All work and lots of play have meant no time for Ciao. Nearly a year since my last review and almost...
All work and lots of play have meant no time for Ciao. Nearly a year since my last review and almost as long since I've read anything... Where to start?
Member since:09.09.2004
Reviews:77
Members who trust:50
I won't delve deeply into the details of how GPS works. That would take ages and you might already know. But in case you don't - suffice to say that there's a bunch of satellites orbiting the earth. Each one sends out a time signal along with it's unique identifier. GPS devices know about each of the satellites and where they are in relation to each other so, by working out the time difference between each of the signals sent by each satellite, the GPS receiver can work out where on earth it is (literally!).
With that out of the way I will try and explain why, after two years of owning a "bog-standard" GPS receiver, I decided to upgrade my trusty old (bright yellow) Garmin eTrex to a shiny new (silver) eTrex Summit.
Garmin are well known for their GPS offerings. In recent years they've turned it into a massive business. The eTrex range is one of the longest-standing in Garmins line-up and it is aimed squarely at people who enjoy the outdoors. The old yellow eTrex was, and indeed still is, at the bottom of the range. This is not to say it's a bad product, but after a few years of use, I started to realise it's limitations.
The base-model eTrex is a straight-forward GPS device that is capable of storing up to 500 waypoints. Up to 50 of these can be strung in sequence to create a route, but the base model can only store one such route. The unit maintains a track log that you can use to retrace your steps, which can be handy in a white-out on top of a mountain. It will also let you navigate (using the word loosely) to any stored waypoint. But that's about it. So when you are going away for a week and
won't have a PC with you, it can be a bit tricky working with a selection of routes. It's not impossible, but it will take up most of your evening trying to work out which waypoints you need to string together to make up tomorrow's walk. There's certainly room for improvement.
The improvement over the eTrex comes in the form of the eTrex Summit. Only one step up in the range, it's much the same in terms of appearance. A sleek, waterproof grey/silver case about the size of an older mobile phone, the Summit boasts the same capacity for 500 waypoints, but this one can store up to 20 routes (again of 50 waypoints each). It also seems to have a larger track log memory, meaning that you can record your trail for longer before it starts to get over-written. In practice, there's about enough track log memory for about 6 hours of walking.
The interface is the same across the whole range, a large LCD screen with an eerie green backlight for night-viewing, sensibly placed buttons for single-handed use and a tough plastic case that will take being dropped from waist height without complaining. There is a lanyard attachment point, complete with lanyard which I've found invaluable while hill-walking. The serial port is protected by a rubber flap to keep the water out and the battery compartment has a rubber o-ring to stop water fouling up the power supply. All things considered, it's a design that has lasted very well indeed, despite the amount of abuse it gets when I'm out and about.
While the interface remains the same, the hardware (and software) has been upgraded from the base model. Whereas the base eTrex would only give you a heading when you were on the move, the Summit comes with an electronic compass for accurate bearings even when stationary. This does take it's toll on the battery life but can come in handy, especially when you have lost the GPS signal. In addition to the compass, the Summit also improves on the GPS-based altimeter function with the addition of a full barometric altimeter. This allows for much more accurate estimation of elevation and gives an excellent calculation of ascent/descent rates. Both of these new functions come with their own GUI modes, the compass being the most familiar and the altimeter being the least useful. Other display modes will show you how far/long to your next waypoint, how fast you're traveling, your average speed, maximum speed, elapsed time and distance walked - all of which can be both inspiring and demoralizing, depending on your frame of mind!
Because of the new features, the battery life of the Summit is poorer than the base model (around 12 hours compared to 18 without the compass) but this is bearable and should see you good for one or two long walks although in particularly cold weather you could get caught short by the batteries suddenly deciding they have had enough. A word of warning here though - rechargeable batteries are great BUT they have a curious habit of reporting themselves as nearly empty very. The result is that the eTrex Summit shows the battery warning light after not very long at all - maybe 2 - 3 hours but then continues to operate for a good 7 - 8 hours more before switching off completely. It's a problem I've noticed with rechargeable batteries in general but when you might be relying on the device for navigation it's probably best to stick with Duracells.
It's probably worth mentioning that there are a reasonable number of accessories for the eTrex range. I bought a handlebar mount for mine so that I could plot mountain bike routes as well as hill-walking. Unfortunately it's more than a little unstable and the batteries tend to jolt free meaning everything turns off - most unsatisfactory. Other options include mobile-phone alike carry cases, dashboard mounts and cigar-lighter power adapters.
So far, then, the Summit does everything the base eTrex can do and a few things more which make it much more useful for a hill walker/rambler type person. What the unit DOESN'T do is provide base-maps that you can use to navigate around unfamiliar territory. But to be honest, I am far happier carrying a proper OS map anyway, just in case. The Summit does have a map page, but all you will find on it are waypoints that you have marked and the track showing where you have been. It is very much a case of only getting out what you put in.
It is the lack of base-map information that keeps the cost of the unit so low while still providing all the navigation features of the more expensive models. Where the Summit really does come into it's own is when it is used in conjunction with some mapping software on a PC (such as the excellent Memory-Map navigator). Get yourself a USB/serial cable and hook it up to your PC. Create your maps on reliable OS-based digital maps and export them to the unit, waypoints and all, for future use. It's then a simple task of selecting the appropriate route when you reach the start point and the GPS will guide you all the way round (if needed).
In summary, the eTrex Summit is an excellent upgrade from the base eTrex. The additional route capacity makes it a tool much better suited to a week long feast of walks and the addition of a proper altimeter and a digital compass turn it into a comprehensive navigation tool. The robust case and waterproofing, complete with the lanyard or even handlebar attachment makes it ideal for anyone with a keen interest in finding their way around the great outdoors, but it works best if you invest in a PC data Cable some mapping software and a bit of time using it before you go out.
3 years ago I paid around £235 for mine. IN a recent check on prices I've seen it available for as low as £140 which is probably about as good as you will get. So if you're looking for a rugged, handheld GPS that's ideally suited to hill-walking in the UK, you could do a lot worse than the eTrex Summit.
Sure, there are flashier models available, with colour screens and base-maps but in my experience you will be paying through the nose for a bunch of features that you really don't need. Stick with something simple with a regular compass and map for backup and you'll enjoy your walking a whole lot more than if you spend your entire day glued to a colour screen wondering how accurate the base mapping is!
It just remains for me to remind you that a GPS should not be relied upon 100% for navigation. The signals are only accurate to within around 15m, but this isn't always good enough and there is always the chance that the batteries could run out etc. Spare batteries are essential, especially in the winter when the cold saps them of their power at an alarming rate. But regardless of how many spare batteries you carry, you should ALWAYS venture out in the hills properly equipped with a compass and the relevant OS map.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
The eTrex H GPS from Garmin guarantees simple and reliable satellite navigation ... more
service.The12 channel receiver quickly picks up satellite signals and holds ontothem, even in extreme conditions. It has an internal antenna, so itstill fits easily in your...
Postage & Packaging: free Super Saver Delivery Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours...
The eTrex H GPS from Garmin guarantees simple and reliable satellite navigation ... more
service.The12 channel receiver quickly picks up satellite signals and holds ontothem, even in extreme conditions. It has an internal antenna, so itstill fits easily in your...
Postage & Packaging: £4.39 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
A staple among outdoor enthusiasts, eTrex Summit HC features a high-sensitivity GPS ... more
receiver for peak performance in any environment and includes 24 megabytes (MB) of internal memory, a detailed basemap, crisp color screen, barometric altimeter and ele...
Postage & Packaging: Free! Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
A staple among outdoor enthusiasts, eTrex Summit HC features a high-sensitivity GPS ... more
receiver for peak performance in any environment and includes 24 megabytes (MB) of internal memory, a detailed basemap, crisp color screen, barometric altimeter and ele...
Postage & Packaging: free Super Saver Delivery Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours...