Is There a Text in This Class?: The Authority of Interpretive Communities - Stanley Fish

Is There a Text in This Class?: The Authority of Interpretive Communities - Stanley Fish > Reviews > good book

Non-Fiction - Arts & Music - Literary Criticism & Theory - ISBN: 0674467256 more

Overall user rating Is There a Text in This Class?: The Authority of Interpretive Communities - Stanley Fish 2 reviews | Write a review | Add product to list





Please wait ....
Rate this product:  
 
All Is There a Text in This Class?: The Authority of Interpretive Communities - Stanley Fish reviews Previous review
good book


Author's product rating:   Is There a Text in This Class?: The Authority of Interpretive Communities - Stanley Fish - rated by eminemis_the_best

Degree of Information Very high 
How interesting was the book? Compelling 
How useful was it? Indispensable 
Would you read it again? Absolutely 
Value for money Excellent 

Advantages: easy to read
Disadvantages: to long

Recommend to potential buyers: yes 

Full review
Literary theory has long grappled with the question of who is central to a text. Can the author reliably convey his or her ideas to the reader, or is the reader in charge, putting their own interpretation on what we see or read?

At one extreme are Marxist literary theorists, such as Terry Eagleton, or Raymond Williams, who argue that culture is constructed out of society, and it is only through an analysis of society that we can understand it. Thus the author is in charge, conveying ideas by means of a shared inheritance of concepts which can change society and be understood by it.

At the other end of the spectrum is deconstruction. This, asserted by Jacques Derrida and Roland Barthes, means that there are no limits to the interpretation we can put on a text, or indeed on what a text actually is. Barthes once famously analysed a wrestling match for its literary significance, for example. We are free to take whatever we want from culture, and hence the author is powerless, as there is no way that he or she can foresee the effect their words will have. Instead, the reader is in charge (structuralism), or no-one is in charge (post-structuralism), the text simply exists. Both these approaches negate any need to consider the history surrounding a book, the biography of the author, or what he or she was trying to say. They simply delight in the play of words and the possibilities that exist.

Both of these approaches are original and valid attempts to understand culture. Fruitful argument can be had on one side or the other. However, Fish's theory comes into neither category.

In the middle is Stanley Fish. His theory of "interpretive communities" states there are many different ways of approaching a text. However, we can be categorised into groups who will read a text in a certain way.

For example, (read my review of Casualty for more information) there are many people out there who actually enjoy Casualty and Holby City, think the storylines are meaningful and the acting superb. Me and my housemate use watching medical drama as an excuse to get drunk and throw corks at the telly whenever something really bad happens. Yet other people just watch it because there is nothing else on, or for something to listen to in thebackground. Different interpretive communities.

Why Stanley Fish feels it necessary to explain this concept ad nauseam in over 300 pages of writing, is beyond me.

His theory is one of sitting on the fence, of picking and choosing between two radical theories, and in the end achieving nothing, other than saying that different groups of people can read different things into a text. This is a commonsense statement that gets you nowhere as far as analysis, or seeing a text differently is concerned.

I read this book only because i had to. While it is fairly accessible, Fish outlines a wishy-washy, middle-of-the-road theory that does not advance literary theory one iota 
Write your own review




More details
How easy was it to read / get information from Very easy 

Evaluate this review
How helpful would this review be to someone making a buying decision?
Rating guidelines

   

Comments on this review
More options
All Is There a Text in This Class?: The Authority of Interpretive Communities - Stanley Fish reviews Previous review

Products you might be interested in
Colonial Discourse and Post-Colonial Theory (A Reader) - Laura Chrisman, Patrick WilliamsColonial Discourse and Post-Colonial Theory (A Reader) - Laura Chrisman, Patrick Williams

Non-Fiction - Arts & Music - Literary Criticism & Theory - ISBN: 0745014917

 1 review

Buy now for only £ 25.59

The Magic of Thinking Big - David J SchwartzThe Magic of Thinking Big - David J Schwartz

Non-Fiction - Arts & Music - Literary Criticism & Theory - ISBN: 0135471346, 0671854216, 0671854542, 072250943X, 1416511555

 1 review

Buy now for only £ 4.13

The Artists Way - Julie CameronThe Artists Way - Julie Cameron

Non-Fiction - Arts & Music - Literary Criticism & Theory - ISBN: 0330343580

 2 reviews

Buy now for only £ 4.50

Adobe Photoshop CS3 for Photographers: A Professional Image Editor's Guide to the Creative Use of Photoshop for the Macintosh and PC - Martin EveningAdobe Photoshop CS3 for Photographers: A Professional Image Editor's Guide to the Creative Use of Photoshop for the Macintosh and PC - Martin Evening

Non-Fiction - Arts & Music - Art & Design - ISBN: 240520289

This product has not yet been reviewed. Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 17.50

British Hit Singles and Albums (Guinness 19th Edition)British Hit Singles and Albums (Guinness 19th Edition)

 1 review

Buy now for only £ 59.99

Our Wedding Anniversary Memory BookOur Wedding Anniversary Memory Book

This product has not yet been reviewed. Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 11.41

If on a Winter's Night a Traveller - Italo CalvinoIf on a Winter's Night a Traveller - Italo Calvino

Non-Fiction - Arts & Music - Literary Criticism & Theory - ISBN: 0436082713, 0749399236

 1 review

Buy now for only £ 3.01

I Want Those Shoes - Paola Jacobbi, Simonetta WenkertI Want Those Shoes - Paola Jacobbi, Simonetta Wenkert

Non-Fiction - Arts & Music - Art & Design - ISBN: 0747582467

This product has not yet been reviewed. Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 0.01

In VogueIn Vogue": The Illustrated History of the World's Most Famous Fashion Magazine - Alberto Oliva, Norberto Angeletti

Non-Fiction - Arts & Music - Art & Design - ISBN: 0847828646

This product has not yet been reviewed. Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 24.86




Are you the manufacturer / provider of Is There a Text in This Class?: The Authority of Interpretive Communities - Stanley Fish? Click here