Katherine... 2

KatherineA

Add to my Circle of Trust

Subscribe to reviews

About me:

Member since:08.07.2004

Reviews:31

Members who trust:12

Quote-start

An Aussie White to Avoid

Quote-end
28.07.2004

Advantages:
It's Chardonnay  -  which many people like

Disadvantages:
Poor value for money

Recommendable No:

29 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful See ratings
very helpful by (86%):
  1. busby19782002
  2. purplelynne
  3. Scarlet_Ribbons
and 34 other members
helpful by (14%):
  1. CareBear
  2. petitesquirt
  3. flooda
and 3 other members

View all ratings

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Share this review on Google+

Australian wine is not what it used to be.

~ BACKGROUND ~

Five or six years ago, okay, in the UK, you could bet that any bottle of Australian wine you picked up would be very good quality and excellent value for money.

Led by Jacobs Creek, and then a host of other brands including Hardys, Penfolds and Rosemount, Australian wine in the last ten years has promoted a revolution in British wine drinking habits.

We've moved from drinking French into the New World - for where Australian wines led the way, others followed - New Zealand, USA, South Africa, Chile and Argentina.

Hardy's Stamp range of wines includes reds, whites and a rose wine. They are widely available in supermarkets and off licenses and retail around the £5 a bottle mark.

~ POOR VALUE FOR MONEY ~

For £5 a bottle now, they really are poor value for money. Spend that fiver on a good bottle of Chilean (if you like red) or South African (for excellent whites). If you want to buy now, what your £5 was getting you in Australian wine half a dozen years ago, you need to be looking at £7-£8 a bottle.

Why? The Australian wine market has rapidly expanded to keep up with the super-fast growing international demand. In short, they have had to drop quality to put enough bottles on the shelves.

Not so bad in the mid 90s when harvests were very good, but since 1999 the quality of grape harvests in Australia has been falling. And its the cheaper, bulk quality wines that suffer from this the most.

~ BLIND TASTING ~

As a long time fan of Australian wines, when Tesco did their 20% off Australian offer in May 2004, I organised a blind tasting with freinds of Australian whites. All the wines we tasted were in the £5-£6 a bottle mark.

Out top came Jacobs Creek Semillon Chardonnay. I suspect this is because the blend contains a greater proportion of Semillon grape, vs Chardonnay and I do think people's taste-buds may be suffering a certain Chardonnay fatigue. But Jacobs Creek, for the money, is probably as good as you are going to get at this price range. It was my personal favourite of the wines we tasted too.

Second was Lindemans Bin 65 Chardonnay. Its a classic Chardonnay, very smooth on the tongue with oak, but not overpowering. (Much Australian wine is oaked in oak casks which adds to the flavour. Try a wine actually described as "oaked" and one described as "unoaked" to understand the difference. More about oak when we come to the Hardys Stamp.)

Next on the list came Tesco Own Able Australian Chardonnay. This was a very new wine and surprisingly fresh tasting. Retailing at around £4 a bottle, again, it relatively good value.

Hardys Stamp came last (out of four). As I mentioned above, many Australian wines are oaked (does not have to be mentioned on the label). The oak adds a certain fullness to the palatte but can be used to try and give a poor wine a more wholesome, rounded flavour - and this is what has been done with Hardys Stamp Semillon Chardonnay. In fact, I think the oak is overpowering.

~ HARDYS STAMP CHARD-SEM TASTING NOTES ~

The Hardys Stamp has a very poor, what is called in the wine trade, mouthfeel. I would describe it as tasting pasty with a sourness that shouldn't be there. What tastes in the Jacobs Creek like a mixture of fresh grass (typical of Semillon) and caramel (typical of Chardonnay), in the Hardys Stamp is verring towards the synthetic. Bring on the day when they have to give better details of the level of chemicals that have gone into wine, I say!

In short, what's wrong with the Hardys Stamp? Answer: Too much oak, and, perhaps because of trying to compensate for poor quality grapes, too many chemicals.

~ HARDYS ~

Some more information about Hardys wines can be found here:

http://www.hardys.com.au/

Remember, I'm only reviewing one wine - there are others made by the Hardy company which aren't so easily outclassed by the close competition. But that's another review.

~ CONCLUSIONS ~

Spend your money on wine wisely. If they start offering this wine as three for ten pounds then it's a good buy. At five pounds a bottle, it's not. I'd spend my five pounds on a South African White instead these days.

  Write your own review

Share this review on Google+

« Previous review   Next review »

Rate this review »

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

Rate as exceptional

Rate as somewhat helpful

Rate as very helpful

Rate as not helpful

Rate as helpful

Rate as off topic

Write your own review Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful. Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful.   Report a problem with this review’s content

Comments about this review »

busby19782002 10.12.2004 15:21

Great review thanks for the info! I found this wine had quite a bitter aftertaste :o)

purplelynne 20.08.2004 13:48

I haven't tried this, thanks for the warning. Lynne x

Scarlet_Ribbons 20.08.2004 13:06

I much prefer red to white anyway. A good review thought. Helen xx

Add your comment

max. 2000 characters

  Post comment

Product Information »

Manufacturer's product description

Australia was the first to add Semillon to Chardonnay and has made the blend world famous. Toasty Semillon adds com...

Product details

Wine Label Hardys
White Wine Type Semillon; Chardonnay, Chardonnay
Region Australia

Ciao

Listed on Ciao since 19/09/2009

Show all Product Information

More reviews »

Review Ratings »

This review of Hardys Stamp Semillon / Chardonnay 2007/08 has been rated:

"helpful" by (14%):

  1. CareBear
  2. petitesquirt
  3. flooda

and 3 other members

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Products you might be interested in »

Hardys Crest Chardonnay

Hardys Crest Chardonnay

Region: Australia - Chardonnay, Sauvignon

Rate it now

Buy Now



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Hardys Stamp Semillon / Chardonnay 2007/08? Click here