Quote-start

Beautiful Car ... but with very irritating flaw.

Quote-end

4 Aug 5th, 2004  (Aug 25th, 2004)

31 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Features, Build Quality, Safety, Looks, Reliable

Disadvantages:
Painfully Under - Powered at Low Revs

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Road Handling

Comfort

Fuel consumption

Looks

Whinger

Whinger

About me:

My 'About me' used to once state: "The butcher with the sharpest knife has the warmest heart&qu...

Member since:29.03.2004

Reviews:12

Members who trust:8

INTRO
My last ever company car before I went 'solo' (i.e self employed) was a Silver Lexus IS200, The SE (Special Equipment Version). I very much doubt you'll have any idea just how badly (prior to getting one of these, that is) I wanted to have one of these - even if you do regard the car as being desireable, I still feel that my (albeit highly subjective) sentiments for 'top-tier' Japanese cars - might make me seem to some people as perhaps even a bit weird! You see ... I have always put what I have held to be the flagships of Japanese automotive engineering, on a pedestal, head and shoulders above the rest ... and that includes the likes of BMW for that matter. If any doubt about the veracity of my statement in the last sentence then I have only three words to say in response "Nissan - Skyline - GTR" - if anyone thought that only the Germans could make a car with decent handling then ... well ... I always find it highly amusing to consider that from what I understand ...for a goodly amount of time ... there was NOTHING Germany could throw at it that could hope to topple the Nissan Skyline GTR Version R32 (a.k.a. 'Godzilla', affectionately) from its throne - being the car that held onto the lap record for the Nurburgring as well as it holds the road - and that's just one example (there are of course others such as Mitsubishi GTO, Mitsubishi Lancer EVO 6, Subaru Impreza WRX etc. etc. etc.)

OHH!! DECISIONS, DECISIONS ....
Now, without the budget to buy and run a Skyline GTR (I swear I WILL own one of these legends on 4 wheels one of these days!!!!) - I had a choice of buying either something like a low spec 'Beemer' (perhaps a 316i or 318i) with a modicum of extra equipment (Gee-Whiz!! perhaps, .... Gasp!! .... even, air-con if I was lucky!?!!) or for a shade under £20,000 (at the time in 2001) I could get a 'Fully-Loaded' as Standard Lexus IS200 with the following spec:

Air Conditioning with Climate Control,
Heated Leather Seats, Totally Electrically Adjustable
6 Speaker Sound System with 6-Disc Autochanger Built-in,
Elec Windows,
Elec Folding and heated Wing Mirrors,
2-Litre 6 Cylinder 153BHP Variable Valve Timing 24-Valve All Alloy Engine
6 Speed Manual Close Ratio Gearbox
17" 5-Spoke Alloys
Electronically Managed Traction Control, Stability Control and ABS
4 Airbags (Front Driver and Passenger + Side Driver and Passenger)
Front Windscreen De-Icer (as well as rear of course)
Electric Sunroof
Rear Boot/Trunk That opens remotely (i.e without you having to physically touch it)
State of the art Alarm/Immobiliser

That wasnt of course the half of it ... the car looked beautiful and had a charisma and character about its road-presence that in my mind the BMW could only ever dream of having ... I did say I was a bit of a Jap Car nut didn't I? And Maybe I AM!!! ... In the film The Fast and The Furious the 'hero' cars were all Japanese save for the only German car in the film which lost its race to a Honda S2000 and of course the Ferrari F355 Spyder that got 'smoked' at the lights by 'Star of the Show' 3rd Generation Toyota Supra Twin Turbo.

The IS200 looked like it had the same sort of story to tell: Alledgedly Peppy Performance, good Equipment, Build Quality and of Course reliability .....

I found the car: RELIABLE, VERY WELL EQUIPPED, COMFORTABLE, STYLISH, SAFE, AND WITH GOOD 'ROAD MANNERS' ... but all this was eclipsed sadly by a couple of seemingly notable flaws:

SO WHAT WAS WRONG WITH IT?
Well, I could NEVER fault the equipment, the build quality, or the reliability. But .... the Engine ......... ARRRRRGGGHHHHH !!!!!!! It just had such feeble power delivery below 4,000 rpm. Ok, fair enough, if you like thrashing a car's engine hard day-in-day-out to get anywhere then .... well ... fine .... enjoy! As for me I like to arrive at work or what ever my destination, relaxed, settled and at peace - not feeling like I have just had to race Vin Diesel or Paul Walker for the title in an illegal street race. Quite simply, there was either not enough pull away onto a round-about if I kept the revs low (and people would beep me) or else I would have to change up at at least around 4,000 to 4,500 RPM to get anywhere without cutting someone up. I think the engine was only 'happy' and delivering the goods in excess of 4,500RPM ... and true ... when I was in the mood for going on a nice long weekend A-Road Drive the car did not disappoint. But in normal run of the mill daily life I have found that both the 2-Litre and 1.8 Litre Toyota Avensis (neither of which 'profess' to be sports saloons) that I have also driven were much more responsive and useful (and far less dramatic) in daily commuting traffic! I guess V.V.T. (Variable Valve Timing) engines are powerful and impressive but can prove very sluggish at low revs, particularly if they are having to move a solid and well built bodyshell.

GEARBOX
Again a similar story ... everything ran smoothly but only when you were 'On-Cam' so to speak ... in fact the gearchange from 3rd to 4th when pushing the engine hard (and only on motorways in countries such as France or Germany - where a higher than 70 m.p.h. speed limit is permitted, of course!) emits a truly beautiful sound, shifting up, as you can really 'hear', as well as feel, the promise of what I feel is a truly sporty close-ratio gearbox. However change gear like any normal commuter might be likely to do in typical London traffic (whilst trying to get somewhere but save fuel as much as possible) and I found it baulky, 'gritty' and just totally unsmooth .... unlike most other manual Jap gearboxes that I have had the pleasure of using, which have always been as smooth as silk.

A BIG SHAME
There was/is nothing else that riles me about the car. Some people dont find the 'Sports Chronometer' style Speedo and Rev Counter Display to be particularly attractive. I however had no such problem with it ... in fact I found it quite appealing. The controls are all light and the steering wheel is perfectly weighted with just the right amount of 'feel' for a power assisted steer (if a little under-geared). The car holds the road well - although it's wise to keep the Anti-WheelSpin/Traction Control applied at all times in snowy weather (my one switched this function off every time you have finished driving, so had to be re-switched on/engaged every time a new journey was embarked upon), I remember one embarrasing time when I had only had the car a week or so and the ground was full of snow and I was driving up a slight incline in Mill Hill and the car simply went nowhere and it was only later that I realised the Anti-WheelSpin had reset itself to off!!

VERDICT
I would still recommend it - but if you are going to drive in town then, for heaven's sake, get one with an Auto 'Box or get the IS300 (3 Litre Version) which has enough low-end 'guts' to propel the car off from a standstill in those typical London Rush Hour Commuting situations without needing to wail like a banshee! Yes it's still a good car and can be great fun to drive if you dont have to use it to commute! And it's not a slow car per se, it's just not particularly nippy when you might need it most in traffic , in fact I would go as far as saying that, actually, out of town, it is rather rapid in accelerative response after 60 mph .... but this is not really suitable for a country with heavy congestion, a need for greater road safety, a 70 M.P.H. max speed limit and of course speed cameras. The Toyota Avensis I currently drive (which was my own purchase, not a company car) does everything, in this particular respect , with far less drama. A great shame as the IS200 is so fine in all other respects - I just didn't fancy having to rev the engine hard like Messrs Schumacher in order to perform menial tasks such as getting to work and back. 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Lexus IS 220d

Lexus IS 220d

Saloon - Rear (RWD) - 6 Speed Manual Gearbox - 2231 cc - Maximum Speed: 135 mph - 175 bhp - Diesel - Available Trims: SE-L, SE-I, SE

User reviews (1)

Buy Now

Lexus RX 300 3.0

Lexus RX 300 3.0

4 X 4, Estate - Four Wheel Drive (4x4) - 5 Speed Automatic Gearbox - 2995 cc - Maximum Speed: 124 mph - 201 bhp - Petrol - Available Trims: SE-L, SE

User reviews (4)

Buy now for only £ 3,250.00

Lexus IS 300 3.0 24v

Lexus IS 300 3.0 24v

Saloon, Estate, Hatchback - Rear (RWD) - 5 Speed Automatic Gearbox - 2997 cc - Maximum Speed: 143 mph - 211 bhp - Petrol

User reviews (1)

Buy Now

Lexus GS 300/430
Lexus IS 250

Lexus IS 250

Saloon - Rear (RWD) - 6 Speed - Automatic, 6 Speed - Manual - 2499 cc - Maximum Speed: 144 mph - 204 bhp - Petrol - Available Trims: SE-L, SE-I, SE

Rate it now

Buy Now

Lexus LS 400

Comments about this review »

kmc25_1 11.11.2005 11:46

Great car. Got a spin in one recently and was mighty impressed.

buzzard_cad 19.09.2005 23:19

A good review, all I got was a Ffffff Ford Focus and it is a diesel. Sheesh, why didn't they let me keep the old Cavalier SRi. At least it could pull away from a junction? Martin.

shotgun_norman 26.05.2005 12:01

Its good to finally hear some drawbacks with this car!



More reviews »

Lexus IS 200 2.0 24v - review by markd_uk

Advantages: Good level of equipment, comfortable, sporty
Disadvantages: Slightly sluggish with auto, cramped interior, poor boot space

Lexus IS 200 2.0 24v - review by markd_uk markd_uk 27.09.2004 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Lexus IS 200 2.0 24v

Lexus IS 200 2.0 24v - review by eduardob

Advantages: Stylish, bullet proof build, tons of equipment and not a BMW.
Disadvantages: Poor fuel consumption and performance for it's class and not a BMW.

Lexus IS 200 2.0 24v - review by eduardob eduardob 29.01.2004 (29.01.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Lexus IS 200 2.0 24v

Lexus IS 200 2.0 24v - review by FantasticMrFox

Advantages: Customer Service, Build Quality, Value for Money
Disadvantages: Alloy Wheel Salt Erosion Pitting

Lexus IS 200 2.0 24v - review by FantasticMrFox FantasticMrFox 12.08.2004 (12.08.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Lexus IS 200 2.0 24v

Lexus IS 200 2.0 24v - review by InspectorGadget

Advantages: Lexus quality
Disadvantages: none

Lexus IS 200 2.0 24v - review by InspectorGadget InspectorGadget 02.08.2000 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Lexus IS 200 2.0 24v

Lexus IS 200 2.0 24v - review by Slideways

Advantages: Good looks and sporty appearance
Disadvantages: Lack of performance / power

Lexus IS 200 2.0 24v - review by Slideways Slideways 31.03.2001 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Lexus IS 200 2.0 24v



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Lexus IS 200 2.0 24v? Click here