Schmutzie 5

Schmutzie

Add to my Circle of Trust

Subscribe to reviews

About me:

Member since:01.01.1970

Reviews:126

Quote-start

Greek Without Tears

Quote-end
29.04.2003

Advantages:
You'll enjoy your holiday more

Disadvantages:
None

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Quality of Text

Interesting/Absorbing?

Logical Layout?

Relevance of Questions

Helpful?

PriceSee Amazon. Could be as low as £25.

Type of BookPractical

Level of DifficultyAverage

34 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful See ratings
very helpful by (100%):
  1. DavidJWest
  2. j_mcb
  3. hepialid
and 70 other members

View all ratings

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Share this review on Google+

WHY I WANTED TO LEARN GREEK
Iíd wanted for years to visit Greece. The history and literature of the country have been a passion of mine since I came across the Greek myths as a child. I longed to see Athens, and a few other famous places, but most of my pleasure in visiting another country lies in getting right off the tourist beats and meeting people, seeing how they really live.

By choice I usually travel on my own, and after a terrifying experience some years ago in Russia I decided that Iíd never go anywhere again unless I spoke enough of the language to cope with problems. Greece seemed an impossible dream, as I was incapable of learning Greek. There was only one problem, but it was a fundamental one: the alphabet. Because of the rather strange form of dyslexia from which I suffer I could not get to grips with it at all.

Ironically, I can offer tips galore to anyone else trying to do so, including using flashcards, learning two or three symbols a day, transposing the Greek into your own system of phonetics, diving in head first, plenty of other methods. Oh, I could teach it. But no way on earth could I learn it. I tried to follow the BBCís Greek Language and People course on TV, and bought the book. The course is so unspeakably bad that I was almost put off for life. I bought Teach Yourself Greek, a very sound if dull book, but no solution to the alphabet problem. I had the Talk Now! CD, and was doing well with vocabulary and pronunciation. But I still couldnít really get anywhere because of the alphabet.

A BREAKTHROUGH
Two years ago I picked up Breakthrough Greek in my local bookshop, and all my problems were solved. This course uses a simple system of reproducing the Greek words in our alphabet, so that you can read them as easily as if they are the English they resemble; and with the help of the cassettes you can do very well.

Kalimera= good morning.Ya sas=hello. Epharisto= thank you.

I could do this ! Really excited, I bought the whole pack, book and three audiotapes for £27.99 on Amazon. The full price is £39.99, but itís worth it.
The book is a paperback, well set out, with black and white photographs and sketches. (More recent editions of the courses in this series have colour illustrations). Itís nothing like the wonderful presentation of Italianissimo, but itís quite good enough for the price. The layout is spacious, and the lessons could not be improved upon.

THE APPROACH WHICH SUITED ME
I had five months in which to learn, and I approached Greek in a way novel for me. As a rule I am a great believer in learning languages in a formal way, with a thorough study of grammar. I think this is essential for any serious student of languages, including our own. A knowledge of English grammar is a must for all professional writers. After all, if you know how a language works you can use it more efficiently and subtly, and know exactly what you are doing. Iím often amused and pleased that the grammar in a salacious article in The Sun is just as sound as a staid piece in The Times.

I saw at once that the formal approach would not get me as far ahead as I needed to be, for the grammar is not easy with all the cases of some of the parts of speech to learn, and three genders of nouns. I decided to go for the Ďdirect methodí, learning as many useful phrases as possible, and hoping to be able to adapt them. This worked well, and the layout of the lessons helps.
We can have a look at the first lesson, and youíll see that at once you have some very useful material.

HOW EACH CHAPTER WORKS
On the left page are three mini-dialogues, which consist of simple greetings, and asking how someone is. On the right are notes, which you could miss out if you wished. I didnít. Itís all easy.
When you can say these phrases, you go on to the next page. Two more mini-dialogues, saying Ďexcuse meí, saying where youíre from.
The next set says youíre from the UK, there on holiday, and allows you to ask and give names.

Thatís all you have to learn in chapter one, but already you have the basis for a simple introductory conversation with a Greek.
All the dialogues are on the tapes, and are spoken by Greeks. Thereís also a guide, who gives you tips in English. Both his English and his Greek are so good that itís impossible to tell his nationality.

The little dialogues are followed by a list of the key words and phrases. I tested myself, by covering first the column in Greek, and then the other in English. Written practice comes next, simple multiple choice questions in English to test your comprehension, and a little crossword puzzle.
Using the tape, you listen and you tick boxes for more multiple choices. Itís all made lively by amusing little sketches to help you. The exercises are kept short, and little writing is necessary.

Thereís a section on grammar, which you could skip. The exercises there are more formal, but I enjoyed them, and found that without at first realising it I was learning a lot of the grammar. In this chapter, it was the key verbs ĎI amí and ĎI doí. (There is no infinitive form in Greek).
The Greek alphabet is taught letter by letter. In this chapter itís K and A which I did manage to learn because they are the same in English !
Then thereís a short article ĎDid You Know?í with facts about life in Greece, and its history.
Finally, you do oral work with the tape.
You can see that the chapter is packed with things to learn, things to do, and information; but take my word for it that you donít feel in the least overwhelmed. Everything is presented in tiny Ďbitesí, itís all well spaced out, and thereís no feeling of pressure or information overkill at all.
You should find no problems with pronunciation. There is a guttural sound which may be unfamiliar, but if you know the Spanish Ďjí and the Ďchí in the Scottish Ďlochí you wonít find it difficult. The intonation is not dissimilar to English.

WHAT YOU WILL HAVE LEARNED BY THE END OF THE BOOK
All subsequent chapters follow the same pattern. Indeed, all the language books in the Breakthrough series have this pattern. Itís very effective. By the time Iíd finished the course, just before I was to visit Greece, I realised that Iíd learned an enormous amount. There were practical things :
Ordering food and drink; getting tourist information and directions; going shopping; telling the time; travel arrangements, hotel bookings and enquiries.
Less practical but equally useful in getting along with the Greeks: talk about yourself and your job; give opinions about things; ask people about their lives; talk about families.

How would it all work out in practice?
Wonderfully well is the answer. The proof of the usefulness of any language course is how it all works when you come to use it.

I TRY IT OUT
When I can speak a language, thereís a huge thrill in speaking it for the first time when Iím on holiday, even if itís one Iíve spoken for years. With a new one, the thrill is so intense itís almost erotic. Iíve never been nervous, as I discovered long ago that people like you for having a go, however stumbling your efforts. (Well, thatís been true of all the countries in Europe Iíve been to except oneÖÖ..but in the interests of peace I wonít say which. Iíve been corrected and lectured there several times over minor errors.)

Even in the bustle of Athens, faces lit up when I spoke in Greek, this beautiful language. Off the beaten track the reception I got was wonderful. Two lovely memories of many remain in my mind. In a tiny village in Crete, I was thirsty and walked into a cafť for a coffee. Everyone fell silent. As my eyes got used to the darkness in there after the blazing sunshine, I realised I was in a Ďmen onlyí establishment. They were staring, though not in a hostile way, just surprised.
"Excuse me, sirs," I said. "I did not understand. Men only. I shall go now. Good day to you."
Several jumped to their feet, and huge smiles spread like lightening.
"Lady, lady, come in. Welcome !"
I was there for over an hour, and had a delightful time chatting and joking with all the old chaps.

A few days later I visited a small pottery in a village near Rhodes. I was looking at some beautiful mugs, far too expensive for me, when a man said in broken English. "You want buy heem?"
"Very beautiful, " I said, "but too dear for me."
He continued in Greek. "Why do you speak our language ?"
"Because itís beautiful, and so is Greece."
"I am giving you these mugs."
"You are kind and gracious."
I was then kissed and hugged by all the workers in the pottery, and given coffee with tiny cakes. Itís this sort of thing which makes learning a language worth while.
The course had equipped me to cope very well with all the different situations I encountered.

GIVE YOURSELF TIME TO GET ACCLIMATISED
Greek has a lot of dialects, and both pronunciation and some vocabulary can vary a lot from island to island. It was not a problem. They are a polite and friendly race, and a request for them to repeat something or slow down usually brought results. It certainly need not put anyone off. In any case, and this is true of any language, if you persevere, after a few days you get an Ďearí, and it all becomes easier.

****************************

The course did me proud, What I couldnít do was read signs, or any printed matter, but I had my trusty Rough Guide Greek Phrasebook with the alphabet in it, and ran into no problems with things like street signs and timetables. Most people would have no difficulty learning the alphabet from the way the book presents it.
I recommend this excellent course. Iíve had a quick look at the German, Spanish and French ones in the series and can see that they are equally sound. All are very well presented, very practical and fun to use. They do not have the glamour of Italianissimo, but at that price you donít expect it.

Going to Greece this year ? Ask me, or steveuk, if you want to know more. He speaks fluent Greek.
More useful books : Rough Guide, Greece; Lonely Planet, Greece; Rough Guide Greek Phrasebook.

© Schmutzie 2003


  Write your own review

Share this review on Google+

 

Rate this review »

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

Rate as exceptional

Rate as somewhat helpful

Rate as very helpful

Rate as not helpful

Rate as helpful

Rate as off topic

Write your own review Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful. Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful.   Report a problem with this reviewís content

Comments about this review »

j_mcb 08.07.2003 02:20

This sounds like a beautiful language to learn. It was great to hear the reaction you got from the Greeks when you spoke their language! They seem extremely friendly. A fantastic opinion! Joe

hepialid 20.06.2003 22:05

Sounds like an effective and enjoyable way to learn. I wonder, do they do a similar series for other languages? Andy.

Worrals 20.06.2003 12:15

Wow, sounds as though you learned a lot. I generally crib enough phrases to cope with ordering from menus and asking for toilets, but you were having proper conversations!

Add your comment

max. 2000 characters

Post comment

Similar offers for Breakthrough Greek »

1 to 2 out of 2 similar offers for Breakthrough Greek
Breakthrough Greek (Breakthrough Language Courses) - Eleni Gambarotta

Breakthrough Greek (Breakthrough Language Courses) - Eleni Gambarotta

Pages: 240, Edition: New edition, Paperback, Palgrave Macmillan

 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace books
Postage & Packaging:  £2.80
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...

The Incomplete Breakthrough in Greek-Turkish Relations: Grasping Greece's Socialization Strategy - Dr Panayotis Tsakonas

The Incomplete Breakthrough in Greek-Turkish Relations: Grasping Greece's Socialization Strategy - Dr Panayotis Tsakonas

This methodical analysis of Greece's strategy towards Turkey highlights important new ... more

findings about the role particular elements of a
state's strategic culture play in explaining major
and/or minor shifts in strategy. The book breaks
new ground in exploring when and how states
develop socialization strategies.

 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace books
Postage & Packaging:  £2.80
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...

Review Ratings Ľ

This review of Breakthrough Greek has been rated:

"very helpful" by (100%):

  1. DavidJWest
  2. j_mcb
  3. hepialid

and 70 other members

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Breakthrough Greek? Click here