Home > Beauty > Make-up > Eye Make-up > BeneFit Eye Make-up > BeneFit Bad Gal Lash Mascara
BeneFit Bad Gal Lash Mascara

Community images

  • BeneFit Bad Gal Lash Mascara
  • bad gal mascara and packaging
  • curly eyelashes
  • BeneFit Bad Gal Lash Mascara
  • BeneFit Bad Gal Lash Mascara

Reviews - BeneFit Bad Gal Lash Mascara

Eye Make-up - Mascara

> Show product information

Quality

User reviews

Filter by
Review type
  • Reviews with images (4)
  • Quick reviews (3)
  • standard reviews (105)
Product rating
  • (47)
  • (35)
  • (15)
  • (6)
  • (5)
Sort by Helpfulness
  • Helpfulness
  • Product rating
  • Date

Super

“Luxury Lacking Lash..!”

published 28/08/2012

Free! - Worked well - Didn't smudge - Gentle formu...

Did NOT live up to its claims..

~ Benefit Bad Gal Lash Mascara ~ I do love a bargain. I was therefore delighted to discover that a recent copy of "Glamour" magazine was giving away some freebies with each copy of their magazine. As the freebies were from the "Benefit" cosmetics range, which I had tried only once or twice before...

> Read review

Quality
Ease of Application
Waterproof?
Does it irritate your eyes?

Did you find this review helpful? Yes 0

Good

Beautiful application with a wonderful initial eff...

Doesn't wear well, left with flecks on my lower li...

If you haven't already spotted I am a bit of a make up junkie. In fact, the first step to try and combat to your problems is admitting you have one, but did this mascara give me a suitable hit? Benefit should know what they're doing, they have been doing the whole make-up thing since 1976, and...

> Read review

Quality
Ease of Application
Waterproof?
Does it irritate your eyes?

Did you find this review helpful? Yes 0

Excellent

Brilliant volume without looking silly!

It's expensive... but highly worth it for a nice t...

Recently a magazine gave away a smaller version of this mascara, which is the reason for the sudden influx in reviews on here for it! I however have been a fan of this mascara for a long time and own the full size version of it. I noticed some mixed reviews for this mascara so I feel I need to...

> Read review

Quality
Ease of Application
Waterproof?
Does it irritate your eyes?

Did you find this review helpful? Yes 0

Excellent

“Volume Lashes”

published 22/06/2009

does what it says

-

I have always considered my eyes one of my best features, but the only thing is its extending eyelashes to make them stand out more and look longer which I find hard to do. I have tried so many mascaras and for daytime use most of them work just fine in adding more volume to my lashes, however...

> Read review

Quality
Ease of Application
Waterproof?
Does it irritate your eyes?

Did you find this review helpful? Yes 0

Good

“Bad Gal? I'd say Ambivalent.”

published 23/06/2009

not clumpy, natural

expensive, not dramatic enough

Benefit Bad Gal mascara has been widely revered in the makeup world as a 'cult' product. But, lets remind ourselves what 'cult' really means. It means revered not widely, but among a small group of obsessive fans. After using this product, I can see why. Call me picky, but when I buy a mascara I...

> Read review

Quality

Did you find this review helpful? Yes 0

Super

“Bad? No It's Definitely Good”

published 03/02/2009

Only requires one coat, lasts all day, no smudging...

Not waterproof, shelf life only 6 months

I've always been in two minds about trying this Bad Gal Lash Mascara by Benefit. I've always been of the impression that mascara is mascara, whatever the price. I've also read a couple of reviews on Dooyoo which suggested that it may not be worth paying extra for. However, this all changed at...

> Read review

Quality
Ease of Application
Waterproof?
Does it irritate your eyes?

Did you find this review helpful? Yes 0

Super

“Bad gal lashes!”

published 27/06/2009

Great volumising effect

Not waterproof

The Benefit brand originated in San Francisco and follows the ethos of vintage glam, it reminds me of the 1940's era. The official website for the brand (www.benefitcosmetics.com) states that the aim was to create stores with a candy store like atmosphere. I bought thieir mascara for the first...

> Read review

Quality
Ease of Application
Waterproof?

Did you find this review helpful? Yes 0

Good

“No So Bad Bad Gal Mascara”

published 29/08/2006

Huge brush, no clumping, dramatic coverage

Not waterproof, tends to smudge, quite expensive

Being a bit of a retro girl, I've always been attracted to the funky kitsch packaging of the Benefit brand, but never felt that really justified buying the products. However, having read a glowing review of Bad Gal Lash in one of the Sunday glossies and in desperate need of a new mascara, I...

> Read review

Quality
Ease of Application
Waterproof?
Does it irritate your eyes?

Did you find this review helpful? Yes 0

Good

“It's not bad, gals!”

published 28/09/2009

glossy, long lashes

too expensive, not enough volume

I got a tube of this mascara free with Glamour magazine a couple of months ago like I know a lot of the other girls on Dooyoo did. I wouldn't have chosen to purchase this product myself as I am completely happy with the Max Factor Masterpiece mascara that I use. Also, I have tried quite a few...

> Read review

Quality
Ease of Application
Waterproof?
Does it irritate your eyes?

Did you find this review helpful? Yes 0

Good

“ Bad Panda”

published 07/09/2005

great colour, no clumps

stops lashes curling, smudges easily, expensive

Appearance --------------------- They say you shouldn't judge a book by its cover, so I guess you shouldn't judge a mascara by its packaging but it's good to know what it looks like so here goes. Benefit BADGal Mascara comes in a black box with pink and white writing. It's quite stylish with just...

> Read review

Quality

Did you find this review helpful? Yes 0

Excellent

“Very beneficial!”

published 04/06/2006

Beautiful results!

It's a bit tricky to remove!

Benefit are probably my favourite cosmetics company of all time; their products work, they're quirky, the packaging is beautiful and they make you feel like when you're a kid and you're playing dress-up! One of the main problems that people have with Benefit is that their products, on first...

> Read review

Quality
Ease of Application
Waterproof?
Does it irritate your eyes?

Did you find this review helpful? Yes 0

Satisfactory

The packaging is nice

The result doesn't justify the cost

I have used an awful lot of mascaras over the years, including some pretty terrible ones and some fantastic ones too! I wasn't sure which category this product would fit into as I've had a bit of a hit and miss experience with Benefit in the past, though this mascara looks pretty stylish with...

> Read review

Quality
Ease of Application
Waterproof?
Does it irritate your eyes?

Did you find this review helpful? Yes 0

Super

Works well

It's rather pricey!

When it comes to mascara I really hate the stuff! From the process of buying it to using it I find the slimy stuff terrible on every single level. However being a bit of a party animal and enjoying my wild nights out of course I'd feel more than half naked (as I am usually anyhow lol) without...

> Read review

Quality
Ease of Application
Waterproof?
Does it irritate your eyes?

Did you find this review helpful? Yes 0

Not for me

“Bad(ly Made Up Gal!)”

published 26/08/2012

Easy to remove, doesn't clump

Difficult to apply a decent coating, smudges easil...

I don’t have the time or the inclination to wear much make up on a regular basis but the one item that I wear everyday is black mascara. I am always on the look out for bargains and special offers so I was pleased to spot that Glamour magazine was giving away Benefit products with every issue a...

> Read review

Quality
Ease of Application
Waterproof?
Does it irritate your eyes?

Did you find this review helpful? Yes 0

Super

Thick formula, legnthens lashes, cute packaging

expensive, needs She-Laq to keep it smudge-proof.

I admit I am a complete Benefit Addict- their cute packaging always appeals to me and I've found with most of the products I've tried that it really does do what it says on the package. Sometimes, however, a product disappoints me slightly- perhaps just after my high expectations. This, however...

> Read review

Quality
Ease of Application
Waterproof?
Does it irritate your eyes?

Did you find this review helpful? Yes 0