Similar offers
Postage & Packaging: £4.39
Postage & Packaging: free Super Saver Delivery
Postage & Packaging: free Super Saver Delivery
Quote-start

When Good Phones Go Bad

Quote-end

1 Feb 21st, 2006 

52 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
A nice idea

Disadvantages:
A dreadful alround performance

Recommendable No:

Detailed rating:

Look & Feel

Durability & Robustness

Battery standby time

Value for money

Range of features

sghawken

sghawken

About me:

Doh!

Member since:31.10.2005

Reviews:897

Members who trust:363

My life is very odd one day I can be working from 6am-12am, the next day I might not work at all. A priority of my life is timing; most work I receive comes to me via e-mail. Whoever gets the e-mail first is the one that gets the job. It can be very trying losing out on 8 or 9 jobs just to complete 1. I figured that an ideal way for me to access e-mails and the internet on the move was to buy a PDA enabled mobile phone.

I went into The Link, I was greeted with a variety of options, but the sales assistant swore by the Treo 600. He spent great time explaining the complexities of the phone. How the phone can suit everyone's way of life. And the cracking sales line "It's not small, but it's not big" was used, the assistant seemed proud of this revolutionary statement. I never quite had the heart to scream "MUPPET!" in his face. But I did go on his recommendation and purchase the phone. It cost me £99 sim free, which at the time seemed like a steal.

Steal =transitive and intransitive verb take something unlawfully: to take something that belongs to somebody else, illegally or without the owner's permission

There was something very illegal about this transaction, but at the time I had no idea what.


Chapter 1 The Phone Itself

The phone itself is kind of funky; it has an ordinary telephone keypad with a large variety of letter keys and symbol keys chucked in around it. This created a proper qwerty keyboard. Unlike some PDA style phones that you need to get the machine to understand your handwriting, this little baby lets you type the words in allowing quick use of e-mail, text messaging and letter writing. The phone colour is sort of a graphite colour; it often looks black and often looks silver.

What I wanted the phone for was the e-mail and internet side, yes you actually get the "proper" internet and not the nasty wap service offered on most phones. Delivery of these pages is slow, but then bare in mind your receiving and transmitting data from a 36k modem. Rather like most web pages on ordinary PC's you need to scroll down through the web pages to get to the bits you want. This can be arduous as some pages come up in a very elongated fashion. It took me 2 minutes to get to the bottom of the first page of the website I needed. You can mess about with the setting to speed things up and reduce the length of the pages, but I don't like to mess with things I don't know about.

Other facilities of the phone are a digital camera; this phone offers by far the worst digital camera I have ever seen. If you're familiar with ebay, sometimes you'll see a item for sale with a picture that is impossible to make out. This is the sort of style picture the treo gives you. Pictures seem blurred and actually a little misty snd seedy, almost like seeing an image from a low budget soft porn movie. I took a photograph of someone and the image was not really recognisable, the only way you would identify the person was if someone had told you who it was.

The phone has a media player built in, again very poor quality. The sound is only mono, and the images are difficult to see. The media is stored onto interchangeable smart cards. The card that came with the phone has enough for about 6 tracks on it. So a bigger smart card is essential.

You can obviously send traditional text messages, and more elaborate picture messages and video messages. Although the phone does not seem to have enough memory to allow the later of the three options to work.

The phone has an intel PXA270 processor built in apparently this provides an outstanding multimedia experience. Hmmmmm


Chapter 2 The Problems

The phone was new, it was not a second hand phone bought on the cheap. But within minutes of getting the phone to power up (an ordeal in itself) I found faults.

The battery on the phone is sealed into the phone, you have to charge the unit as a whole. I put the phone on charge and left it to do its thing. 29 hours later I looked at the phone and it was still charging, I powered up only to find the total charge was only 27%. Every few hours I checked again, and it went up by 1 or 2 % on each occasion. 4 days from purchase and the phones charge was only 73%, and the life was very poor. One three minute phone call meant that the phone had its battery life reduced by 7%. I realised that there was an obvious battery problem but was not going back to a link for several days, so I decided to bare with it.

The second big problem was that every time you plugged the phone in it erased the phones memory, meaning you need to go through a training process several times a day.

The third and final problem was the phone facility; the sound quality for someone receiving a call from it was appalling. I contacted several people all said I sounded like I was talking through a computer.

I could not even praise the units ease of use, it was difficult if not impossble to perform simple operations like a phone call or a text message. Saddle this with the fact that the unit intermitantly clicks on and off of transmit mode (where you can use the phone), to a non transmission mode ideally suited for airplane use.

After several days I returned to the Link to exchange the phone, the exchange was quick and painless. And no real questions were asked at the time. Unbeknown to me this was because the problems were fairly standard

Intermission HERE ARE THE SPECS

Operating system
Palm OS® 5.4 (Garnet)

Memory
32MB (23MB user accessible) non-volatile
Processor
Intel® PXA270 312MHz processor
Screen
320 x 320 colour TFT touch screen display
16-bit colour displays over 65,000 colours
Wireless
GSM/GPRS model: 850/900/1800/1900 MHz world phone
CDMA model: 800/1900 MHz nationwide phone digital phone
Bluetooth® 1.1 wireless support
Digital camera
VGA with 640x480 (0.3 mega pixels) resolution
Automatic light balancing
2x digital zoom
Integrated self-portrait mirror
Video capture
Audio
2.5mm headset jack is stereo headset compatible-requires a stereo headset adapter, sold separately, for use with standard stereo headphones
Speaker
RealPlayer included - requires SD card, sold separately
Polyphonic MIDI ring tones
External ringer on/off switch w/ vibrate mode
Keyboard
Full QWERTY key layout with backlighting
Integrated number dial pad
Key guard feature
Expansion slot
Support for Multimedia Card, SD & SDIO cards
Battery
Removable, rechargeable lithium-ion battery
Talk time: up to 6 hrs on GSM/GPRS model
Talk time: up to 6 hrs on CDMA model
Standby: up to 300 hrs on GSM/GPRS model
Standby: up to 336 hrs on CDMA model
Power/sync
Multi-connector on device
USB sync cable
AC adapter (108-32 VAC/60Hz)
Size
2.3" W x 4.4" H (excluding antenna) x 0.9" D
59mm W x 113mm H x 23mm D
Weight
6.3 ounces
178 grams

The specs are taken directly from the palm website


Chapter 3 LAW MAN

After the second handset had similar problems I decided to contact the Palm People, they were horrified that I had been able to buy the phone without a contract. That had no interest at all in the faults, the conversation was quite horrific. In fact they even threatened me with legal action against me if I failed to return the phone to The Link within 24 hours.

When I returned to the Link they told me that the Palm people were "off their rockers". And fobbed me off with a series of reason as to why they can legally sell the phones. And then after this they told me they would not accept the phone back. When I had returned the phone on a previous occasion the sales assistant had not amended the phone details on the receipt.

While sat in a nearby pub reflecting on the situation with a meal, I glanced at the phone, the IMEI number (IMEI is a unique identity given to a phone) did not match the box IMEI. With this knowledge I returned to the link, and it transpired that not only did it not match but when traced back through its life the phones were actually refurbished units, sent to the Link by Palm itself. The Link finally agreed to refund me on the discovery that the handset I had in my hand had belonged to not one, but two other people.


I cannot recommend enough that buyers avoid this phone, despite the ideal being a useful one the lack of support from palm and the lack of quality rings out. There are indeed far better phones on the market with the same facilities.
 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Handspring Treo 180

Handspring Treo 180

Flip - Infrared - Dual Band - 147 g

Rate it now

Buy Now

Sony Ericsson Satio
Handspring Treo 180g

Handspring Treo 180g

Flip - Infrared - Dual Band - 147 g

User reviews (1)

Buy Now

Apple iPhone
Handspring Treo 270

Handspring Treo 270

Flip - Infrared - Dual Band - 153 g

Rate it now

Buy Now

Nokia N97

Nokia N97

Slate - Lithium Ion - Quad Band - 150

User reviews (22)

Buy Now

Comments about this review »

LegendaryMrDude 22.04.2006 06:55

Sounds to me like I might do well to avoid the Link as well as this particular phone... Sam.

salem_witch 05.03.2006 23:54

Aww what a shame as it looked so funky!

Fuzzy98 26.02.2006 18:45

Well, you'd know all about soft porn movies! I know of the expression "It's not small, it's not big" - i've uttered it many times... Seriously though sweetheart - an excellent review and a phone i'll avoid at all costs. It's take me forever to work out how to use it and by that time it would have been superceeded by a newer model lol

Similar offers for Handspring Treo 600 »

1 to 10 out of 80 similar offers for Handspring Treo 600 Show all similar offers
Handspring Treo 600 Car Charger

Handspring Treo 600 Car Charger


Postage & Packaging:  £4.39
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days......
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace electronics
Proporta Aluminium Case Handspring Treo 600

Proporta Aluminium Case Handspring Treo 600

The Proporta Treo 600 Series Aluminium Case is beautifully designed and finished to meet ... more

the exact specifications of your Treo handheld.
Made from a lightweight, aircraft grade aluminium
with a tough anodised finish, it also includes a
soft, protective neoprene lining to keep your
device as snug as a bug in a you get the idea. Cut
outs give access to ports and controls so that you
can still use your device whilst its in the case.
Your device can also be docked in your vehicle
using the


Postage & Packaging:  free Super Saver Delivery
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 24 hours......
 Visit Shop  >
amazon electronics
Proporta Alu - Leather Case for Palm Tungsten Handspring Treo 600 / 650 - Flip Type

Proporta Alu - Leather Case for Palm Tungsten Handspring Treo 600 / 650 - Flip Type

The Proporta Treo 600 Alu-Leather Case is hand crafted to meet the exact specifications of ... more

your Treo 600. Featuring our trademark 'Screen
Saver System', which uses a sheet of rigid,
lightweight aircraft grade Aluminium to line the
Case, the Proporta Treo 600 Alu-Leather Case can
even protect your precious device screen from
crushing and impact shocks. Stylish and clever.


Postage & Packaging:  free Super Saver Delivery
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 24 hours......
 Visit Shop  >
amazon electronics
Puregadgets Exclusive Brodit Active Car Cradle Holder Tilt Swivel for Handspring Treo 600 (#968590)

Puregadgets Exclusive Brodit Active Car Cradle Holder Tilt Swivel for Handspring Treo 600 (#968590)

The active holder charges your battery when it is in the holder. The charging device ... more

connects to the PDA automatically when you put the
PDA in the holder. The holder is attached onto a
tilt swivel and can be adjusted in order to avoid
light reflection. Connects to the vehicle's
cigarette lighter socket, 12/24 Volt. Attach onto
a ProClip Mounting Platform.


Postage & Packaging:  £4.99
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace electronics
Puregadgets Exclusive Brodit Passive Car Cradle Holder Tilt Swivel for Handspring Treo 600 (#848590)

Puregadgets Exclusive Brodit Passive Car Cradle Holder Tilt Swivel for Handspring Treo 600 (#848590)

With your iPod in a holder attached onto the dashboard it is always within easy reach ... more

-safe and convenient. The holder is mounted onto a
tilt swivel so it is adjustable for avoiding light
reflection on the screen. It is easy to put the
iPod in the holder, and to take it out of the
holder. Attach onto a ProClip Mounting Platform.


Postage & Packaging:  £4.99
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 6-10 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace electronics
Proporta Aluminium Case Handspring Treo 600

Proporta Aluminium Case Handspring Treo 600

The Proporta Treo 600 Series Aluminium Case is beautifully designed and finished to meet ... more

the exact specifications of your Treo handheld.
Made from a lightweight, aircraft grade aluminium
with a tough anodised finish, it also includes a
soft, protective neoprene lining to keep your
device as snug as a bug in a you get the idea. Cut
outs give access to ports and controls so that you
can still use your device whilst its in the case.
Your device can also be docked in your vehicle
using the


Postage & Packaging:  £4.23
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace electronics
Proporta Alu - Leather Case for Palm Tungsten Handspring Treo 600 / 650 - Flip Type

Proporta Alu - Leather Case for Palm Tungsten Handspring Treo 600 / 650 - Flip Type

The Proporta Treo 600 Alu-Leather Case is hand crafted to meet the exact specifications of ... more

your Treo 600. Featuring our trademark 'Screen
Saver System', which uses a sheet of rigid,
lightweight aircraft grade Aluminium to line the
Case, the Proporta Treo 600 Alu-Leather Case can
even protect your precious device screen from
crushing and impact shocks. Stylish and clever.


Postage & Packaging:  £4.23
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace electronics
Handspring Treo 600 / 610 Replacement Battery

Handspring Treo 600 / 610 Replacement Battery

You will receive 1 high quality Rechargeable Battery. This Rechargeable Battery100% fits ... more

and is properly matching!Li-Ion Rechargeable
Battery (originally packaged factory-new
merchandise)This high capacity rechargeable
battery definitely disposes of more power than the
original rechargeable battery included in delivery
of the unit.  This rechargeable battery can be
used instead of the original rechargeable battery
without any problems and can be recharged with the
available standard power supply. The rechargeable
battery is protected and secured against
overcharge and short-circuits.Features of this
rechargeable battery:safety due to heat and
overcharge protectionreal lithium-ion rechargeable
battery, more power than the original rechargeable
batteryno memory effect  recharge your battery
whenever you likeexcellent fitting accuracy,
certified quality merchandise, not an original
accessorythe standard battery charger can still be
used


Postage & Packaging:  £1.99
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace electronics
Handspring Treo 600 Car Cup Holder - Gomadic Brand

Handspring Treo 600 Car Cup Holder - Gomadic Brand

The New Gomadic Cup Holder Car Mount allows you clear visibility and finger tip access to ... more

your device in an attractive; streamlined package.
The Cup Holder Mount promotes reliability along
with style and ease. The New Gomadic Cup Holder
Auto Holder is also the only mount on the market
with a lifetime warranty and keeps you in touch on
even the longest road trip.  Here are just some of
the highlights of this holder.


Postage & Packaging:  £6.24
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace electronics
Handspring Treo 600 USB Sync&Charge Cable

Handspring Treo 600 USB Sync&Charge Cable


Postage & Packaging:  £4.39
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace electronics


More reviews »

Handspring Treo 600 - review by hawkida

Advantages: convenient, expandable, wonderful device
Disadvantages: high charges for data transfer, some niggles with the software occasionally

Handspring Treo 600 - review by hawkida hawkida 16.02.2004 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Handspring Treo 600

Handspring Treo 600 - review by madison4

Advantages: Stylish and user friendly
Disadvantages: Stubby Arial and no bluetooth facility

Handspring Treo 600 - review by madison4 madison4 20.07.2004 (20.07.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Handspring Treo 600

Handspring Treo 600 - review by dianeo3

Advantages: All in one with a great touch screen
Disadvantages: Bulky and heavy, no MS office products

Handspring Treo 600 - review by dianeo3 dianeo3 29.01.2004 (02.02.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Handspring Treo 600

Handspring Treo 600 - review by Plodd

Advantages: Lots of functions
Disadvantages: Larger than normal phone

Handspring Treo 600 - review by Plodd Plodd 12.05.2004 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Handspring Treo 600

Handspring Treo 600 - review by xnathanx

Advantages: Small for a PDA, good features
Disadvantages: Radio quality, big for a phone

Handspring Treo 600 - review by xnathanx xnathanx 10.05.2004 (10.05.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Handspring Treo 600



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Handspring Treo 600? Click here