A Good Hanging (And Other Stories) - Ian Rankin

More Images

A Good Hanging (And Other Stories) - Ian Rankin > Reviews > Proof that the Short Story is an acceptable Medium.

Fiction - Crime - ISBN: 0752809431 more

Overall user rating A Good Hanging (And Other Stories) - Ian Rankin 4 reviews | Add product to list

Edinburgh is a city steeped in history and tradition, a seat of learning, of elegant living, known as the 'Athens of the North'. But that isn't all. The city's flip-side is a city...
more...of grudges, blackmail, violence, greed and fear - where past and present clash and old wounds fester. In any year Detective Inspector John Rebus can expect gang warfare, murder, assault and battery at the very least. In this collection he investigates the hanging of a student actor during the Festival, an arson attack on a bird watcher and the witnessing of an apparent miracle... See all Product Description

All A Good Hanging (And Other Stories) - Ian Rankin reviews Previous review
Proof that the Short Story is an acceptable Medium.


Author's product rating:   A Good Hanging (And Other Stories) - Ian Rankin - rated by bannonc

Would you listen to it again? Yes 
Story Outstanding 
Characters Outstanding 
Listenability Once you start it, you won't be able to switch it off! 
How does it compare to similar audio books? Very good 
How does it compare to audio works by the same author? Quite good 

Advantages:
Disadvantages:

Recommend to potential buyers: yes 

Full review
I am a big fan of the short story, but had previously only read Ian Rankin novels. What a treat I had in store.
I love the darkness in Ian Rankin's imagination. The Rebus character appears, detailed and human as always. The additional characters are equally wonderfully portrayed- you have a real sense that these people exist- they become alive very easily as you read. Even in the short story, Rankin manages to complete a picture that allows you to visualise a character, a setting, or a scene- the emotions are clear and the motives unconfusing.
I have become a little disappointed lately, as a short story writer myself, and a fan of short story writers such as Bradbury. The medium is a difficult one to publish in, especially for the unknown writer. My faith was slightly renewed by reading these stories, and I hope that such concise writing, and excellent story telling, will help enhance the public image of the short story, and make this an easier forum.
 





Evaluate this review
How helpful would this review be to someone making a buying decision?
Rating guidelines

   

Comments on this review
More options
All A Good Hanging (And Other Stories) - Ian Rankin reviews Previous review