Advantages Two games in the price of one, great hand-made graphics, cute stories, easy to learn
Disadvantages not very challenging, suitable for younger ages and not for experienced players, no time pressure
Detailed Rating
| Gameplay/Playability | |
|---|---|
| Graphics | |
| Sound | |
| Value for Money | |
| Difficulty & Complexity | |
| Longevity | Poor longevity |
The second game of the pack Holly 2: Magic Land introduces the player to a new story. When Holly's young daughter disappears, an elf tells her that she must visit the land of magic to find her child. She follows the Elf to the Magic Land where she meets many different characters and she is asked to solve various Hidden Objects games and mini challenges to find her little girl.
It’s a “seek and find” type puzzle game with a variety of mini quests in each level. The whole game is played by clicking on the items with Holly’s magic stick. The type of small games and puzzles that the player needs to solve is mainly Hidden Object games, where it is asked for example to identify the toys on the shelves. You might also have to find the objects listed in a provided list of items or find multiple versions of the same item (for example gems, toys or fruits). There are also puzzles where you search for the various objects based on their silhouettes. Finally, there are extra mini games where the player is requested to find the differences between two seemingly identical images, complete Memory tasks, assemble pictures by moving pieces or by placing them in the correct order etc.
There is a round clock on the screen that shows the available time for every episode and additional hints are available to help the player. The hints can be collected by clicking on gold pine cones or strawberries for the first and second game respectively. When you collect 3 golden items you can get an additional hint.The game has a different style from the usual hidden objects games. It took me a while to get used to the graphics and the cartoonish images were a bit confusing at first. The objects were sometimes unidentifiable and it was not clear what kind of object I was looking for. Further, there is not a big variety in the background images and many levels looked very similar.
The audio is good and it also reminds me of Christmas but it is repetitive after some time.From my experience, the game is very easy to learn, the puzzles are well designed and challenging but they are too long, with no time pressure and the hints are very easy to get.
The challenge that you will face during the game is to find the objects. Sometimes they are very well hidden in the background or they are behind other items and only a small part of them is visible so they are hard to recognise. In the first game, the Christmas Tale, there is the option to move some objects or open drawers to find the items behind them, which makes the game more interesting. By comparing the two games, I found that the Christmas Tale was a lot more difficult and demanding than the second one (the Magic Land).The games include a variety of different quests and types of items that you are asked to collect (toys, fruits, gems, leaves etc.). However, in the two series of the pack, the tasks are very similar and they are just set in a different environment. Usually, each quest requires from the player to find 20-30 items hidden in the picture. The first 17 out of 20 objects are not difficult to spot and you might find it hard when searching for the remaining 3 items, this is the part where it’s useful to use the hints. When I first played the game, I found the cartoonish appearance very cute but it made it difficult to separate the objects. Later, when I got familiar with the images it was much easier.
Concerning the time pressure, I believe that the game could be a lot more challenging if the time limits were more restrictive. In all levels, I was able to complete the games in ¼ of the time provided. Also, I realised that the game is not scored so the only challenge is to complete the level by finding the items, which is not difficult with the amount of hints provided. Therefore, there are no point rewards if you are very quick and finish the level in less than the provided time. Further, when you click on the wrong objects, you don’t lose time or have a penalty as it happens in other similar games, so you can just click randomly on the screen when you are looking for the item but you are not sure where to search. Some of the puzzles were just guessing, for example there was a mini game with different images drawn on bags and the player has to guess which country they represented. Most of the drawings weren’t clearly linked to the countries and I had to click on them randomly.The games are not very long lasting as each game can be completed in about 4 to 5 hours if you want to play it all in one sitting. We finished the first part in 4 days, and we were playing together for about one hour daily. The second game had easier tasks and it was somewhat quicker. I have played better Hidden Objects Games, this one is quite different but I think it is more interesting for young players.
Overall, this game is like a fairytale with rich and cute graphics but not much challenge. It is probably not very interesting for experienced players and adults but it’s a good and enjoying Christmas gift for young children. It’s not a game that I would choose to buy for myself and I would recommend to take advantage of the 1-hour free trial before purchasing.
This review may be published on other sites in the future
Attention, this is the first review from this author
Instead of giving a negative rating, consider:

Help this member by giving your advice

Report fraud (for example plagiarism) or other issue with the review to the Ciao support team
Add your comment
trayrope 11/01/2013 08:33
Gingerkitty 26/10/2012 11:03
Excellent review x
wazza115 13/09/2012 18:36
karalouk 17/07/2012 22:20
lillamarta 21/02/2012 10:12