A gadget junkie who believe reviews should be accurate for the consumer, not beneficial for the prod...
A gadget junkie who believe reviews should be accurate for the consumer, not beneficial for the producer. Oh cosmic! looks like you're all pis**d at me already - let the public disembowelling begin!
Member since:10.05.2007
Reviews:7
The Canon XL2 is the pro-sumer miniDV camcorder that is most often spotted on the sets of low budget and independent films. Not because it is a cheap option, but because for a fraction of the cost of a professional rig, you can deliver the same results.
SOME OF THE MORE IMPORTANT SPECS: 1/3" Progressive Scan 3CCD image sensor PAL & NTSC versions available TTL Autofocus and Manual focus ring 20x optical zoom Min focus distance 20mm on wide macro Min illumination 60i, 1/60 shutter speed = 5.5lux Filter Diameter 72mm Viewfinder 2.0 inch TFT colour LCD (200,000 pixels) Microphone stereo electric condenser plus 2xXLR ports Total Pixels 16:9 460,000 (962x480), 4:3 350,000 (720x480) DV out is IEEE1394/mini Firewire connection Video out is 4pin mini-DIN Dimensions 225x220x496mm weight 7.8lbs with lens and battery
If you're looking to get high quality picture definition from your camcorder
then nothing short of 3CCD will do, but once you get onto the 3CCD rung, you will realize the ladder goes much higher than you needed to climb.
Working as a semi-professional cameraman I have used everything from hidden pincams right up to Broadcast Digibeta rigs as well as underwater cameras and the relevant housings they require, and I would confidently say that if you are a non/semi professional looking for a high quality DV format camcorder for recording family/events then you will not be disappointed by the clarity, image sharpness and excellent colour reproduction of the XL2.
Loaded with the usual features found on other high endcameras: Optical image stabilization, dual aspect ratios, gamma adjust, frame rate adjust, all manual mode - BUT where it leaves ALL its competitors standing is the fantastic inclusion of the XL Mount Interchangeable lens system.
This has to be THE selling point for this camera, which is a shame as all the other features are strong enough to make this a market contender anyway. By changing the lens you achieve a flexibility that is unprecedented in consumer video electronics. There are four main lenses: the 20x OIS, 16xOIS, 16xManual and wide, but with the XL system adapter you suddenly have the entire range of Canon photographic lenses at your fingertips, a necessity for specialist shooting like nature documentary and astrological study. However, it is important to remember that the lens is probably the most expensive part of a modern camera, so this coupled with the high quality of Canon lensesin general, could lead to an expensive sink for the gadget hungry director.
If like most end users you plan to keep this on full auto and 'hose' it around you could probably get the same results with a cheaper option (the Canon XM2 springs to mind). But if you're a budding film maker or a photographic perfectionist then this model really allows you to take control of every aspect of the camera. From shutter speed to aperture you can create your look actually inside the camera.
Through your eyepiece you have easy line of sight to the 2.0 inch colour LCD viewfinder, accompanied by record, shutter and gain indicator lights, with optional on-screen metering for audio and light (very handy!). Flipping up the viewfinder exposes the 2inch LCD screen for use away from the eye, and the whole viewfinder unit can be moved back and forth to accommodate your size exactly while shoulder mounting the camera (lets hope you're right handed!). In fact the built in shoulder cushion makes the camera actually feel nice to use.
The button placement seemed intuitive, although possibly a little fiddly when trying to make adjustments in a hurry. The external XLR sockets with phantom power make for very easy use of professional close mics that will plug directly in to left or right channel which have their own individual level switches.
Watching the footage back you would be forgiven for thinking that you're watching HD, but you're not. In fact even though Canon actually helped to define the HDV standard, this is still SD (standard definition) which has a severly limited shelf life in the fast moving world of technologies, but was an essential choice for the manufacturers who wanted to make all of Canons SD lenses useable.
Also, it is important to remember that you will only get high quality playback if you shoot high quality footage. As with all professional rigs it can be very unforgiving in the areas of exposure, focus and colour replication if you don't white balance it as well as focus and light properly for your shots. Remember 5.5 lux is not as dark as you'd think, and many other cameras can outperform the XL2 in low light situations (the Sony PD170 for example).
In summary: Outstanding colour reproduction, clarity and customizable options. Very versatile if used with additional lenses. Comfortable to use (though at 7.8 lbs you might want to invest in a tripod for extended use) Pro styling makes you look the part Built in XLR
REALLY THE BEST IN ITS CLASS - but not for the amateur who wants to 'point-and-press', save yourself some money and try the XM2 instead.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Regardless of how often Ciao post a product, multiple reviews are prohibited by their T+C. So the error is yours.
gnipping 11.05.2007 16:13
Good grief Penfold!
So you feel it necessary to then go to and replicate the same comment on each of those reviews in order to make sure I get the point - sheesh!
I have emailed ciao and asked them for advice on this matter, it would seem that the error is ciaos for multiple listing of the product, but who's pointing fingers.
Glad to help make you feel better about yourselves today .. may I suggest that tomorrow you try sit-ups?
DigitalMini DVNTSC3 x CCD 20.0 X optical zoom 5.3 lbProduct DescriptionCanon\'s new XL2 ... more
camcorder offers an evolutionary design and new professional features - including a choice of 60i- 24p or 30p frame rates- 4:3 or high resolution 16:9 aspect ratio-...
Advantages: Interchageable lens system, 2xXLR inputs built in, adjustable viewfinder position Disadvantages: Not good for low light performance, bulky when compared to consumer units, not HD
Advantages: Interchageable lens system, 2xXLR inputs built in, adjustable viewfinder position Disadvantages: Not good for low light performance, bulky when compared to consumer units, not HD
May 10th, 2007
not helpful by (100%):
