking of purchasing, and supply you with a report on any faults or defects it may have. I used this service when purchasing my current taxi from a garage in Northumberland in August, 1999. So confident was I after receiving the OK from the AA, that I actually bought the car sight unseen, and flew over from Ireland to collect it. The report was spot on, and it has been an extremely reliable and super car for the past two years. I paid £90 for this service, and I note from the AA web-site that this price has now increased to £94, but I would still consider this very good value. (For more details, see my opinion “So You Want More Choice”….. plug, plug)
“Find The Cheapest Petrol” Service ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ ~ This is a service I have never had to personally use, as the cost of petrol here in Ireland is NOWHERE near as expensive as in the UK. (Our average price per litre for unleaded is around 65p (Irish), equivalent to about 50p Sterling.
~ ~ There is a link on the AA web-site to an organisation called “PetrolBusters.com”. Upon joining (just your email address) you simply type in your postcode, and it will give you a list of local garages and what they are charging currently for unleaded petrol. It also gives you the highest and lowest prices in your home region, and you can even print off a map of their location. I tried it out for my old home address in East Lothian, Scotland, and was surprised at the results, and also by the fact that many of the garages that were the cheapest 25 years ago are still the cheapest today!! If I was still living in the UK, this is a service I would highly recommend, and that I would check out on a regular basis.
“Loans” Service ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ ~ The AA also offers their members a loan service. I checked this out on their web-site, and it didn’t appear to me to be very good value, with fairly high APR’s being charged, which varied depending on the amount and duration of the loan. There again, I am out of touch with the current rates in the UK. But we pay far lower APR’s than this here in Ireland! (Maybe another member who is more acquainted with the current UK rates would like to leave a comment on this?)
“Other” Services ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ ~ There are a range of other useful services listed on the AA web-site, but for the sake of brevity, I am not going to go into great detail on them here in this opinion. They range from AA insurance, route planners, travel news, member’s discount schemes, and driving schools, to advice on where to stay, where to eat, and what to do if you are visiting anywhere. All I will say is that they certainly seem to have all the bases covered in almost any aspect of the motoring world you would care to name.
OVERALL ~~~~~~~
~ ~ I think that I would still have to rate the AA as probably the best of the motorist’s breakdown organisations. Certainly, there is far more competition in the market than there used to be, when you were either with the AA or the RAC, and other companies probably offer good services in this area. But overall, I think it’s still the good old AA for this particular motorist.
UPDATE 30/9/2001 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ ~ I had cause to use the good old AA again when I returned from my annual holiday in Scotland this year. I'd lost the key for my immobiliser on my taxi somewhere in the wilds of the Highlands, and there was no way the car was going to start without it. So on the 'dog and bone' I got to the AA. They arrived (to my home!!)within half an hour, and there was no way this guy was going to be beaten by the problem, despite the fairly complex electronics concerned. He spent over TWO HOURS getting me sorted, and had practically the whole of the dashboard dismantled at one stage. And all for the price of my annual membership. (Well, I did give him the price of a good drink!) They have gone up in my estimation once again. BRILLIANT service.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
A great op, I have been a member for years, (was staff for seven years, many moons ago!!) and I still use their website for route planning all the time. I broke down in a windy and wild bleak part of scotland a few years ago, and they sent a local garage, something I never realised they did.
kornkid2001 04.11.2001 19:50
aa is the 4th emergency service as they say, and i agree fully, thanks kk!
JamesE 30.01.2001 00:24
I TRIED THE PETROL BUSTER WITH SOME STRANGE RESULTS THANK YOU !
Advantages: Get you back on the road on most occasions fairly quickly Disadvantages: Maybe services aren't provided within the membership fee, be careful!
Ruby 21.06.2001 ·
Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of AA
Advantages: none- I never actually had a breakdown to use the services Disadvantages: they benefit financially if you do not receive your renewal notice
cscullion 23.09.2009 ·
Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: somewhat helpful
Review of AA
Advantages: I passed! Learn in brand new Ford Focus, well trained Instructor, free AA membership for 12 months Disadvantages: cost - you pay for the good service you receive
surfchik27 02.06.2005 (02.06.2005)
·
Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of AA Driving School