The fatted calf looks worried, for I, the Prodigal, have returned! For a bit anyway...
The fatted calf looks worried, for I, the Prodigal, have returned! For a bit anyway...
Member since:29.11.2002
Reviews:29
Members who trust:9
Think you've got problems? I've just spent three years and many's-a thousand pounds at university on a degree in English and Film that is next-to-no use in the real-world job market. Why bother? Well... because I can think of worse ways to spend three whole years than reading books and watching films, can't you?
But a lack of emploability isn't the only problem here. Because I did joint honours, I sometimes suffer from dilemmas brought on by divided loyalties. Example: which is better - the book or the film? (... which came first, the chicken or the egg?...) I've discovered the answer to use when I'm not sure. You just shrug slightly and say "Well, what you have to appreciate here is that the two media are so very different, but just for the record I thought both the texts worked well as functions of the narrative in their own particular sphere. Now... whose round is it?" And now that I've finally read the book upon which the film I saw two years ago was based, I can say this is the approach I'd take on Susanna Kaysen's 'Girl Interrupted'.
Kaysen's tale of her years in a mental hospital during her late teens in the 1960s is often, somewhat inevitably, compared to other owrks of a similar vein - particularly Sylvia Plath's 'The Bell Jar' (the novel which arguably paved the way for the whole 'depressed young woman' subgenre) and Elizabeth
Wurtzel's bestselling memoir 'Prozac Nation'. It has gained popularity in the last few years thanks to the afore-mentioned film adaptation of the same name, which garnered the Best Supporting Actress Oscar and has achieved a certain cult status. I really liked the film - despite my dubiousness about the acting skills of one Winona Ryder - and now, despite glaring differences between the two, I can state the same of the book.
It's by no means a hefty read. Most of the chapters are only a couple of pages long, neatly hemmed in by copies of Susanna Laysen's actual progress reports from the hospital, which she pbtained witht he help of a lawyer prior to starting the book. Where Sylvia Plath could ramble for pages about the hopelessly spiralling thought processes of her protagonist Esther Greenwood, Kaysen keeps everything short and to the point. Even in the passages where she describes the bleak thought patterns that accompany her mental illness, she's using a matter-of-fact tone and a brief example rather than labouring the theme.
Herein lies one of the wonderfully refreshing aspects of 'Girl, Interrupted'. Perhaps it's because Kaysen is writing in retrospect, having come through her depressive episodes and seemingly gained a sense of perspective in her distance from the subject. She doesn't write about depression in a bleak way, walling the reader up in subjective intensity until they become as numb to the words as depressives can be to the outside world.
Instead of wading through such introspection, Kaysen concentrates on events, characters, substantiality. She writes in first person through the eyes of her own borderline personalitydisorder, but it is the descriptions of the other inmates at the hospital whcih bring the text to life. She captures the alternate reality of the ward, giving examples of day-to-day details which constitute reality for the inmates, contrasting with the reality of the outside world, and even occasionally imbuing the smaller events within the sphere of the hospitalwith a significance that resonates in the real world beyond the asylum walls (The Bay of Pigs fiasco being foretold, somewhat tenuously, by Georgina's angry boyfriend and her burnt hand). Such a tendency is characteristic of magic realism, not biography, and thus lends an extra dimension to the storytelling. Of course, it's also got those ubiquitous insinuations along the lines of "Maybe I'm not mad, maybe it's actually you who's mad!" - but these aren't made any less valid just because they're a cliché of the genre.
Kaysen's writing style neatly sidestepsthe kidn of self-indulgent over-emoting that tended to become irritating in 'Prozac Nation', and shows occasional flashes of ingenious eloquence which are all the more astute and impressive when you remember this is not actually a work of fiction. The inclusion of her reports keeps us grounded ina sense of the story's tragic and shocking reality, so that the author doesn't have to keep reminding us of it and begging for our pity. The chapter in which she quotes a textbook definition of her diagnosed disorder and then critiques it is particularly memorable - she's able to raise questions about views on and treatment of mental illness without having to jump on a bandwagon and aggressively push the agenda.
What impresses most is the sense of balance all this provides - possibly the most balanced first-hand account of serious depression you're likely to read. Yet the factuality and detachment don't proclude a sense of humour and of empathy from getting through to the reader - we care about what's going to happen to these girls, and we eagerly go through the not-quite linear arrangement of narrative to find out what their fates will be.
It's interesting to note the plot elements that the film "developed". How they turned Kaysen's head nurse Valerie from a tall, thin, wisecracking demi-goddess into the matronly and rounded figure played by Whoopi Goldberg is anybody's guess - maybe it's a racial awareness thing, or maybe Whoopi channelled funds into the movie or something. It worked in the film, and the original Valerie worked in the book - it's not wrong, remember, just different. But when you strip away the high drama and subplots from the film, you're left with Kaysen's account - pared down, stark and wry; the story of a girl committed to a hospital to hang in suspended animation and observe the course of this interruption to her life. Teh account is fascinating and unique and it will stay with you - three reasons it deserves its spot at the forefront of the ever-swelling market for tales of those who are young and depressed in the land of Hope and Glory.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Don't worry about your lack of employability - I spent four years at Uni, even got a MA degree in history, and what does the real world think I'm suitable for in the job market? Bloody admin. Another great review! Alboy
s_jones_2003 26.08.2004 11:43
Great op, I really like this book & the film too, great pieces! Sarah x
Kiera13 11.08.2003 02:53
What an excellent opinion! it really was a great read. I haven't read the book, but I really enjoyed the film. But no more criticising Winona! She's wonderful (I love her...). xxx
Susanna Kaysen's Girl, Interrupted is the autobiographical story of the author's time in a ... more
psychiatric award in 1967. Sylvia Plath was a patient at the same hospital in the early 1950s so inevitably comparisons have been made between Plath's The Bell J...
Postage & Packaging: £2.75 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
Susanna Kaysen'sGirl, Interruptedis the autobiographical story of the author's time in a ... more
psychiatric award in 1967. Sylvia Plath was a patient at the same hospital in the early 1950s so inevitably comparisons have been made between Plath'sThe Bell Jara...
Postage & Packaging: £2.75 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
Susanna Kaysen's Girl, Interrupted is the autobiographical story of the author's time in a ... more
psychiatric award in 1967. Sylvia Plath was a patient at the same hospital in the early 1950s so inevitably comparisons have been made between Plath's The Bell J...
Postage & Packaging: £2.75 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
Susanna Kaysen'sGirl, Interruptedis the autobiographical story of the author's time in a ... more
psychiatric award in 1967. Sylvia Plath was a patient at the same hospital in the early 1950s so inevitably comparisons have been made between Plath'sThe Bell Jara...
Postage & Packaging: £2.75 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
Advantages: Short, mostly easy to read, hard hitting, funny in places, informative Disadvantages: Short, uncomfortable to read in places, not very uplifting