The greatest Chinese novel
Review of The Story of the Stone: a Chinese Novel - Vol 2 The Crab-Flower Club - Xueqin Cao by
erma
Advantages: Very fulfilling-it makes you think, laugh, cry and see the world in a different view!
Disadvantages: Too long, I guess! You might need to buy the whole set to know the ending!
Ever wonder what the greatest novel in China is like? Have a go at the novel ‘The Story of The Stone’ by Cao XueQin. The book is originally written in Chinese, but David Hawkes translated it into English excellently - still preserving the beauty of Chinese language. The second volume, ‘The Crab-flower Club’ consists the 27th chapter till 53rd chapter out of the complete 120 chapters. The first volume starts with the story ... ...a garden in heaven. The flower then vowed to repay his kindness with a lifetime of tears if given the chance. Together they were born into the world as Jia Bao Yu and Lin Dai Yu. Jia Bao Yu is a handsome spoiled brat who declared since young that 'boys are like mud and girls are like water'. His life is surrounded with beautiful women and maids by strange names like ’Faithful’ and ‘Aroma’ which makes him prefers being in their ...
Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average very helpful
|
| Would you listen to it ... |
 |
| Story |
 |
| Characters |
 |
| Listenability |
 |
| How does it compare to ... |
 |
| How does it compare to ... |
 |
|
very helpful

18.04.2001
|
Not just to be read in schools...
Review of Of Mice and Men - John Steinbeck by
Alderson100
Advantages: Not too long, dramatic ending
Disadvantages: Controversial ending?
...controversial themes through the relationship of the two main characters. George: a sharp, quick-witted character and his best friend Lennie: a large, strong but dumb character who unintentionally often gets them into trouble. Set in America during the Depression it highlights the true struggle men went through to try and find work. Through their journey - the readers is given an insight into many problems the men faced: poverty, lonlieness, prejudice ...
Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average helpful
|
| Would you listen to it ... |
 |
| Story |
 |
| Characters |
 |
| Listenability |
 |
| How does it compare to ... |
 |
| How does it compare to ... |
 |
|
helpful

25.08.2008
|
A novel worth sticking with
Review of Clarissa: Or the History of A Young Lady - Samuel Richardson by
Ottavia
Advantages: interesting use of form and narrative; brilliant character detail and pace.
Disadvantages: Long....
Clarissa
'The longest novel in the european language'. A statement that is about as qualiatative as 'Britain's loudest band'. This is how most people will know of Clarissa. Which is a shame for two reasons: the length of the damn thing is what perhaps justifiably puts people off reading it; moreover, the novel truly deserves to be considered one of the finest in the English language, regardless of its length.
I won't distil the plot as the other ... ...that. Also I want to focus instead on the intricacies of the novel and why Dr Samuel Johnson considered it to be 'the first book in the world for the knowledge it displays of the human heart'.
One thisn that is important to remember when reading Clarissa is that, like most novels of its time, it was written in serial form. The detail and pace of character development and events in the novel are therefore perhaps more akin to that of a season of ...
Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average very helpful
|
| Would you listen to it ... |
 |
| Story |
 |
| Characters |
 |
| Listenability |
 |
| How does it compare to ... |
 |
| How does it compare to ... |
 |
|
very helpful

17.08.2008
|
Readable, humorous and of the highest quality.
Review of Vanity Fair (A Novel Without a Hero) - William Thackeray by
dizzy07
Advantages: Great characters, excellent narration which is thought-provoking yet humorous
Disadvantages: None really. Unless you severely dislike 19th century novels.
...are at its best.
Vanity Fair is subtitled 'A Novel without a Hero', which is reflected in the balanced and honest narration and further in the establishment of characters who are soon seen to all contain significant flaws, as is natural for human beings (a point made by the narrator). The characters of this novel are of great depth and complexity, and of a wide range of diversity; perhaps the best feature of this book. The good and bad aspects of ... ...somewhat close-knit social scene of Vanity Fair.
The novel begins with Amelia Sedley and Rebecca Sharp completing their studies at an academy for young ladies. It is soon made clear of the differing backgrounds of these two principal characters, and their respective experiences at the prestigious academy. This is the first of many contrasts of these two characters. The highly intelligent Miss Sharp who wishes to gain a lofty position in society ...
Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average very helpful
|
| Would you listen to it ... |
 |
| Story |
 |
| Characters |
 |
| Listenability |
 |
| How does it compare to ... |
 |
| How does it compare to ... |
 |
|
very helpful

04.08.2008
|
It sho' don't blow Miz Scarlett...
Review of Gone with the Wind - Margaret Mitchell by
Raef86
Advantages: Excellent story, and not sappy
Disadvantages: None
...With around 1,000 pages, Gone With the Wind is a far more multi-layered read than I'm able to portray it. It's action-packed, with a lot of non-romantic stuff going on amidst Scarlett's pining for Ashley and careless use of men for her own gain etc. The key characters are all very different people, allowing for different perspectives on events…but generally only through dialogue, as Scarlett is our protagonist [however, the book isn't written in ... ...their feelings benefit her in some way.
Basically, give it a chance and I think you'll be surprised by how good it is. You learn a lot about the culture and social structure of this historical period; you get sucked into the story - whether you like Scarlett or not you'll find yourself on her side because so many of the expected niceties that she tries to discard are nonsensical and unfair. I guess there's a strong feminist aspect to this novel, ...
Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average very helpful
|
| Would you listen to it ... |
 |
| Story |
 |
| Characters |
 |
| Listenability |
 |
| How does it compare to ... |
 |
| How does it compare to ... |
 |
|
very helpful

04.08.2008
(09.08.2008)
|
| More popular products | | | | (*) Reviews by Ciao members |
|
|