Similar offers
Postage & Packaging: Check Site.
Postage & Packaging: Check Site.
Postage & Packaging: Check Site.
Quote-start

The Canon PIXMA IP1800 and the end of the world

Quote-end

5 Sep 14th, 2007 

26 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Cheap and replaceable .  Attractive and efficient technology .

Disadvantages:
Ink costs more than the machine .  Potential ecological mayhem .

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Picture quality

Printing speed

Colour sensitivity

Ease of use

Value For Money

FlameDruid

FlameDruid

About me:

Member since:06.09.2004

Reviews:90

Members who trust:36

My new Canon PIXMA IP1800 replaces my Canon PIXMA IP1600 so the planet may be doomed and It could be my fault.

My Canon PIXMA IP1600 had nothing wrong with it. It wasn't broken. The pictures spilled out on glossy paper at A4 ready for framing. The text was crisp and black. I'd had it for a year or so. It was cheap yet efficient and as good as any printer I'd ever owned. It had no tray to catch paper coming out but otherwise was printing perfectly and I've been delighted with it. This is partly why I bought the Canon PIXMA IP1800 which is also excellent. But why bother? They're almost the same machine!

The ink is running out on my old printer and, bizarrely, new cartridges would cost more than a brand new one. My wife was furious.

She looked at the packets of ink cartridges with a shop assistant because she didn't believe me when I told her this.

'The ink costs more than a new printer? That's ridiculous! I'm offended as an environmentalist and....'

This seemed like an extravagant claim to me so I went off to look at games. When I came back my wife was still on her tirade, telling this unfortunate young lady what she thought. She thought it was all very well for the government to push laws at us all making us recycle. She thought it was fine and dandy to make us put all our tins and bottles in plastic boxes to be picked up by moralising binmen. She thought a carbon footprint was an abomination and that pricing ink above the cost of a new printer could only lead to a new ice age.

Let's leave her in full flow and take a short walk to where her voice is merely a soft roar in the distance and consider the logic beneath her rant. She's right you know. It flies in the face of the government's current enthusiasm for saving the planet from global warming for customers to be encouraged in this way to throw away their perfectly good Canon PIXMA IP1600s just to save money.

My opinion differs slightly from hers though I'd never dare tell her. I think that there's a huge international scam going on. Here's my conspiracy theory of printers: I think manufacturers - some more than others - are selling us lovely cheap printers but ink that appears to be made of liquid gold. I had an HP printer years ago that also did everything I wanted and sold it to a friend in order to get another make. This was because the ink for that brand of printer cost much more than it did for Epson or Canon, in particular. That is, in point of fact, why I started buying Canon printers in the first place.

Printers have come on a lot since the rotating bonky wheel on the old Amstrad 8512 and 9512 PCW machines, and the grating whirring of the dot-matrix models of old. In performance terms my own layman's opinion is that you now get fabulous text and pictures out of modern printers so quality - unless you have very particular and discerning professional needs and eyes a lot better than my old eyes - isn't a major question. As my son would say, 'It's all good.'

The truth is that I'm delighted my new printer is black because my keyboard, PC and home-studio gear and even my clock, are black. That means it looks better than the Canon PIXMA IP1600 which is designed to match old beige PC equipment. It's a reliable printer that can produce clear A4 photos and crisp black text. It didn't matter to me that it wasn't supplied with a USB lead for connecting it to my computer because I just pulled my existing one out of the Canon PIXMA IP1600 and stuck it in the Canon PIXMA IP1800. If you are buying one from scratch, of course, it might matter to you as you'll have to pay for a USB lead.

Technical things like: "4,800x1,200dpi" don't mean a lot to me. That's how many dots per inch it can do. A photo looks like a photo - that's all that matters for my purposes. A review I was looking at just now thought it was quite a slow printer. It takes a couple of minutes for an A4 print of a picture. Is that a long time? I'm not a newspaper or a magazine publisher on a deadline. I used to take my Brownie to the chemist and they took days to print my tiny, blurred, monochrome snaps. I can live with two minutes for a clear-as-a-bell A4 colour picture, thanks very much.

Many of these factors, information and preconceptions may have informed my decision but the fact is that this is a really good printer for less than the cost of ink replacement.

However, you may agree with my wife as they scrape her off the ceiling of PCWorld that people shouldn't throw away printers just to save a few pounds. Well I can't say this too loudly in case she hears me but anyone whose ever seen a herd of mad women charge a jumble sale as soon as the doors open (or even before) will back me up on this point: we all like a bargain. We don't think it's big or clever to pay a few pounds more for a printer when we can get it cheaper. Pray for our lost souls or quote Marx if you see fit but mostly people like to get the best deal they can.

If you buy one you're going to have to face the same decision. When that ink runs out will you go and buy ink cartridges that cost three or four pounds more than a new printer that comes with ink included, or will you take your perfectly good Canon PIXMA IP1800 to the tip?

Although the death of the planet may be hastened by the weird pricing policies I've outlined here that make us into wanton and evil consumers, the good news is that this range of printers is super value. A budget printer like this would have been £80 easily five years ago. Now you can get one for around £26.50. That's good news for consumers though not so great for the survival of life on the planet. In fact, the ink for Canon printers hasn't gone up significantly in price. It just hasn't matched the falling price of the machines.

I leave it to your conscience to decide about the Canon PIXMA IP1800. The price is so competitive I bought one rather than get ink for my existing printer. Then again, take out some of my florid hyperbole and my acount of my wife's rant at PCWorld on the matter was real. No, honestly. She did.

Do you go want to save the planet or get a great, cheap printer - now available in black and as cheap as chips?

An important alternative to the official ink cartridges are the cheap compatible ones available. I've just Googled this and found that if you go this route you can order very cheap refills - some at around a fiver each. That's much better.

Still, be aware that an infrequently used printer can be destroyed by the use of cheap alternative ink. It can dry in the print head causing streaking in printouts. I've had it happen and even though I bought a special cleaner cartridge, nothing helped. Some printers have cartridges with a print head built into them but in the Canon IP range they're fitted into the machine and cost too much to be worth replacing.

The Canon PIXMA IP1800 gives you great pictures and text at a super-budget price. 'Proper' ink is as expensive as buying a new machine but cheap alternative ink is available. Even if the worst happens, when the machine is only £26.50, (and despite what my wife may tell you), it isn't going to be the end of the world. 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Canon PIXMA iP4700

Canon PIXMA iP4700

Digital Photo Printer - Inkjet - Colour: 9600 dpi - x 2400 dpi - Direct print USB, USB

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 78.15

HP Color LaserJet CP1215

HP Color LaserJet CP1215

Workgroup Printer - Laser - Black: 600 dpi - x 600 dpi - Colour: 600 dpi - x 600 dpi - USB

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 125.00

Canon PIXMA iP3600

Canon PIXMA iP3600

Digital Photo Printer, Photo printer - Inkjet - Colour: 9600 dpi - x 2400 dpi - USB, Direct print USB

User reviews (2)

Buy now for only £ 55.99

HP Color LaserJet CP1515n

HP Color LaserJet CP1515n

Workgroup Printer - Laser - Black: 600 dpi - x 600 dpi - Colour: 600 dpi - x 600 dpi - Ethernet 10/100Base-TX, USB

User reviews (5)

Buy now for only £ 158.75

Canon PIXMA iP2600

Canon PIXMA iP2600

Digital Photo Printer - Inkjet - Colour: 4800 dpi - x 1200 dpi - USB

User reviews (2)

Buy now for only £ 33.82

HP LaserJet P1005

HP LaserJet P1005

Workgroup Printer - Laser - Black: 1200 dpi - x 1200 dpi - USB

User reviews (3)

Buy now for only £ 59.00

Comments about this review »

Pittypomm 15.03.2008 11:34

I'm trying to replace my Epson photo printer at the moment. We chose epson originally because the ink was cheaper, but now we have a broken printer and a huge stack of ink cartridges. I am a bit annoyed that the new Epsons now have 8 different colour cartridges and not 6, so if I want the latest printer, I have to find someone to give all this ink to...

Expired-Account 05.10.2007 07:59

I'll stick with my HP printer but this does sound good, very helpful

jesi 18.09.2007 05:50

We've still got our Olivettii JP192 with its expensive cartriidges (even when bought from inkfactory.com) because th computer takes a standard (pre-usb) connnection cable ~ we also have a lexmark 3-in-1 machine never used because nowhere to handle it . . . ~ ! ♥♥ ! ~ ........................................................... ~ jes ~ ! ♥♥ !

Similar offers for Canon PIXMA iP1800 »

1 to 10 out of 33 similar offers for Canon PIXMA iP1800 Show all similar offers
Canon Pixma iP1800 Twin Pack Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridges - (High Capacity Version)

Canon Pixma iP1800 Twin Pack Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridges - (High Capacity Version)

Twin pack PG40 and CL41 remanufactured Canon printer ink cartridges. These cartridges are ... more

high capacity cartridges which have been filled
with 24ml (Colour) and 26ml (Black) of ink
compared with 12ml (Colour) and 16ml (Black) that
you get with the original cartridges.  Compatible
with: Canon MultiPass MP150, MP160, MP170, Canon
Pixma iP1200, iP1300, iP1600, iP1700, iP1800,
iP2200, iP2400, iP2500, iP2600, MP140, MP150,
MP160, MP170, MP180, MP210, MP220, MP450, MP460,
MP470, Canon MX300, MX310


Postage & Packaging:  Check Site.
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days......
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace electronics
Canon Pixma iP1800 Black Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridge - (High Capacity Version)

Canon Pixma iP1800 Black Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridge - (High Capacity Version)

Black PG40 remanufactured Canon printer ink cartridge. This cartridge is a high capacity ... more

cartridge which has been filled with 26ml of ink
compared with the 16ml (Black) that you get with
the originals.  Compatible with: Canon Pixma
iP1800


Postage & Packaging:  Check Site.
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days......
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace electronics
Canon Pixma iP1800 Tri Colour Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridge - (High Capacity Version)

Canon Pixma iP1800 Tri Colour Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridge - (High Capacity Version)

Tri-Colour CL41 remanufactured Canon printer ink cartridge. This cartridge is a high ... more

capacity cartridge which has been filled with 24ml
of ink compared with 12ml (Colour) that you get
with the originals.  Compatible with: Canon Pixma
iP1800


Postage & Packaging:  Check Site.
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days......
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace electronics
Canon Pixma iP1800 Twin Pack Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridges - (High Capacity Version)

Canon Pixma iP1800 Twin Pack Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridges - (High Capacity Version)

Twin pack PG40 and CL41 remanufactured Canon printer ink cartridges. These cartridges are ... more

high capacity cartridges which have been filled
with 24ml (Colour) and 26ml (Black) of ink
compared with 12ml (Colour) and 16ml (Black) that
you get with the original cartridges.  Compatible
with: Canon MultiPass MP150, MP160, MP170, Canon
Pixma iP1200, iP1300, iP1600, iP1700, iP1800,
iP2200, iP2400, iP2500, iP2600, MP140, MP150,
MP160, MP170, MP180, MP210, MP220, MP450, MP460,
MP470, Canon MX300, MX310


Postage & Packaging:  Check Site.
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon electronics
Canon Pixma iP1800 Black Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridge - (High Capacity Version)

Canon Pixma iP1800 Black Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridge - (High Capacity Version)

Black PG40 remanufactured Canon printer ink cartridge. This cartridge is a high capacity ... more

cartridge which has been filled with 26ml of ink
compared with the 16ml (Black) that you get with
the originals.  Compatible with: Canon Pixma
iP1800


Postage & Packaging:  Check Site.
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon electronics
Canon Pixma iP1800 Tri Colour Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridge - (High Capacity Version)

Canon Pixma iP1800 Tri Colour Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridge - (High Capacity Version)

Tri-Colour CL41 remanufactured Canon printer ink cartridge. This cartridge is a high ... more

capacity cartridge which has been filled with 24ml
of ink compared with 12ml (Colour) that you get
with the originals.  Compatible with: Canon Pixma
iP1800


Postage & Packaging:  Check Site.
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon electronics
Canon Pixma iP1800 Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridge - Tri-Colour

Canon Pixma iP1800 Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridge - Tri-Colour

Tri-Colour CL-38 remanufactured Canon printer ink cartridge. This cartridge is a high ... more

capacity cartridge which has been filled with 12ml
of ink compared with 9ml (Colour) that you get
with the originals.  Compatible with: Canon Pixma
MP190 iP1800 iP1900 iP2500 iP2600 MP140 MP210
MP220 MP470 MX300 MX310


Postage & Packaging:  Check Site.
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon electronics
Canon Pixma iP1800 Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridge - Tri-Colour

Canon Pixma iP1800 Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridge - Tri-Colour

Tri-Colour CL-38 remanufactured Canon printer ink cartridge. This cartridge is a high ... more

capacity cartridge which has been filled with 12ml
of ink compared with 9ml (Colour) that you get
with the originals.  Compatible with: Canon Pixma
MP190 iP1800 iP1900 iP2500 iP2600 MP140 MP210
MP220 MP470 MX300 MX310


Postage & Packaging:  Check Site.
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace electronics
Canon Pixma iP1800 Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridges - Black and Tri-Colour Twin Pack

Canon Pixma iP1800 Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridges - Black and Tri-Colour Twin Pack

Tri-Colour CL-38 and PG-37 Black remanufactured Canon printer ink cartridges. These ... more

cartridges are a high capacity cartridges which
are filled with 12ml of ink compared with 9ml that
you get with the originals.  Compatible with:
Canon Pixma MP190 iP1800 iP1900 iP2500 iP2600
MP140 MP210 MP220 MP470 MX300 MX310


Postage & Packaging:  Check Site.
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon electronics
Canon Pixma iP1800 Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridges - Black and Tri-Colour Twin Pack

Canon Pixma iP1800 Remanufactured Printer Ink Cartridges - Black and Tri-Colour Twin Pack

Tri-Colour CL-38 and PG-37 Black remanufactured Canon printer ink cartridges. These ... more

cartridges are a high capacity cartridges which
are filled with 12ml of ink compared with 9ml that
you get with the originals.  Compatible with:
Canon Pixma MP190 iP1800 iP1900 iP2500 iP2600
MP140 MP210 MP220 MP470 MX300 MX310


Postage & Packaging:  £2.92
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace electronics


More reviews »

Canon PIXMA iP1800 - review by pchenn

Advantages: Fast printing and great picture colour.
Disadvantages: Cartridge and printing roll.

Canon PIXMA iP1800 - review by pchenn pchenn 04.08.2008 (04.08.2008) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: off topic
Review of Canon PIXMA iP1800

Canon PIXMA iP1800 - review by pdmg

Advantages: Excellent text
Disadvantages: No paper tray!

Canon PIXMA iP1800 - review by pdmg pdmg 17.07.2008 (25.07.2008) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Canon PIXMA iP1800

Canon PIXMA iP1800 - review by alexloukakis

Advantages: Value for money, design
Disadvantages: Size, no paper tray

Canon PIXMA iP1800 - review by alexloukakis alexloukakis 11.11.2007 (13.11.2007) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Canon PIXMA iP1800

Canon PIXMA iP1800 - review by traveller10

Advantages: Photo lab quality at a low price
Disadvantages: None that I could see

Canon PIXMA iP1800 - review by traveller10 traveller10 24.05.2007 (29.05.2007) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Canon PIXMA iP1800

Canon PIXMA iP1800 - review by alifuzzaman

Advantages: Excellent printing quality, fast printing...
Disadvantages: No paper tray.... nothin else..

Canon PIXMA iP1800 - review by alifuzzaman alifuzzaman 20.06.2008 (20.06.2008) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: somewhat helpful
Review of Canon PIXMA iP1800



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Canon PIXMA iP1800? Click here