MALU 5

MALU

Add to my Circle of Trust

Subscribe to reviews

About me: ****** THANK YOU IN ADVANCE FOR YOUR **E** RATINGS. ******

Member since:04.07.2002

Reviews:438

Members who trust:176

Quote-start

Wonder Worms

Quote-end
04.05.2011

Advantages:
a mixture of personal experience and background information

Disadvantages:
none

Detailed rating:

How useful was it?

Would you read it again?

Degree of InformationVery high

How easy was it to read / get information fromVery easy

How interesting was the book?Compelling

Value for moneyGood

31 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful See ratings
exceptional by (13%):
  1. garymarsh86
  2. Marge3781
  3. Kirsty1
and a further member
very helpful by (87%):
  1. KathEv
  2. torr
  3. chrisandmark_is_here
and 24 other members

View all ratings

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Share this review on Google+

A graduate of medicine is likely to become a physician, a graduate of physics is likely to become a physicist, a graduate of mass communication, however, is likely not to know what kind of job they’ll end up with. A gap year is a good thing for the undecided, the ones without job offers or the merely adventurous. For Christopher Aslan Alexander all three options may have applied, he doesn’t elaborate on the reasons why he moved to Khiva, a desert oasis in the Central Asian state of Usbekistan as a volunteer for the Swedish NGO Operation Mercy. He was to stay there for two years to write an online guidebook on this UNESCO heritage site and to help blind children in a local institution. The two years stretched into seven, but when he was seriously thinking of settling down and perhaps getting married, he was refused a return visa after holidaying in Aserbaijan. He was never given a reason, but he suspected the mayor of Khiva had pulled some strings when he didn’t get four silk carpets as ‘presents’.

Silk carpets? For the first months Chris lived with a Swedish couple and their children in crowded conditions. He decided to move out, Koranbeg, an Usbek with ’contacts’ he had met by chance invited him to stay in his house until he’d find accommodation for him. This never happened. Chris was ‘adopted’ by the Usbeks, they became his ersatz family. His host and his brother Madrim renovated ancient wooden ceilings, Chris was fascinated by this traditional craft and from there it was only a small step to traditional Usbek silk carpets. Once the pride of the ton of Khiva the craft was seemingly dead and Chris and Madrim set out to revive it with the financial support of UNESCO.

The long forgotten art of dyeing with natural colours, finding, traditional designs, turning them into ‘wearable’ patterns, finding weavers capable of turning them into high quality carpets and last but not least selling them profitably became the focus of Chris’ life in Khiva.

If one has to label A Carpet Ride To Khiva the category travelogue comes to mind. Yet, if this is defined by a protagonist moving from one exotic place to the next and recounting their adventures along the route, then the book is not typical, it’s more than that. Chris does travel, his search for natural dyes takes him across Usbekistan along the so-called Silk Road and even to Afghanistan, but travelling is not what he’s really interested in, staying is. He wants to understand his host society, their customs and habits and adapt to them as far as possible without giving up his own beliefs.

The book doesn’t fall into the category ex-pat lit, either. I’ve read several specimens of this genre and remember always feeling slightly aggressive towards the authors who think that buying and renovating a derelict house, getting to know some neighbours and bumming if off on their hospitality in some Southern European country means being integrated. I’ve warmed to Christopher Aslan Alexander immediately, though, who btw got his Tuzrkish middle name because he was born in Turkey. Some of the living conditions, the age old customs, the current habits of the Usbeks and the human rights violations in the country are outrageous from an average European point of view, nevertheless he never feels superior and is never in danger of patronising anyone. One mustn’t forget that he’s an odd one from an Usbek point of view, tall, blond, pale, bespectacled, a vegetarian who hardly drinks any alcohol, not circumcised, without an inclination towards ‘bad women’ or donkeys. He seem to be guided by a firm Christian belief of helping thy neighbour, but he doesn’t proselytise. When he sees the possibility of improvement, he suggests it politely and is happy with the people if they succeed.

The book is partly a manual on carpet weaving as this is Chris’ main occupation. It’s clear that the reader learns a lot about it. I now know about the importance of madder, I’ve also got close insight into the breeding of silk worms (Usbekistan is the third most important country concerning the production of silk after India and China), a repulsive and fascinating affair at the same time.

A Carpet Ride to Khiva can also be read as a contribution for the discussion on foreign aid. Chris’ experience is proof that it is possible to improve living conditions - provided local politics support the effort.

Most interesting for me is the information on post-Soviet Usbekistan, a country between Marx and Mohammed according to Chris. It became independent in 1991 and has been under the brutal dictatorship of Islam Karimov ever since. What has remained of the Soviet influence in every day life, in state politics? How strong is the influence of Islam in modern day Usbekistan? They have found an own way in some respects. One example: when Saudi Arabia financed the building of a mosque and Saudi representatives came to celebrate the inauguration, they were deeply shocked when scarcely clad young women served vodka to the guests. Corruption is an all-pervading theme, if one isn’t subjected to it, one can read the story about policemen who rent their uniforms to friends so that they can collect bribes from drivers for breaching traffic regulations (for example, by wearing a seat-belt!) as an anecdote, if one has to deal with corruption day in , day out, things look different.

What has impressed me is how elegantly the author has woven (!) personal experiences together with factual information, his personal experience being the warp (the vertical threads that make up the backbone of a carpet) and factual information being the weft (the horizontal threads that weave between the warp threads). I’ve always been interested in Usbekistan because the most beautiful Islamic architecture of the world can be found there, in the towns of Samarkand and Bukhara. Sadly, it‘s also a country with outrageous human rights violations. Now I‘ve got some insight how people live far away from the capital Tashkent, I‘m grateful for that.

In the last chapter the author informs the readers about his life after the expulsion from Usbekistan and ends with the sentence, “I’d love to write more about this, but it’s a new chapter, and first it needs to be lived.”

  Write your own review

Share this review on Google+

 

Rate this review »

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

Rate as exceptional

Rate as somewhat helpful

Rate as very helpful

Rate as not helpful

Rate as helpful

Rate as off topic

Write your own review Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful. Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful.   Report a problem with this review’s content

Comments about this review »

garymarsh86 16.07.2011 14:11

Superbly reviewed.

Marge3781 10.07.2011 11:47

Fascinating review

chrisandmark_is_here 10.07.2011 01:33

Sounds interesting. x

Add your comment

max. 2000 characters

  Post comment

Compare prices »

1 offer for A Carpet Ride To Khiva - Christopher Aslan Alexander   Sorted by: Price 

Product Information »

Product details

Subgenre Travel Writing
Continent Central Asia
EAN 9781848311497
ISBN 1848311494
Edition Paperback

Show all Product Information

Review Ratings »

This review of A Carpet Ride To Khiva - Christopher Aslan Alexander has been rated:

"exceptional" by (13%):

  1. garymarsh86
  2. Marge3781
  3. Kirsty1

and a further member

"very helpful" by (87%):

  1. KathEv
  2. torr
  3. chrisandmark_is_here

and 24 other members

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Products you might be interested in »

Badlands - Tony Wheeler

Badlands - Tony Wheeler

(+) Well written, engaging read of parts less travelled
(-) May think other countries more worthy of inclusion.

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 3.32

Big Earth - Russ Malkin

Big Earth - Russ Malkin

(+) Lots of picture, interesting, inspiring, easy to dip into
(-) Sometimes implies Russ has done something he hasn't, some photos in the wrong sections

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 10.19

Better Than Fiction - Lonely Planet

Better Than Fiction - Lonely Planet

(+) Many well written contributions
(-) The odd self-indulgent piece

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 3.98



Are you the manufacturer / provider of A Carpet Ride To Khiva - Christopher Aslan Alexander? Click here