Quote-start

C3 - Flawed Genius & Floored Accelerator Pedals

Quote-end

4 Aug 21st, 2003  (Aug 24th, 2003)

31 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Long distance ride comfort

Disadvantages:
Not so hot on corners, flimsy interior build

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Road Handling

Comfort

Features

Looks

BNibbles

BNibbles

About me:

I feel as if I'm in some hi-tech whirl at the moment, with a new phone, router, netbook and not to m...

Member since:08.10.2000

Reviews:478

Members who trust:178

I always approach the rental desk of my chosen holiday car hire company with a degree of disinterest bordering on resignation. After all, one of those brand-spanking new cars outside is never going to be turned over to me is it? I’ll probably get the two-year-old Anonymous-mobile that I’ve driven a hundred times before.

Not this year. Turning up at the Budget desk at Faro airport was a refreshing experience – well, the one hour wait wasn’t, but it was a Thursday, and apparently Thursdays are ‘Brits Hiring Villas’ days in these parts. I also seemed to be the only one in the queue without golf clubs!

So I’d paid my £259 for two weeks (ouch!), got my paperwork filled in and been handed some keys. The double chevrons gave away the manufacturer, i.e. Citroën, but I guess I just thought I’d be getting a basic Saxo, the ‘outgoing’ model.

Judging by the amount of luggage some golfing people were expecting to stuff in, maybe that should be a Paxo – stuff in, geddit?.

Therefore I was mildly surprised and pleased to find that I’d been given a two-month-old Citroën C3, and obviously one of fairly high specification. C3’s don’t flaunt GTi or SLX badges at the rear, so initially it was giving nothing away, although the colour-coded metallic silver (i.e. buggers to get scratched, and therefore just what every hire company needs!) bumpers tended to hint at something above base model.

BASIC DETAILS

The C3 is a five-door hatchback in the ‘Supermini’ bracket. It comes with a variety of engine sizes including a 1.1litre petrol version (ours) and a 1.4 litre oil burner. The petrol engine pushes out a modest 60 brake horse power, and this was to prove significant later, as the weather got steadily hotter, paralleling but surpassing the ‘phew what a scorcher’ days here in the UK by about 5 more degrees (C!).

EQUIPMENT LEVELS

The car was equipped with variable-rate power steering and basic air-conditioning, i.e. not climate control. It had four ‘real’ headlights, not the usual twin-filament bulbs, and the dip-beams are adjustable from within the car, as were the door mirrors. The front air dam was also home to a couple of halogen driving/fog lamps.

A factory-fitted alarm cum immobiliser was evident, although it never went off within my earshot so its efficacy is untested.

The stereo was a Clarion-sourced affair, no bad thing in my opinion, and had a single CD-player and FM stereo radio, upgradeable to a multi-player if needed. From a personal point of view, I’m much keener on ‘unique-fit’ equipment these days, whereas the Clarion machine was a standard E4 dashboard fitting, and therefore easier to rip-off and sell in a pub to a gullible punter who doesn’t know that it also needs the built-in dashboard display to work properly. It can also be controlled for volume and channel from the right steering column stalk.

NIFTY BITS

I’m including equipment that I’ve either not encountered before or at least not in a car like this. It goes without saying, that being a French car, a certain ‘verve’ has been put into the interior fitting design. Not that it’s particularly colourful, being three shades of grey with some matt-silver bits, more the way it’s toned in and with not a straight line on show.

Seats were trimmed in two-tone light grey velour whilst doors flirted with the dark side somewhat. Not the coolest of colours when it comes to leaving it in a sunny car park, but there was always that air-conditioning to come back to. Interior door handles, the facia vents and the gear knob were given the matt silver treatment as a bit of light relief.

Unusually, the front seats had central armrests that could be retracted when not wanted. They were not, however, height-adjustable. Any discrepancy between the two rests was down to the relative seat-back angle to which they were linked.

It’s funny how the little things matter so much isn’t? How much do I hate scraping wax off my windscreen from a season’s car park tickets? Quite a lot actually. Full mark then to Citroën for providing a clear plastic spring clip built into the windscreen gasket, so that tickets can just be pinioned there for the relevant period without recourse to waxy glue!

The ‘donger’ that ….err donged every time we went above 45 kph wasn’t too welcome until we realised that it can be turned off, or set to warn of any speed being exceeded, so I suppose it could be termed a ‘poor man’s cruise control’. I’ve come across this in a Beemer but never in a basic family car before.

Citroën have also put a lot of thought into load capacity. Many hatchbacks promise to be ‘mini estate cars’ only to let you down with a high load sill at the back, and an uneven load floor once the seats are folded. Not so the C3. Yes, it does have a high load sill, with a drop immediately the other side, but once you have filled this void with small bags, a sturdy cover, which has been nestling folded in two against the back seat, pulls down to cover the first layer of luggage, giving you an almost flat load bay from the bumper all the way to behind the front seat passengers. This we found was ideal for our suitcases after carry-on luggage had been stowed underneath.

The control binnacle was an eclectic mix of digital and analogue indicators. For instance, the speedo was a liquid crystal, as was the tripmeter, the fuel and temperature gauges were lit orange columns of hyphens and VERY ‘in your face’ In a semicircular arc around all this was an analogue tachometer (rev counter) – all very Fritz Lang meets Matrix

NOT SO NIFTY

Firstly, the matt silver bits appear to have been painted, if the wear and tear to the door handles was anything to go by – bear in mind that this was a mere two months old, so you wouldn’t expect to see black plastic peeping through just yet.

The aforementioned arm-rests tended to get in the way whilst gear changing of using the handbrake, so from a driver’s perspective at least, they weren’t quite the luxury item they appeared to be.

The passenger electric window failed in the down position, but of course if you owned the damn thing, you’d be down to that dealer’s tomorrow banging on their door. Me, I was 40 miles from Budget, so with a bit of effort I just managed to get it back into position and Duck-taped my wife’s hands behind her back for the rest of the holiday. This also kept our credit card spending within more reasonable limits, so thank you to Citroën for a flawed product – nice one, you saved us a fortune!

Some of the dashboard bits looked as if they could start rattling any minute, although to be fair, Portugal’s ‘C’ roads (i.e. the ’virtual’ ones that are only there on the map) would make a boulder rattle. By the way, do get a several maps for Portugal. Some have places without roads, others, roads that don’t show places and worse still, roads that aren’t there yet, so a general consensus is useful, plus three passengers who can all read maps! It’s also possible to find perfectly passable roads that aren’t mapped at all.

USING IT

Firstly, a lot of the car’s practicality comes from its egg-like styling, which leaves it with a very practical roofline, even for the rear seat passengers. Curiously, this ovoid shape leads it to be the first car that I driven for years to have front window quarter lights, which are a security hazard in my book. Personally, I like the shape – well from most angles I do, and it certainly leads it to be pleasantly low on wind noise. Combined with many of Portugal’s main roads being tarmac’ed with a very smooth mix (lethally slippery in the wet), and the sensible choice of Michelin Energy tyres, it rolls like a more luxurious saloon, with commendable inside noise levels. Further damping is provided, by such features as the ‘floating’ console around the gear stick, which is free to move a little on rubber blocks, giving further isolation from engine and gearbox vibration. Closing the doors gives the impression that the car is substantially built, and credit here goes in part to all the heavily curved panels that make up its shape. The more curved they are, the less they can reverberate. Even the roof is heavily domed.

As a further sound-deadening measure, I suspect, top (5th) gear is a rather long-legged 2,200 r.p.m for 80 kph (about 50 mph), which for such a low powered engine seems a trifle overdone. This manifests itself as a reluctance to climb even shallow hills, such as found on motorways, when four passengers are on board. Turn on the air-conditioning and watch it flag still further, until everything seems to require the use of one gear lower than normal. It’s either that or say hallo to the truck ‘creeper’ lane! Turning off the ‘air’ by contrast feels like someone just lit your afterburners, and can be used as your last ace in the hole when in a fix. I also found that a combination of 5th gear WITH the ‘air’ turned on was a good way of preventing the car exceeding the motorway limit on long DOWNhill runs, like some luxury coaches use an electric retarder to prevent overheating the brakes!

The last time I drove a car so compromised when fully loaded was, ironically in another Citroën, this time a 2CV when trying to find the correct lane in London’s Park Lane with full load on board. You really do learn the meaning of ‘plan ahead’, and I start to half understand what apologists for fast cars mean when they rabbit on about ‘enough power to accelerate out of trouble’.

Where the C3 really scores is in the field of ride comfort. I’ve already touched on the comparatively low interior noise level, and to continue the illusion that you’re driving something much more swish, the car rides in straight lines beautifully. Given my reservations of its ability when loaded and with the ‘aircon’ running, it makes an excellent motorway cruiser (in Britain in winter perhaps!).

I can’t be too specific about fuel consumption, after all, who checks this with a holiday hire car? However, I feel that we’ve achieved at least the equivalent of 40+ to the gallon, even with the ‘life support’ systems fully running. Incidentally, the number four setting on the blower fan is deafening and can lead the driver into distraction. However, we found we could use level three after a few minutes of ‘full blast’.

SUMMING UP

UK versions of this car start at around £8600, although its difficult for me to say which version we had, or even if it’s available in ‘cooler’ countries, where base models don’t usually get air-conditioning as standard. At a guess, I’d say ours was one above base, with the CD player and air-conditioning specified as extras.

If you want a small family car that’s comfortable to ride in over long distances, even for tall people, then the C3 is worth a test drive at least. Of course, the downside of this suavity is a distinct lack of hard cornering ability, but everything in life; car handling included, is a compromise. At least all the passengers get what my wife calls the ‘Oh Sh**!’ handles to hang onto.

The Nissan Micra TV ad of a couple of years ago said something like “You can’t have a small car that’s good on motorways – you can with a Nissan”. Add Citroën C3 to that list. Just don’t go up any long hills in hot weather, or get one with a bigger engine!

If I could give it 3.5 stars, I would!
 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Citroen C3 1.1i

Citroen C3 1.1i

Hatchback - Front (FWD) - 5 Speed Manual Gearbox - 1124 cc - Max Speed: 98 mph - 60 bhp - Petrol

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 3,995.00

Citroen Berlingo Multispace 1.9D

Citroen Berlingo Multispace 1.9D

MPV, Estate - Front (FWD) - 5 Speed Manual Gearbox - 1868 cc - Max Speed: 88 mph - 71 bhp - Diesel

User reviews (14)

Buy now for only £ 4,250.00

Citroen C3 1.4i

Citroen C3 1.4i

Hatchback - Front (FWD) - 5 Speed - (Man) / 4 Speed - (Auto), 5 Speed Manual Gearbox, 4 Speed Automatic Gearbox - 1360 cc - Max Speed: 104, 112, 101 mph - 75, 90 bhp - Petrol

User reviews (8)

Buy now for only £ 3,300.00

Citroen Saxo 1.1
Citroen C3 1.4 HDi

Citroen C3 1.4 HDi

Hatchback - Front (FWD) - 5 Speed Manual Gearbox - 1398 cc - Max Speed: 103 mph - 70 bhp - Diesel

User reviews (9)

Buy now for only £ 4,495.00

Citroen Xsara Picasso 1.6i

Citroen Xsara Picasso 1.6i

Estate, MPV - Front (FWD) - 5 Speed Manual Gearbox - 1587 cc - Max Speed: 106 mph - 95 bhp - Petrol

User reviews (7)

Buy now for only £ 2,000.00

Comments about this review »

alexpeck 04.09.2005 19:07

Excellent. You sound like someone who has lived the C3 experience! I love the car, but Citroen are infamous for lacking in interior fixture quality! The plastic bits do fade (rub off) through a year or so of use. The handbrake button is the fastest to go. Alex.

glajma 25.08.2004 16:29

Great review and very helpful for someone who is just about to buy one. I'm going for the 1.4 Desire which comes with cashback and air con at the moment - looking forward to trying out the turbo boost!! We already have a Picasso which we love and hope that this will be a worthy addition to our collection. Having said that, the old car is a Matiz so a tandem would be an upgrade I suppose! Gail

BNibbles 09.02.2004 08:33

Dear Giantraddish - precisely my point, it's mediocre because it shines at some things and not at others. Frankly, I'd be confused if it came to buying one too! I would appear that the object lesson here is - don't give a lukewarm reception to a car, in case someone rates your opinion SH.

Compare prices for Citroen C3 »

1 offer for Citroen C3   sorted by: Price 


More reviews »

Citroen C3 - review by natielou

Advantages: looks and comfort when it drives properly thats about it
Disadvantages: everything - including having to deal with citroen who dont have a clue how fix them

Citroen C3 - review by natielou natielou 31.03.2009 (07.04.2009) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Citroen C3

Citroen C3 - review by xplosiv3

Advantages: Clutchless Gear Box,Air Conditioning, ABS Brakes, Power Steering, Remote Control Central Locking, Electric Windows,
Disadvantages: Performance,Grip On Wet Slippy Roads,

Citroen C3 - review by xplosiv3 xplosiv3 17.03.2008 (17.03.2008) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Citroen C3

Citroen C3 - review by DavenAilsa

Advantages: Looks
Disadvantages: Reliability, service, and pretty much everything else

Citroen C3 - review by DavenAilsa DavenAilsa 10.12.2006 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Citroen C3

Citroen C3 - review by UrkiE-UK

Advantages: .....What speedbump? I didn't feel any speedbump...
Disadvantages: Interior looks cheap upon closer inspection

Citroen C3 - review by UrkiE-UK UrkiE-UK 23.01.2005 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Citroen C3

Citroen C3 - review by yaseen1

Advantages: Good Allround Vision, roomy, lots of leg space, large boot, reliable.
Disadvantages: crap air conditioning, high roof so difficult for roofrack or box

Citroen C3 - review by yaseen1 yaseen1 23.11.2003 (23.11.2003) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Citroen C3



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Citroen C3? Click here