Quote-start

A horror story of errors

Quote-end

1 Jul 14th, 2007 

12 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
International felxibility for your funds between uk and usa possible

Disadvantages:
Extremely poor customer service

Recommendable No:

Detailed rating:

Product package

Security and Privacy

jp7541

jp7541

About me:

Hi all - Hope you enjoy my reviews. I've been away from Ciao for almost 2 years, but now I'm back. F...

Member since:14.07.2007

Reviews:27

Members who trust:4

I opened up a citibank account because I shall be requiring the flexibility to tranfer funds easily between the UK and the US.

I now have the following accounts with citibank:
Flexisaver
Current Account
US Dollar Saving account
US Dollar currnet account

However, I experienced problems from day one of applying. Firstly I was informed that I could go to a Branch and open an account there. Although strictly true, the telephone operative who provided this information failed to mention that normally to see their personal bankers you require an appointment.

After making a special journey just to go to the bank and finidng this out, I ended up wasting approximately 3 hours waiting for a personal banker to become available.

Eventually once the account was open I received a call from the Personal Banker to say just this. I was provided with a sort code and account number so I could begin initiating the fund transfers to my new account.

Imagine my disbelief when these transfers were rejected and the funds had returned to their original account. Upon further investigation I discovered this was because before you can begin to fund your new citibank account you are supposed to contact them to activate it. Nowhere in the terms and conditions document for the account was this stated and I wasn't given this information by the personal banker who called me to inform me the account was open.

So now having lost a significant amount of money on interest whilst my funds were in transit, I proceed to activate my account. Your initial funding of the account, in order to activate it, can be done with a debit card. Unfortunately for me, the transaction failed due to the citibank computer system crashing. I was assured the transaction had failed and advised to call back later to try again. Upon my secong attempt later, the transaction was succesful.

Again, I found myself horrified as I discover that both transactions had been succesful in terms of funds being removed from my HSBC account, but only the second transaction being successful for these funds being credited to my new citibank account. They had effectively lost my first debit card payment into the account !!

This problem took numerous days to resolve. The call centre staff were unable to advise on how to proceed. I got different and conflicting advise on the different occasions I called them.It was only after I got HSBC to begin a trace of the funds that the money eventually turned up in my citibank account. ( All these transfers were five figure amounts)

Not once did I get an apology and nobody even suggested compensating me for the interest lost. The call centre operatives have no authority whatsoever, and can only carry out basic transactions. I found them poorly trained and very prone to errors. I once asked for an exchange rate quote for sterling to dollars and was given the wrong information. When I queried it with the operative, he argued with me and refused to re-check it. It was only when I spoke to his supervisor that I got the correct information.

Their internet services are adequate for simple transactions. However, with telephone banking I would only advise using them for simple balance queries. if you want to do something slightly more complex I advise either popping in to a UK branch or speaking to a call centre supervisor to carry it out. Don't trust the regular call centre operatives.

If you've not got bored hearing my 'horror' stories. Only bank with citibank if you need the flexibility they can provide between the UK and the USA. Otherwise save yourself the nightmare. 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Comments about this review »

shaaza 14.07.2007 21:16

wicked review..

pgn0 14.07.2007 21:01

Sounds like a force to be reckoned with, metaphorically speaking: not what you want when you need your money moved effortlessly and painlessly between UK and US accounts and thence between currencies... Surprising how few banks in the UK can deal efficiently and effectively with US$ transactions, too!

tac20 14.07.2007 20:55

Sounds a oain. Nice review x



More reviews »

Citibank Accounts - review by averagepunter

Advantages: Great Internet and Telephone Banking Service
Disadvantages: No High Street Presence

Citibank Accounts - review by averagepunter averagepunter 17.11.2002 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Citibank Accounts

Citibank Accounts - review by buono

Advantages: Convenient, VISA networ for free cash withdrawals, excellent phone and internet banking
Disadvantages: Only 3 branches in UK

Citibank Accounts - review by buono buono 19.03.2001 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Citibank Accounts

Citibank Accounts - review by mandyhaley

Advantages: Easy to use
Disadvantages: None

Citibank Accounts - review by mandyhaley mandyhaley 13.05.2001 (22.07.2001) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Citibank Accounts

Citibank Accounts - review by chriscole8

Advantages: Real time balances
Disadvantages: Appaling customer services, paying in arrangements

Citibank Accounts - review by chriscole8 chriscole8 24.11.2003 (02.12.2003) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: somewhat helpful
Review of Citibank Accounts

Citibank Accounts - review by marcellep2

Advantages: Free Telephone banking, Internet, £500 Overdraft
Disadvantages: No branches

Citibank Accounts - review by marcellep2 marcellep2 08.04.2008 (08.04.2008) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Citibank Accounts



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Citibank Accounts? Click here