blackpudd... 5

blackpuddinonnabike

Add to my Circle of Trust

Subscribe to reviews

About me:

Member since:03.11.2003

Reviews:66

Members who trust:4

Quote-start

The best things come in small(ish) packages

Quote-end
23.04.2009

Advantages:
Performance; Running Costs; Looks (for some)

Disadvantages:
Ubiquity; Looks (for some); Interior isn't as nice as the previous model

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Value for Money

Road Handling

Comfort

Features

Looks

Fuel consumptionGood

15 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful See ratings
very helpful by (96%):
  1. TheHairyGodmother
  2. Soho_Black
  3. paulpry118
and 20 other members
helpful by (4%):
  1. ebarnden1

View all ratings

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Share this review on Google+

The BMW Mini is something of a 'love it, hate it' car. People seem to be put off because you see them everywhere, and they appear to have become somewhat de rigeur for estate agents and the like. Personally I love them, and when we decided to replace our 4 year old Mini One it was a fruitless search to find something for around the same price that we thought would offer quite the same fun.

We were looking to upgrade really. The Cooper S was what I really wanted, and competitors were thin on the ground. The Clio 127 is a bit cheaper, with similar performance, but just didn't do it for me. It was a story repeated a few times. The reason we'd started looking at other cars, though, was because our original new Mini (if you see what I mean) was the old new style, and the new styling, brought in a couple of years back, was different enough for us to think it wasn't quite as nice.

That, however, was almost completely forgotten on a first test drive. A couple of months down the line and I know we've once again made the right decision by sticking with Mini.

LOOKS

As I said earlier the looks are subjective, so if you don't like how it looks I can't really say you're wrong. The reason I like it is partly because it's different from most lookalike boxes on the road (it tends to be the 'retro' styled that look different, like the new Beetle and Fiat 500). But different isn't enough on its own, and here you stray into unquantifiable personal taste.

It floats my boat, simple as that. I've got over the initial misgivings. It's a squatter, slightly fatter looking, car than the original redesign. But it retains those retro cues, the cheeky wee headlights, and with some 17 inch alloys, bonnet scoop, and rear spoiler, it looks like it means business.

PERFORMANCE

Plant your foot in this car and you'll soon realise you're in a very hot hatch indeed. With a 0-60 time of around 7.1 seconds, propelled along by a torquey turbo-charged 175bhp 1.6 engine, you will be pushed back into your seat with a grin slapped onto your face. The performance does have a slightly 'hooligan' feel to it. Not quite as raw as a Clio 127, but you wrestle the steering wheel to remain on the straight and narrow as torque-steer from the engine sets in.

The speed off the line is matched, and in some cases exceeded, by the speed you can carry round corners. Our old 'One' felt like it was on rails, but with the better tyres, and stiffened suspension, it feels as if you've got grip that could go on for weeks. The little traction control light might flash up occasionally on the dash, but the involving nature of the drive is such that you generally know exactly what is going on underneath.

Mind you, with that hard suspension and power output, hit a bump going through a corner and it once again feels like you're having to fight it every step of the way.

Remarkably with all of this performance, the mpg figures (a combined total of 45mpg) are better than in our old 'One', and shame many other little sportscars. As do the carbon dioxide emissions, which put this in a lower VED bracket than pretty much all of its competitors.

INSIDE

The new Mini is often derided for being short on internal space, certainly when compared to its external dimensions, and what other similar cars can offer inside. To complain about these things slightly misses the point (and it's an aspect that doesn't seem to have harmed sales).

That said, we've comfortable sat 4 adults in it, and even managed 5 for one small hop. The driver's seat has to be moved a bit further forward than I'd normally drive to accommodate rear passengers, but it's a minor inconvenience.

Equally, while the boot IS tiny, there's enough space to fit in a decent amount of groceries, and if you pop the rear seats down flat you suddenly have a large space to work with. Our old car took us to and from Skye a number of times, loaded up with all-sorts for a self-catering trip, and the new car will be doing the same in June this year (got to love those twisting country roads).

The styling inside is one thing which I think lets the new car down. Some people thought the old car had gone a little too far with the retro look, but I tihnk the new car looks a little dowdy in comparison. It benefits from the optional chrome lining inside sprucing things up, and it's still a step above grey and black plastic overload, but the old car just felt nicer to sit in.

That's not to say it's a bad interior for occupants. I'm 6'3" tall and can fit in to drive perfectly well, with bags of headroom thanks to a height adjustable seat (and lowering down just adds to that feeling of driving a go-kart).

COST

Another accusation launched at the Mini is the expense. Of course this was tempered for us catching this new car in the middle of the economic downturn, meaning we got the optional Chilli pack (with things like air conditioning and height adjustable passenger seat - option we would have chosen anyway) for half price, money off the base price, and a higher trade-in price on the old car. Offers never before seen at Mini.

Compare it to other small cars and it's not actually that expensive. The Clio 127 is cheaper, but at around £18k we paid less than you would for a new Mazda MX-5, little Volvo, or fast Golf (if you wanted something with the same performance).

And to run the mileage figures mentioned above, together with lower VED band, shows that it's cheaper to run on an annual basis.

And then add in the bombproof build quality of a BMW (who I normally hate, but will forgive for the Mini. This car is definitely screwed together more tightly than the older model) and the offer of free servicing for three years, and the cost over the lifetime of the car looks better and better.

OVERALL

If you already have a predisposed hatred to the new Mini then nothing said above is going to change your mind.

All I can say is that looking at pure 'bang for your buck' the Mini delivers for me every time. It's still a pleasure to walk out to it, hop in, and hit that start button. It's even more of a pleasure now to see what it can do...

The only final thing I'd say is that if you get one of these be prepared for plenty people telling you it isn't a 'real' Mini. For some reason being bigger than the original, for some, renders it a bad car. Okay, so maybe the name doesn't quite fit, but if you get past a semantic dislike, you could find that this is more fun than you realised.
Pictures of MINI Cooper S
MINI Cooper S car1 - BMW Mini Cooper S
BMW Mini Cooper S
  Write your own review

Share this review on Google+

  Next review »

Rate this review »

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

Rate as exceptional

Rate as somewhat helpful

Rate as very helpful

Rate as not helpful

Rate as helpful

Rate as off topic

Write your own review Write a review and you will earn 1p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful. Write a review and you will earn 1p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful.   Report a problem with this review’s content

Comments about this review »

kevin121 30.04.2009 10:00

Out of my price range, even with the good offers you discuss, but hey, I can still look on with envy!

becky_tredget 23.04.2009 21:08

I have a mini one, and i love it. I have always loved the mini series. Great Review. :o)

mythdata 23.04.2009 19:57

I bought mine last year, then I got another dog so its only used when me and the two dogs go out, as there is no room for the hubby LOL .... I could always strap him to the roof :O) I got a great deal as I part exchanged my MX5 Hairdresser car.

Add your comment

max. 2000 characters

  Post comment

Compare prices »

1 to 2 out of 2 offers for MINI Cooper S   Sorted by: Price 
FK-Automotive Coilover Königsport Mini Cooper S Yr. 2001-2006

FK-Automotive Coilover Königsport Mini Cooper S Yr. 2001-2006

- Galvanized Steel strut housing - with Wrenches & Coilover Spray - Hardness Adjustable - ... more

Gives a sporty setup - Yr:04.2002 - with TÜV -
Lowering appx. 25

 Visit Shop  >
carparts-tuning.co.u...
Postage & Packaging£0.00
Availability1-2 days
carparts-tuning.co.uk

Product Information »

Manufacturer's product description

MINI present the Cooper S 3dr Hatchback with 6 Speed - (Man) / 6 Speed - (Auto), Front (FWD) running on Unleaded Pe...

Product details

Long Name Cooper S 3dr
Series Cooper S
Engine Type 1.6

Ciao

Listed on Ciao since 27/12/2006

Show all Product Information

More reviews »

Review Ratings »

This review of MINI Cooper S has been rated:

"helpful" by (4%):

  1. ebarnden1

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Products you might be interested in »

Mini Cooper Convertible

Mini Cooper Convertible

Convertible, Coupe - Front (FWD) - 5 Speed - (Man) / CVT - (Auto), 5 Speed - (Man) / CVT - (Auto) - 1598 cc - Max Speed: 120 mph - 115 bhp - Petrol

User reviews (6)

Buy Now

MINI Cooper

MINI Cooper

Hatchback - Front (FWD) - 5 Speed - (Man) / CVT - (Auto), 6 Speed Automatic, 6 Speed Manual - 1598 cc - Max Speed: 124, 126 mph - 115, 120 bhp - Petrol

User reviews (58)

Buy Now

Rover Mini Cooper 1.6

Rover Mini Cooper 1.6

Hatchback - 1598 cc - 211 bhp - Petrol

User reviews (10)

Buy Now



Are you the manufacturer / provider of MINI Cooper S? Click here