hiker 4


Add to my Circle of Trust

Subscribe to reviews

About me: Happy New Year to all of you still around on here... I'll pop in now and then.

Member since:28.03.2003


Video reviews:1

Members who trust:108




Funny, but with some serious points hidden in the narrative

The humour won't appeal to everyone .

Recommendable Yes:

36 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful See ratings
very helpful by (100%):
  2. Amazingwoo
  3. Coloneljohn
and 33 other members

View all ratings

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Share this review on

''It began for Basil "Banger" Peyton-Crumbe the day he died in a pheasant shooting incident''.

If you were in any doubt as to the nature of the novel given the cover jacket and the author's disclaimer to the effect that any similarity between the human characters and any real person is entirely coincidental, but he feels safe from any threats of libel action on behalf of the dead animals whose characters he has mercilessly manipulated for narrative effect, then its opening sentence should put you straight.

It is all going to be a trifle silly.

Banger Peyton-Crumbe is (was) an aristocrat of the old order. He lived in the big house, had done his duty by the estate by marrying and siring a child – sadly a daughter, who even more sadly turned out to be an animal lover, but that wasn't really his fault. There's a grandson who might be salvageable. He was the kind of person for whom these estates were designed. He had no interest in money. What he didn't need sat in a current account earning zero interest, the rest he spent keeping up the estate, improving the estate, and in his own way he took a fairly ecological stance on things. Not animal-welfare orientated, but some of the side-effects might not have been downright cruel.

His dogs were looked after so long as they worked. Some of them even after they'd stopped working. None of them were allowed to suffer for long.

His passion was shooting. He ran one of the best pheasant shoots in the country. He ran it the old way. A limited number of birds, allowed a fighting chance. A shoot, not a slaughterhouse.

On such a shoot, he is shot.

Technically, he shoots himself – he's holding the gun, it misfires, he dies.

But he's not the type to mismanage a shotgun, or its loading. Is there more to this than meets the eye? The police don't think so. The police dog does.

For Crumbe though, life is going to get even more interesting. He isn't dead long. He is promptly reincarnated.

As a pheasant.

Meanwhile, his image-conscious city-rich half-brother takes over the estate with his utterly crass girlfriend and her manipulative indulged feline, while the disinherited daughter with her stroppy teenage son and mixture of dogs is forced out of the estate cottage into a rancid caravan.

However, it seems that this might not have been what Banger had intended.

There is more than a touch of the Tom Sharpe's about what follows. Of course it is very silly. Talking animals, conveniently placed newspapers, dim-witted coppers (and brutal ones), political activists and simple caring children. Coincidence played and battered into submission.

But it is humourous. Not laugh-out-loud funny for my taste but smirkily, smilingly, chucklingly amusing.

All of the human characters are extreme stereotypes, and all are cruelly pulled down to size. The animals fare better… although some of them are 'no better than they ought to be'. There's a woodland sequence of pheasant rearing that owes a debt of credit to Lord & Parks' brilliant "Chicken Run". The dogs investigate the crime. Banger survives with a memory of his former life and retains his passion for the shoot, even from the other side of the fence, but gradually becomes a more human character for all his feathers, until the memory begins to fade.

It's a lightweight book and most certainly not to everyone's taste, but I thoroughly enjoyed ''Bird Brain''.

What sets it apart from any other flippant comic novel is that buried in all the ridiculous frivolity and dime-a-dozen detecting there are some valid points about the nature of country estates and the whole shooting business.

It is a business these days: I'm guessing that there are few estates that could afford to run what Banger would call a proper shoot. Kennaway doesn't shy away from this, but he sets out as his background the two extremes of running a managed shooting estate and pretty well invites the reader to figure out where the line should be drawn.

There are those whose management consists of providing what would be natural habitat, stocking it with birds, protecting them to adulthood (but only just) and allowing them to live and breed and feed as they can find and finds the sport in actually having birds that can fly well and only as many as would naturally (more or less) survive in the area of ground covered. Then there are those that overstock, feed the birds into indolence, producing mass flocks that can barely get airborne, don't understand the threat and are pretty difficult to miss. There are shoots where you need to be able to shoot. And shoots where you scarcely need to know which end of the gun to point. There are shoots which expect the fallen birds to be eaten; and those which end up land-filling them because there are so many carcases of such poor quality so badly shot up they can't even be turned into cheap pâté.

There is, Kennaway suggests beneath his narrative, a difference. Maybe, he suggests, we shouldn't be absolutist and abolitionist in our approach and should (as we try to do with other kinds of farming) find a balance.

Of course, you could just ignore all that and read for the thrill of whether the dog will get his man.


Published in hardback by Jonathan Cape
ISBN 9780224093996
Pages 287
Cover price £14.99


This review first appeared on thebookbag.co.uk to whom I'm grateful for the review copy.

(c) Lesley Mason

  Write your own review

Share this review on


Rate this review »

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

Rate as exceptional

Rate as somewhat helpful

Rate as very helpful

Rate as not helpful

Rate as helpful

Rate as off topic

Write your own review Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful. Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful.   Report a problem with this review’s content

Comments about this review »

Coloneljohn 16.04.2012 19:27

I rather like the idea of this.I will have to put it on my buying list. Thanks. John

catsholiday 05.04.2012 09:48

Sounds quite amusing in a very British sort of way!!

brittle1906 04.04.2012 20:41

I think I'd like this one, great review.

Add your comment

max. 2000 characters

  Post comment

Similar offers for Bird Brain - Guy Kennaway »

1 to 1 out of 1 similar offers for Bird Brain - Guy Kennaway
Guy Kennaway By Guy Kennaway Bird Brain

Guy Kennaway By Guy Kennaway Bird Brain

Hardcover, Jonathan Cape

 Visit Shop  >
Amazon Marketplace
Postage & Packaging:  refer to website
Availability:  refer to website

Product Information »

Product details

ISBN 978-0224093996

Show all Product Information

Review Ratings »

This review of Bird Brain - Guy Kennaway has been rated:

"very helpful" by (100%):

  2. Amazingwoo
  3. Coloneljohn

and 33 other members

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Are you the manufacturer / provider of Bird Brain - Guy Kennaway? Click here