noodlebut... 4

noodlebutty

Add to my Circle of Trust

Subscribe to reviews

About me: check out the Let Toys Be Toys campaign on fb and twitter

Member since:11.11.2005

Reviews:150

Members who trust:76

Quote-start

"Musha, God Bless the News-Teller"

Quote-end
18.11.2010

Advantages:
fascinating insight into a lost way of life

Disadvantages:
no photos, no 'warts'

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Degree of Information

How easy was it to read / get information from

How interesting was the book?

How useful was it?

Would you read it again?

Value for money

70 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful See ratings
exceptional by (28%):
  1. malihat
  2. Deesrev
  3. tallulahbang
and 18 other members
very helpful by (72%):
  1. silverstreak
  2. GillyMN
  3. fizzytom
and 52 other members

View all ratings

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Share this review on Google+

Muiris Ó Súilleabháin, (also known as Maurice O'Sullivan), was born in 1904 on the remote island of Great Blasket situated off the Dingle Peninsula, County Kerry. One of the last outposts of traditional Irish culture and language, the island was visited in the early part of last century by several English scholars who wished to study the language and way of life. As a result of this, some of the islanders were encouraged to write their memoirs which were published to much interest, giving the tiny island a disproportionately rich literary output. 'Fiche Blian ag Fás' was published in 1933 and the later English Translation, 'Twenty Years A-Growing' was acclaimed as a world classic upon publication by the Oxford University Press in 1953.

I stumbled across 'Twenty Years A-Growing' in a charity shop earlier this year, having no knowledge of any of this. Attracted by it's seeming authenticity, it's age, cover photo, and an interest in Irish history I instantly forked out the 50p or thereabouts necessary to purchase it. My copy has the original introductory note written in 1933 by E M Forster and a preface by the translators Moya Llewellyn Davies and George Thomson. These are interesting period pieces in themselves, occasionally patronising, with Forster calling the book; "an account of neolithic civilisation from the inside."

A sentence from the first page sets the tone;

"I am a boy who was born and bred in the Great Blasket, a truly small Gaelic island which lies north west of the coast of Kerry, where the storms of the sky and the wild sea beat without ceasing from end to end of the year and from generation to generation against the wrinkled rocks which stand above the waves that wash in and out of the coves where the seals make their homes."

Here is a read that won't be rushed. In her preface, Llewellyn Davies writes of the Irish vocabulary having more range and 'poetry' than the language into which it has been translated. Much it seems is lost in the translation, apparently some of the original passages are also not in the English version. Nonetheless, it still translates well. The author's voice is conveyed in sing-song Irish dialect and the dialogue sounds authentic enough to me.

There are a few Irish words and sayings left in the text, some of which are explained in notes throughout, while others are left to be interpreted by the reader. 'Musha' is one such, which was used all over the place and I came to understand as being both an exclamation and a term of endearment. At times this reads more like a series of anecdotes than a narrative story. The style is direct, fervent in it's expression yet also polite and touchingly naive. I found it did take a little getting used to both dialect and style, but it wasn't too long before I was quite captivated.

The story takes us through O'Sullivan's life in a series of snapshots. It's rich with detail, special days are focused on, then years skip by in an instant. The community eke out their livelihood from land and sea, choose their own 'King' and have limited contact with outsiders. Most people will agree that life on the island is harsh, but at times it also seems idyllic.

An early chapter describes a day out hunting for rabbits, puffins and birds eggs; Maurice, his pal Tomas and their dogs, Topsy and Beauty. It's a simple story but crystal clear in the telling. The sense of setting is perfectly evoked, beautiful in it's detail, the memory told so well that I felt myself there, longed to be back there almost. Years old conversations are recounted in depth, how exact they are I couldn't say, but as one of the main sources of entertainment for the islanders, conversation was treated as a form of art. Particularly enlightening are Maurice's chats with 'Daddo', his grandfather. If Maurice's lifestyle is in the main forgotten, how much more so the days of his grandfather? Daddo harks back to a time when they had no flour, tea or sugar. He thinks the islanders are being made weak with fancy food and shoe wearing children, although he has fond memories of a shipwreck that left them with enough wheat for a year so that they lived 'the lives of gentlemen while it lasted'.

One of my favourite parts is a tale from Daddo about how the men on the island came to be lobster fishermen. His story of a trip out in the curragh, (a boat), in which the men discovered a strange rope left by some English fishermen and lifted it out of the water is an absolute joy. One of the men is convinced that they have pulled up, "the old fellow...the devil himself." It's a tale that really brings across the isolation in which the community lived. The idea of someone being terrified by a lobster seem quite comical today, but it's impossible to know how you would feel if it was something completely unknown.

It's strange to think that this took place only a few generations ago, Maurice's parents were the same generation as my own Irish great grandparents of whom I have scarce knowledge. It made me wonder how similar the lives described in 'twenty years' would have been to those of my own ancestors who left Ireland at the same time as many of Maurice's friends and family as they joined with the mass emigration to America, many of them ending up in Liverpool.

I also wondered how much was hidden. Whilst Maurice covers all sorts of events and incidents; Halloween celebrations, a wake, a trip to Ventry races (now known as the Ventry Regatta), amongst the amusing anecdotes I found myself looking for undercurrents of abuse. Wrong perhaps, but maybe a reflection of the fact that we are nowadays so used to 'misery lit' that a simple tale such as this seems like it's not telling the whole story. O'Sullivan takes an obvious pride in his heritage and his book is filled with love for the people and place he grew up with, it feels disrespectful to ask whether he saw it all through the rose-tinted glasses of an exile, (he moved to Connemara on the mainland).

One thing that could have improved the book for me would have been a few photo's, I don't know if there are any in other editions. I have found a photo of Maurice and his house on a Kerry tourist website, (http://www.kerryholiday.co.uk/blaskets.html#village), as well as a picture of The King's House - the description and the picture seem ludicrously far removed from each other. For me, 'Twenty Years A-Growing' delivered on it's early promise to transport me entirely to a completely different world and involve me in a long lost way of life. It's something of a forgotten classic and I'm not sure the style of writing would appeal to modern consumers used to the warts and all style of storytelling so prevalent today, but for those interested in the old ways it's an invaluable read.

The last inhabitants left the Great Blasket in 1953, the same year O'Sullivans book was being published in the English language. These days the island is visited only by tourists.

Details: 312 pages, published by Oxford Paperbacks; New Ed edition (17 Feb 1983). Currently priced £5.99 new on Amazon.

Pictures of Twenty Years A-Growing - Maurice O'Sullivan
Twenty Years A-Growing - Maurice O'Sullivan Twenty Years A-Growing - Maurice O'Su
Cover on my copy
  Write your own review

Share this review on Google+

 

Rate this review »

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

Rate as exceptional

Rate as somewhat helpful

Rate as very helpful

Rate as not helpful

Rate as helpful

Rate as off topic

Write your own review Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful. Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful.   Report a problem with this review’s content

Comments about this review »

silverstreak 02.02.2011 09:46

Fascinating stuff.

GillyMN 30.12.2010 16:15

"Peig", also written by a native of Blasket, is the bane of Irish Children learning Irish! This one is far more readable. Good balanced review.

malihat 01.12.2010 15:37

Excellent review. Sounds like a good read.

Add your comment

max. 2000 characters

  Post comment

Compare prices »

1 offer for Twenty Years A-Growing - Maurice O'Sullivan   Sorted by: Price 

Product Information »

Product details

Edition Paperback
Author Maurice O'Sullivan
Original Release Year 1983
EAN 9780192813251
ISBN 0192813250

Show all Product Information

Review Ratings »

This review of Twenty Years A-Growing - Maurice O'Sullivan has been rated:

"exceptional" by (28%):

  1. malihat
  2. Deesrev
  3. tallulahbang

and 18 other members

"very helpful" by (72%):

  1. silverstreak
  2. GillyMN
  3. fizzytom

and 52 other members

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Products you might be interested in »

The Real Mrs Brown - Brian Beacom

The Real Mrs Brown - Brian Beacom

(+) Interesting read, ideal read for the summer, lots of information about Brendan O'Carroll's life
(-) I did find the comparisons between Brendan's life and Mrs Brown slightly annoying after a while

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 26.16

The Mystery of Princess Louise Queen Victoria's Rebellious Daughter  - Lucinda Hawksley

The Mystery of Princess Louise Queen Victoria's Rebellious Daughter - Lucinda Hawksley

(+) Lively life of a lively, unconventional woman
(-) Some unfortunate historical howlers

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 14.36

The Devonshires The Story of a Family and a Nation - Roy Hattersley

The Devonshires The Story of a Family and a Nation - Roy Hattersley

(+) Interesting, readable and comprehensive family biography
(-) A little dry at times

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 7.23



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Twenty Years A-Growing - Maurice O'Sullivan? Click here