Trying to find time to write a review on www.cutpricables.co.uk - they are excellent!
Trying to find time to write a review on www.cutpricables.co.uk - they are excellent!
Member since:02.07.2003
Reviews:26
Members who trust:21
A few years ago I hit a milestone age and I thought it was about time I started paying some attention to my skincare ((Ok, then, it was 30). We were shopping in Lakeside and I was feeling a bit free with my credit card, so wandered around all the make-up counters in one of the department stores.
I noticed that the Clinique counter was very busy, and then saw their advertising. They were having a "Bonus Time" - buy two products and recieve a free bonus gift. The bonus gift had about 6 different product samples and I thought it was worth a go. Being a bit of a bargain hunter, I bought 2 products, got a free gift, then went back later to a different member of staff for another go. This strategy has served me well over the years :-)) I'm getting a bit ahead of myself, so let's back-pedal a little.
THE "OVER-THE-COUNTER" ASSESSMENT I was dreading this bit. I'm not all that keen on those heavily made-up counter assistants and their condescending attitudes, so I was quite nervous and picked on a young looking one (I thought she wouldn't be able to patronise me too much :-)). The assistant was quite green behind the ears and genuinely very enthusiastic about the Clinique products (it transpired she had just got back from a training course that they put all their sales staff through), but went through the skincare consultation and demonstration. The skin typing was a series of questions and answers that these days you can do on-line (see below). The demonstration consisted of exfoliating the back of one hand, then applying moisturiser to both hands so that I could feel the difference. The technobabble didn't really impress me, but I could feel the difference in my skin. The treated hand was much smoother and felt tighter, so I went ahead and bought the product. Of course, the skin on your hand is very different to the skin on your face (which is much thinner), but this didn't occur to me until I got home! Anyway, by this point I didn't really have enough courage left to try another counter, and the free gift signs were waving in front of my eyes :-))
THE "ON-LINE" ASSESSMENT Skin typing can be carried out on line on Clinique's website (see below). you need to register on the website (a fairly simple process), then click on the "Which product is right For you?" link at the left of the screen. You are presented with a series of multiple-choice simple questions about your skin colour, hair colour, ease of tanning, dryness, etc.). Choose the answers that best describe your skin, press the button at the bottom and hey presto! In the interests of this review, I retook the skin type test on line and came out with the same results as my over the counter consultation from 6 years ago, so I was pleased with that. (Ok, if you really want to know - I am skin type II).
There is a button at the bottom that you should choose if you are a man. You will then be recommended the men's products instead of the women's. In general men's skin is thicker and stronger than women's and tends to be less dry, so skin types differ between
the sexes.
After coming up with your skin type, the consultant (human or computer) suggests which of the products from Clinique's 3-step System is suitable for you. For my skin type, I use Mild Soap, Clarifying lotion No. 2 and Dramatically Different Moisturising Lotion.
THE THREE STEPS (or 4 steps)
OK, so you've got your skin typing done and are now the proud owner of your 3-step Clinique skincare system. There's nothing that special about Clinique's 3 steps, they are the same as everyone elses. The 3 steps are cleansing, exfoliating and moisturising.
**Cleansing**
I don't bother with the soap because using soap over the long term aggravates my eczema. If I did use soap, the mild Clinique one would be my choice. My friends that suffer from spots say the extra strength soaps are great for for oily skin, and the mild ones are just that - mild! Clinique products are free from perfumes so are usually quite good for sensitive skin and they have neutral smells which suits me down to the ground (I suffer from asthma and perfumes often make me wheeze). The mild soap just has a faint soapy smell, and the extra strong one smells a little medicated. Both soaps are hard and lather very well (although we do live in a soft water area).
The mild soap is a plain white colour and the stronger soaps are slightly yellow. One of the great things about Clinique's products is that they usually list all the ingredients so if you know that you are sensitive to a particular chemical, then you can avoid it. For the soap, the ingredients are listed both on the box, and on a separate leaflet inside the box. Each of the soaps comes individually wrapped inside the box (either one big soap or three little ones - see below for prices). Most of the chemicals listed are fairly innocuous and necessary to the products. One of the features I really like is that each of the soaps in the range comes with its own soap dish and lid, but at £8.50 for 100g bar they can afford to add these little niceties! It sounds expensive, but you have to remember that this soap isn't for washing your hands with and lasts for ages. My husband's bar lasts for months at a time.
Clinique say you should wash "make-up free skin". This means that if you wear make-up, you need to remove it before starting the 3 steps. Thus the skin-care thus becomes a 4-step process. Personally, after removing make-up, I wash my face in clean water and pat dry. If you have dry skin, you probably don't need the soap either.
**Exfoliating** There are 5 different Clarifying Lotions for women, though I can't personally see any difference between "No. 1" and "Mild". The lowest number is for the driest skin, and as your skin gets oilier you are recommended a higher number. The Clarifying lotions 2, 3 and 4 all contain alcohol, so can be drying for the skin.
Each of the clarifying lotions is a different colour, which makes it easy to find the one you want on the shelf. Again, there is no perfume. The smell is clean and refreshing and not too strong. I always think there is a very faint smell of witch hazel. Unusually, there is no list of ingredients on the clarifying lotion bottle, although I have had lists with smaller bottles that I have had in the bonus gifts.
The idea behind exfoliating is to remove the dead skin cells from the surface of the skin. Make-up companies claim this encourages the growth of new skin, though I am not sure that there is much scientific evidence for this. However, they do seem good at keeping my skin clean, and certainly work for my friends with oily skin too, so there must be something good happening. I suspect the clarifying lotions work so well because of the antiseptic properties of the alcohol keeping bacteria at bay, preventing spots forming in the first place.
The "Mild" and "No. 1" lotions are recommended for people with skin conditions such as eczema and psoriasis. Personally, I suffer from eczema and have been using Clarifying Lotion No. 2 for 6 years with a great deal of success and no bad reactions so far. The higher numbers have a higher alcohol content.
When you first start using Clarifying Lotion, it feels a bot strange. There is a cold sensation (caused by evaporation of the alcohol), and it can sting a little (though not in a bad way, just that it feels like something is happening!). This latter sensation only happens the first few times you use the product and disappears after a while, as your skin gets used to it. After using the Clarifying lotion, my skin feels lovely and smooth and clean. Years ago, I remember using Clearasil lotion. I was swayed by the advert on the TV showing a girl using this lotion on a cotton wool ball, rubbing her face and bringing off loads of dirt. I bought some and was really annoyed that the cotton wool wasn't dirty after I used it! The Clinique product does what that other one promised to do - it actually leaves your skin feeling really clean :-)).
The bottles are clear plastic with coloured plastic tops, so you can see the contents and it's easy to tell when you are running low and need to buy a new one. They are not cheap, but do last a long time. I buy the smaller size bottle and it lasts me a couple of months. It is generally better to buy smaller sizes in make-up (even if they work out more expensive weight for weight) because they can go off if you leave them open too long, and you can get spots and eye-infections from them.
**Moisturising** Everyone gets the same recommended moisturiser, but I don't really feel it's necessary if you have oily skin. I use it in drier areas, around the edge of the face, cheeks and on my neck. After cleansing and exfoliating, my skin just drinks up the moisturiser and it never leaves my skin feeling greasy the way some moisturisers can. I also never have any trouble with spots, although I wouldn't recommend any moisturiser to someone who suffers qith oily skin. I use a separate gel moisturiser around my eyes as I feel that normal moisturisers are a bit heavy for the eye area. Having said that, the "Dramatically Different" Moisturiser really is exactly what it says on the tin - dramatically different! It's light and smooth and oil-free, easy to apply and goes a long way. I prefer it to any other moisturiser I have tried. For example, it is much lighter than Oil of Ulay, and easier to apply than Nivea. It soaks in better than any of Lancome's moisturisers. Long ago, a dermatologist told me that all moisturisers are basically the same and you may as well use Vaseline. This may be true from the point of view of preventing wrinkles, but I wouldn't like to suffer the spots! The other thing I really like about it is that it doesn't smell. Once again, there is no added perfume.
The full-size moisturiser comes in a glass bottle that is boxed and has a leflet with full ingredients list. The bottle top is silvered, and the silvering is prone to coming off in the long term so that you can get tiny flecks of silver in your makeup. I have had this problem with the eye make up remover too. The sample bottles that come with the bonus gifts are usually plastic, although they still have silvered lids. Both types of bottle are clear, so it is easy to see when they are getting empty and need replacing.
THE RESULTS As I have said before, I suffer from eczema. Before I started using Clinique make-up, I used a motley collection of products from Boots No. 7, L'Oreal, that sort of thing. I used to suffer a little from facial eczema, but not too bad. After using Clinique's skin care products, my facial eczema completely disappeared. As long as I use it, the eczema stays away. When I get lazy, it starts to come back. I've mentioned how good this is for my skin to a few Clinique counter staff and they always say Clinique doesn't make any claims for treating eczema. I think this is a very responsible attitude for a company, who obviously train their staff well. Of course, not everyone's skin is the same and you should probably test a small area of your own skin before going the whole hog. To this end, Clinique counters will give you a free consultation and a free small sample 3-step pack to take away so that you can find out for yourself if this product is for you before shelling out big money.
THE MEN'S RANGE Similar to the women's stuff but repackaged in silver packaging to appeal to the blokes.
The Men's moisturiser is called "M Lotion". Apart from the packaging, the product appears to be identical to the Dramatically Different moisturing Lotion recommended for women.
The exfoliator is now called "Scruffing Lotion" and is packaged in "unbreakable bottles". Clinique also make a virtue of its "antiseptic properties" for preventing infections in shaving cuts - presumably due to the high level of alcohol in the bottle! the colours are duller than the women's range, but i suspect there is little difference otherwise.
The soaps are pretty much the same, but the men's soap dishes are a dark grey colour, while the women's are creamy coloured.
I tried a few experiments with the skin-typing on Clinique's website to see what would happen if I put the same information in first for a woman, then pretending to be a man. I found that the women's oily skin soap equates to the men's extra strength soap, and the women's clarifying lotion equates to the men's scruffing lotion plus half (for example if a woman was recommended clarifying lotion No. 3, the consultation came out with Scruffing Lotion 3 1/2 for a man. The M Lotion was recommended even for a man with oily skin, which I personally think is a bit excessive. Two people I know with oily skin have developed spots after using Clinique's moisturiser (but they also get spots after using other moisturisers so this is perhaps not very surprising).
GREAT FOR SPOTS If you suffer from oily skin, and stick to the first two steps, then Clinique's products should really help you. They also have some brilliant "under-the-counter" products (such as Clinique's "Anti-BlemishSpot Treatment", but I digress...).
TESTED ON ANIMALS Clinique's products are all 100% allergy tested. This means they have all been tested on animals. This is a difficult ethical dilemma for me, as I personally don't agree that cosmetics should be tested on animals.
OFFICIAL CLINIQUE WEBSITE
http://www.clinique.co.uk
Register on the website to print off a voucher for a free full-size free Colour Surge lipstick from Boots Clinique counters.
PRICES 3 Little Soaps With Travel Dish (Mild or Oily Skin)150g £12.00 Facial Soap with Soap Dish (Extra Mild, Mild or Oily Skin Formula)100g £8.50 Facial Soap with Soap Dish (Extra Mild, Mild or Oily Skin Formula)150g £11.00 Clarifying Lotion (Mild, No. 1, No. 2, No.3 or No.4) 200ml £13.50 Clarifying Lotion (No. 1, No. 2, No.3 or No.4) 400ml £21.00 Dramatically Different Moisturizing Lotion 50ml £14.00 Dramatically Different Moisturizing Lotion 125ml £24.50 M Lotion 50ml £14.00 M Lotion 100ml £19.50 Men's face soap (Regular or Extra Strength) with Soap Dish 150g £11.00 Scruffing Lotion (1.5, 2.5, 3.5 or 4.5) 200ml £13.50
BONUS PROMOTIONS The Clinique promotion of giving a bonus gift with two purchased products is a regular feature of their counters, and their website (see below) gives details of all the forthcoming promotions (dates and locations). I have blond eyelashes and always wear mascara, but haven't had to buy any for years - they always seem to give one away. Whenever Boots has a bonus promotion, I stock up on skincare products, get my bonus gift and earn Boots points too. Actually, I often use my Boots points to buy my Clinique, but that's another story...
The bonus gift often has basic make-up essentials such as lipsticks and blusher, together with sample sizes of other products such as moisturisers. I love Clinique's eye make-up removers, and find the sample bottles they give away in the bonus packs ideal for use when travelling. The other clinique product I use on a regular basis is City Block. I'll leave that for another review!
If you register your details with your local Clinique counter (whichever shop that happens to be in), the next time they have a "Bonus Time" they will send you a postcard with the dates and gift details.
YES, BUT IS IT REALLY WORTH THE MONEY? Clinique make-up is not cheap, but they use good quality ingredients and the products last a long time. To me, they represent good value for money. I don't know what it is about Clinique's products that is different to everyone elses, but they do really work. I have recommended Cliniques skincare products to everyone I know, and all those who tried them carried on using them (including my grandmother, mother, sister and best friend). Personally, I'm a cheapskate, but this is one company whose products are worth the money.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
fab review ! like you said Clinique is expensive but it works out well worth it if you take advantage of the bonus days
debs
crispybits 16.03.2006 18:53
Thank you for this very detailed review. You've saved me about £20. :-D I was going to take advantage of a Clinique value-pack offer - which included the moisturiser - for £35. Instead I went for the facial soap and toner as standalones ('cause those were what I was interested in) which worked out cheaper. Great review and fabulous advice, thank you!
baby_uk 24.08.2005 21:17
very in-depth review and jam-packed with loads of great helpfl info
Clinique 3-Step Skincare System Step 1 (Cleanse) - 3 x Little Liquid Facial Soaps for Oily ... more
Skin 50ml - All the benefits of Clinique's famous dermatologist-developed liquid facial soap in a new portable size. Cleanses without stripping. Preps skin for the exfoliating action of Clarifying Lotion.
Clinique 3-Step Skincare System Step 1 (Cleanse) - 3 Little Facial Soaps Oily Skin Formula ... more
50gr (With Travel Dish) - Clinique believes in soap for faces because soap is our guiding dermatologists' skin cleanser of choice, their own formulation. Cleanses thoroughly, gently. Rinses off completely. The best way to remove facial dirt and oil. Leaves skin fresh, clean - never taut or dry.
Advantages: Gentle, Effective, Easy-to-Follow Disadvantages: Requires regular use for maximum effect
fantasticmoosetastic 20.12.2007 (20.12.2007)
·
Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Clinique 3 Step Skin Care
Advantages: Gentle, Effective, Easy-to-Follow Disadvantages: Requires regular use for maximum effect
fantasticmoosetastic 20.12.2007 (20.12.2007)
·
Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Clinique 3 Step Skin Care