...
Through sheer laziness, I left the personal account with the Clydesdale. During the early Spring of 2003, they employed a couple of human beings, one of whom telephoned me early this year to ask me about my account needs. I told her that I had no regular means of being paid, and that ... Read review
...my personal account with the Clydesdale (no real quibbles there, actually, until now), but had a completely unwarranted nasty letter this morning. I rang the branch immediately and spoke to one of the "old guard" (i.e. pre- new "number cruncher" measures to slap charges straight onto accounts without taking circumstances into account), who I shall keep anonymous to protect their job. They advised me to move my account at once ... ...to pay myself before my Clydesdale current account went over the overdraft limit. It was three weeks since I opened the account, and I was also concerned that I had had no confirmation from the Clydesdale that I had even opened the account. I (eventually) got them on the phone (only 89 rings - I kept a record!), and they told me that the guy who had opened the account had gone on sick leave that evening, and that due to the nature of his condition, ... more
UPDATE II - 29 SEPTEMBER 2003 As they've recently redeemed themselves slightly in my eyes, I feel it only fair to update this op AGAIN...
Through sheer laziness, I left the personal account with the Clydesdale. During the early Spring of 2003, they employed a couple of human beings, one of whom telephoned me early this year to ask me about my account needs. I told her that I had no regular means of being paid, and that some months she could expect to see several thousand pounds paid into the account, and others, nothing at all. I offered to fax her a few recent contracts so that she knew I was telling the truth (which I did), and we then came to the arrangement that when I had reached my overdraft limit, although I would not be able to get any cash out of my account, they would not (within reason) refuse direct debits, or bounce important cheques which I had discussed with them by prior agreement. In other words, I could pay the rent, but not buy that pair of boots that I saw as an equally important need.
"We're trying to understand customer needs better" she told me. I replied that they certainly needed to, and it was only sloth that had kept me from moving my enormous overdraft elsewhere.
So...yes, they do still charge for every transaction, and yes, I probably WOULD still be better off elsewhere, but I now have a trust relationship with someone at Piccadilly Circus, and need never lose sleep about paying essential bills again.
In short, if you are looking for a bank, they are worth talking to, but give them a hard time, otherwise they could end up shafting you.
UPDATE - 13 SEPTEMBER 2002
I still had my personal account with the Clydesdale (no real quibbles there, actually, until now), but had a completely unwarranted nasty letter this morning. I rang the branch immediately and spoke to one of the "old guard" (i.e. pre- new "number cruncher" measures to slap charges straight onto accounts without taking circumstances into account), who I shall keep anonymous to protect their job. They advised me to move my account at once to "somewhere that actually gives a toss about the customer" (where would that be, then?), as "Head Office are deliberately trying to close accounts like yours down" (i.e. frequently overdrawn, less than £20000 passing through them a year, no other services, like loans or credit cards, from the bank).
Sorry to keep updating this op, but I want to make sure nobody else gets screwed royally by the Clydesdale. **************************************************
In addition to my current and savings accounts, I also have a business account with the Clydesdale. I was originally recommended to them by one of the Executive Banking clients (who then earned a seven-figure sum a year), who undoubtedly gets a completely different class of service to the rest of us, as he is still gushing in his praise of their competence and clarity.
The service, as detailed by all the other opinions here, is absolutely appalling, and the lucky devil that actually got someone on the phone must have some kind of miracle gift! The average number of rings before I lose the will to live is 60 or 70.
Charges are horrific for transactions (average £0.25 for withdrawals AND deposits!), and £32 for going a few pence over my overdraft limit left me reeling with shock the first time it happened. In addition, they have a remarkable talent for cancelling direct debits altogether without warning, so you are left in the interesting position of wondering each month whether you have actually paid your bills or not.
However, their running of the business service is something else again.
I opened a business account in May 2000 for my newly formed Limited Company. I saw a really nice, helpful guy, who gave me solid advice, provided me with an account number to set up BACS payments with people I was already under contract to, and promised me a chequebook by the end of the following week (this was a Thursday - I still remember it well). He said that I could call on the bank at any time, discuss business plans, have access to finance - all those things that a new business finds useful, comforting, and essential from their bank.
1 June 2000 - I still didn't have my chequebook, and since around £1,000 had been transferred by BACS into the business account, I needed to pay myself before my Clydesdale current account went over the overdraft limit. It was three weeks since I opened the account, and I was also concerned that I had had no confirmation from the Clydesdale that I had even opened the account. I (eventually) got them on the phone (only 89 rings - I kept a record!), and they told me that the guy who had opened the account had gone on sick leave that evening, and that due to the nature of his condition, would not be returning to work. Ever.
I didn't get angry at this point - these things happen, and the poor guy's working life was over. I did ask a few questions about my account though, only to be told it didn't exist, they had no record of the account number, and that they certainly didn't have a chequebook waiting for me. Where then, was my £1,000?
Floating in the ether, actually...
By this time, I had been charged over £100 for returned cheques, direct debits, and other charges on my current account. They had money which they knew was mine, just held in check because there was nowhere to put it. I did seek advice on this, and they should have just put this money into my current account until I gave them further instructions.
After much haggling, I eventually had a business account in July, two months after incorporation. My first quarter tax bill was absolutely enormous due to having to "pay" myself every penny I earned. At least, that's how the IR saw it.
But was this the worst of it? Oh no...
In July 2001, I had a six week gap between contracts, and I warned the Clydesdale that there was likely to be a week to 10 day period where my personal current account might slip beyond the permitted red into purgatory. I had no response to my letter (177 rings at 11.45 in the morning - what else was I supposed to do?), so assumed (wrongly) that there would be no problem with this, and that they would view this period with a little leniency.
In my business account was £500 to pay my tax bill.
Except it wasn't.
Clydesdale Bank Plc chose to remove that £500, without my permission, and pay it into my current account to cover the overdraft.
My cheque to the IR bounced.
Needless to say, banks shouldn't do this. To illustrate my point, if I was the CEO of a large multinational, and transferred money from the corporate wedge to my own bank account, I could find myself in court for theft.
This episode ended up costing me around £900 in fees, letters, accountancy charges, and general hassle from the bank.
I'm moving the business account - I haven't before now since I haven't been in a position to. The personal accounts will follow it out the door shortly.
Be careful.
UPDATE - STOP PRESS, 30 MAY 2002
They have just done it again, and I wasn't even overdrawn this time! I have passed the matter to my solicitor, and this time, I am taking them to court. Watch this space...
Advantages: None if you like to keep your money Disadvantages: This bank losses your money faster than you earn it
...end of problems with the clydesdale bank plc.
It all started when I opened a second account with them to make sure that all my bills got payed on time, without me spending any of the money by mistake. Very good thing to do you may say, but when the first month passed and I was inundated with reminders from several companies to whom I now owed money. I gave the bank the beniffit of my doubt with it being the first month of the account being open.
... ...thing out just before I went to work overseas for the next few months. by the time I got back I owed several companies money again as well as the bank charges that I had encoured while I was away. Now when I set up the account I made sure that there was more than enough money going into the account every month so that when I got back home I would have no bills outstanding and also money left over so I could take my family away on holiday, so there ...
squibby 19.11.2000
· Read full review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful Review of Clydesdale Bank Accounts
Advantages: Supposedly good for savers Disadvantages: Bad service, bad Account range
...been an account holder at Clydesdale for more than half my life. Only recently have I realised that the type of accounts they offer are so far short of the standard obtainable on the High Street.
Generally through my own negligence and indifference to my Bank account I have missed all the benefits available from Royal Bank of Scotland or Bank of Scotland who run accounts especially for students, (which I was)and graduates (which I am)and potential ...
RAL27 14.03.2001
· Read full review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful Review of Clydesdale Bank Accounts
Advantages: large overdraft offered Disadvantages: Charges for EVERY transaction made
...the service offered by the Clydesdale bank called 'student account 2000' and think this service is absolutely awful. I have been charged for every single transaction made, and as a student this is not ideal. The current rate that i am being charged at is 32p every transaction, this may not sound too much but it can mount up to as much as £25 per month! This could obviously be spent on something more worth while, rather than pouring it into the pockets ... ...charge students for the privalege of banking with them. The Bank Of Scotland, for example, has no hidden charges assosiated with their student account, which is exactly how it should be. Clydesdale bank is simply taking advantage of young students who are in a vulnerable position. ...
trace1 09.05.2001 (11.05.2001)
· Read full review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: somewhat helpful Review of Clydesdale Bank Accounts
Efficiency of service
Competitiveness of char...
Online - Content/organi...
Similar reviews »
Reviews which might be of interest for "Clydesdale Bank Accounts"
Advantages: They don't charge for their ATMs Disadvantages: Rubbish rates, rubbish service, closed branches & ATMs
I have been with the Clydesdalebank since I was at school in the early 1970s, the word 'loyal customer' obviously doesn't mean anything whatsoever to a bank. My current account last year earned me a huge 12p of interest after tax!! That is after paying my wages into this account every month & keeping about £1000 of emergency cash in the account all the time.
I recently moved to the Bank of Scotland who is paying over 6% gross for the same type of account & the Clydesdale contacted me wondering why I left!!!!
The Clydesdalebank have closed so many branches in recent years, closed their ATMs & closed their customer information counters so you now need to queue up for about 20 minutes to ask a simple question to a teller.
When you eventually reach the teller they are more interested in asking you if you want a loan or mortgage ...
ScottishWestie 22.10.2007
· Read full review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful Review of Clydesdale Bank
Advantages: Available to people 11+ Disadvantages: Acceptance not as good as Visa Debit but getting better
I have two Visa Electron cards from Bank of Scotland (Halifax) and have no real complaints about them.
Had VERY little trouble with acceptance since recieving them and far more freedom with my money. People who are saying that hardly anywhere accepts them are wrong.
As for putting it through as VISA online, 8 times out of 10 this does work and I've done it myself.
For those aged 16+ (as I will be in a couple of months) open an account with Lloyds TSB instead, they give you a Visa Debit card. Clydesdale/Yorkshire Bank issue Maestro on all of their accounts, for people aged 11+, even on their basic bankaccounts for those with bad credit ratings.
Don't knock Electron but get something better if you can. ...
bugmenot2 02.10.2006
· Read full review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: somewhat helpful Review of VISA Electron
I'm a student currently and around a year ago set up my third current account with Lloyds TSB. I set up a meeting online and was given a reference for my local branch and a time. When I first arrived at the bank I was delighted to find the staff were very helpful and friendly, having worked for a few weeks for the Clydesdalebank previously, this bank seemed in excellent working order! My account was set up instantly via the bank's computer network - all done and dusted within 20 minutes! There and then the manager gave me my account details, let me enter security details for internet banking and issued a welcome pack. The manager was extremely helpful and gave me some great tips for the future with regards to upgrading and changing my account; also advising that I ran as much money through my account as possible, as it all counts ...
agazad 24.01.2005 (25.01.2005)
· Read full review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful Review of Lloyds TSB