Home > Books > Fiction > Modern Fiction Books > R Modern Fiction Books > Room - Emma Donoghue > Review
Room - Emma Donoghue

User Review

for Room - Emma Donoghue
See next review "Clinging to the Light."
5 Stars Make Room in your life for this...
47 of 47 Ciao Users found the following review helpful See ratings
Recommendable: Yes

Advantages Strong, Believable characters, Compelling storyline, Price at the moment

Disadvantages none for me!

Detailed Rating

Would you read it again?
Story
Characters
Readability
How does it compare to similar books?
How does it compare to other works by the same author?

The Author

Drewster-Rooster since 25 Mar 2010

Moving home and just become a daddy for the first time so not very active on the site right now... more

196 Members trust me
Introduction

The first review I read about the book "Room" was late last year when a fellow dooyooer wrote about it, there was something about the review which resonated in me and finding myself intrigued I made a mental note to at some point buy the book for myself. The new year came in and as I had been given a few books as Christmas presents last year I decided to read what I had and then look at buying the titles on my amazon wish list, Room was one of the titles and last week I finally got round to buying a copy. Saturday morning came and I picked up the book, read the first 3 pages and became hooked. 15 hours and many cups of coffee later I finished the story and this is what I thought of it...

The Story

Jack and his Ma live in Room, an 11ft square fortified and locked shed in Old Nick's back garden. Jack was born in Room on Rug and knows nothing about the outside world. His Ma was abducted a few years before Jacks birth and kept locked away, subjected to abuse and rape Ma soon became pregnant with Jack and as the book begins he is just about to celebrate his fifth birthday. With only a few books, a TV and the contents of Room Jack and his Ma only have each other, Jack understands that the people on TV aren't actually real and that outside of Room there is only outer space. Ma protects Jack from Old Nick the best she can and now that Jack is getting to the age where he can understand more and be told the truth about matters she is desperate for the pair of them to escape their prison. Told from the perspective of Jack and narrated by him we follow the two of them as they plot an escape from Room and how the five year old copes when his world is turned upside down after discovering what really is on the other side of Door...
The Book

You may have noticed that during my story summary there are capitalised words which are grammatically incorrect, "Rug" and "Room" for example. These are, in fact, characters in Jacks world and he sees these things as his friends, has a strong affection for them and to him they are everything. We are introduced to Jack and his Ma straight away and in the early section of the book understand the bond he has with the things around him, he has his own favourite spoon called 'Meltedey Spoon' he sometimes sleeps in 'Wardrobe' when Old Nick pays his mother a visit and is friends with 'Plant'. It does take a couple of pages to get used to the language used in the book but once you see things from Jack's perspective and understand why is he is where he is and more importantly *why* you can't help but hold a great deal of affection for the character and the situation he and his mother are in.

Cleverly, by using Jack as the narrator of the story you as the reader discover things the same time as Jack does, before Ma talks to Jack about escaping from Room there is time to get to know both of the characters and understand how Jack has been brought up without ever setting foot outside or interacting with anyone other than his mother. The bond between them is as you can imagine paramount, they have spent every single waking minute together for five years and Jack knows nothing other than his mother, she is vitally important to him and he to her and the story really reinforces the love they have for one another.

Some may argue that the language used in the book is too advanced for a five year old, not having children myself I can't compare how Jack spoke with children of the same age however I personally found him to be utterly believable; it stands to reason that Jack would be advanced for his age, he has had one-to-one tutoring for the whole of his life and constant attention from his mother without any outside distraction or interference. The book explores how Jack thinks and about what he 'knows' to be true and its compelling to read the thoughts of someone so young who has a skewed version of what reality actually is, to him it makes sense as that is what he knows but it's when he starts to realise and sees for himself that there is life and world outside of Room that things begin to change.

Split into sections the book covers a period of time in the life of Jack and his Ma and their lives in and out of Room. Social adjustments have to be made, new things learnt and discovered and it's a real joy to follow Jack on his journey. Whilst it's an overused cliché to use the term 'journey' when talking about books and films and normally I wouldn't use the word in my reviews, in the case of Jack and Room it is without doubt the best description of the book as a whole. From a sheltered and protected start to being thrust outside into the world Jack has a lot to cope with and the strength of the story is understanding how he manages to deal with everything around him, everything is new to him and he has to learn how to actually live in a brand new environment where nothing is familiar and everything is scary.

Room is one of those books that stays with you after the end and even now a few days later I can't help but think back on the story. My only word of advice with the book is to stick with it; it did take a couple of pages for me to follow the language used as some of the words don't have a natural flow. Adopting the tone of five year old must have caused some problems for the author to get right and the strange use of capitalised words do interrupt your thought process when taking the book in, however you do become accustomed to how the book reads and it goes to show how compelling it is for me to have read it in a single sitting. There are many plaudits I could throw at the book but overall I absolutely adored it, there are times when it is heartbreakingly sad, laugh-out-loud funny and then nail-bitingly exciting with a perfect balance of tension building and complete character development. It is a book which would be accessible to all, male or female, young or old (although there may be subjects a little too harrowing for the very young) and I would have no hesitation in recommending this to everyone to read.

I paid just £3.58 for my new copy of the paperback book from amazon which is an absolute steal in my opinion; the Kindle version of the book is even cheaper at only £2.51. At 336 pages it's a book that gets to the point quickly and maintains its momentum through to the very last page, it is without doubt the best book I have read for a long time and even though I am drawn to horror and thriller fiction normally I'm glad I made the decision to try something different. Other reviewers have commented on just how good Room actually is and my review adds another perfect, five star rating to the ones that are already here.

Absolutely recommended. Buy it, you won't be disappointed.

Thanks for reading my review, please note that this is also on dooyoo under my username

Rate this User Review

How helpful was this review to you? Rating guidelines

Attention, this is the first review from this author

Instead of giving a negative rating, consider:

  • Help this member by giving your advice

  • Report fraud (for example plagiarism) or other issue with the review to the Ciao support team

Activate low rating buttons

Add your comment

 Post comment  Post comment

JavaScript should be enabled to rate or post a comment.

Comments

Maybe you have a question about Room - Emma Donoghue? Ask here
Previous page Next page Page 1 of 10 | 1 - 5 out of 48 comments
  • jonathanb 18/04/2011 14:26
    Rated this review as
    Very Helpful

    A clever premise and intriguing sounding story. May have to find room on my shelf for this one.

  • noodlebutty 10/04/2011 22:56
    Rated this review as
    Very Helpful
  • elfbwillow 27/02/2011 17:31
    Rated this review as
    Very Helpful
  • IzzyS 27/02/2011 15:50
    Rated this review as
    Very Helpful
  • louisechackett 27/02/2011 11:08
    Rated this review as
    Very Helpful
Previous page Next page Page 1 of 10 | 1 - 5 out of 48 comments

More reviews

for Room - Emma Donoghue

Compare prices

for Room - Emma Donoghue