Compare Prices
Postage & Packaging: Free!

Maybelline Great Lash

Quote-start

Lashtastic

Quote-end

5 May 14th, 2007 

131 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Doesn't clump or flake, natural looking, cheap

Disadvantages:
None

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Ease of Application

Waterproof?

Does it irritate your eyes?

rd52169

rd52169

About me:

Thanks for reading and rating my reviews. Will try to return all read & rates, let me know if I have...

Member since:22.07.2004

Reviews:30

Members who trust:100

I have been using this mascara for years and years now. I think I first tried it because many years ago I read in a magazine that it was a favourite of beauty editors and make up artists. I have tried many different types of mascara since but I always go back to this little gem.

This is apparently the No. 1 mascara in the USA. It promises perfectly defined lashes with a clean, separate finish, and that the lash building brush makes lashes fuller and longer with no clumps. It is widely available and costs £4.99 in Boots (think it costs less in Tesco) and the tube contains 12.5ml. It comes in three shades, Blackest Black, Very Black and Brown. I normally buy Blackest Black but I haven’t noticed much difference between it and Very Black.

The packaging is rather striking, it definitely stands out from the crowd. The tube is bright pink with a green lid, not the most stylish of combinations and to be honest it looks a bit cheap and nasty, but do not let this put you off, after all it’s what’s inside that counts. It doesn’t looks very attractive in your handbag but on the plus side it is very easy to find!

The brush is rather small and compact and made up of bristles in a spiral pattern, there are 11 turns in total spaced quite far apart. As the brush is quite small this makes it easier to apply the mascara to the corners of your eye and your lower lashes, although as I am not the most dextrous of people I sometimes struggle to coat all of my outer lashes without touching my eyelid as the tip of the brush isn't tapered. If you do get it on your eyelid it is easily removed with a moist cotton bud or tissue before its sets. I find that generally too much mascara is loaded onto the end of the brush when you remove it from the tube, so I always remove any excess with a tissue (otherwise it ends up on my eyelid). Before applying it to my lashes I always comb them and most of the time I curl them. The mascara itself is has a nice thick consistency and goes on pretty smoothly and evenly, but it does take longer than would be ideal to coat all of the lashes due to the size of the brush. After application I comb my lashes again, this makes a huge difference and I find it is important to do this fairly quickly before the mascara sets, so I normally apply it to one eye then comb it before applying it to the other eye. The mascara dries quite quickly, which is good so you don’t have to wait too long for it to set. Once dry my lashes feel quite stiff but do not feel heavy and caked.

As I have blonde hair and pale skin my lashes are unfortunately very fair, so mascara makes a huge difference. I tended not to wear mascara during the day until recently when my optician informed me I had small eyes (not something a girl wants to hear), so I decided that mascara was a necessity. I like to look fairly natural during the day so I only apply one coat to just my top lashes, and I can't stand clumps or my lashes sticking together. This mascara makes my eyes look larger and more defined but still very natural, there are no tell tale signs such as lumps or spiderness that you get with some mascaras. I find that my lashes do look longer and fuller without the problem of the mascara containing any fibres, which I find tend to flake off and irritate my eyes. I have noticed that if I am short of time (or just being lazy) and I don't curl my lashes before applying it, the mascara does have a curling effect. This is not as good as if you had curled them first, but I find that the curling effect is further enhanced if when during application you hold the wand at the tips of your lashes for a second whilst pushing up and in towards your brow. This mascara does not give a false lash effect, but then I haven't found one that does, and it does not claim to do this.

What I like best is that I don’t feel like I am wearing mascara, I am not consciously aware of it. It easily lasts all day long and doesn't smudge. On the whole I have found it to be pretty much indestructible. My eyes are prone to becoming dry and irritable, probably largely due to my hay fever, and as a result I tend to touch and rub my eyes a fair bit, not to mention them watering occasionally. This mascara never budges, though if I really rub them I do look like I’ve had too many late nights. I also have the habit of forgetting I’m wearing mascara/eye makeup and rubbing my eyes, then panic when I remember, but when I look in the mirror to see how bad I look the mascara hasn’t budged. You would think that this means that it is hard to remove when you want to, but this is not the case. I use Simple’s eye makeup remover, which you would expect to be pretty mild and gentle, but I have never had a problem removing all of this mascara, and on the odd occasion that I have been too drunk to remove it before bed, I have not had too bad a panda eye effect in the morning. I have never noticed any flakes around my eyes, even at the end of the day.

I have found that if I apply more than one coat of mascara my lashes start to stick together, which I find really annoying and then try to separate them by removing the mascara from that bit with my nails, which completely undoes the effect of putting more than one coat on. Unsurprisingly two coats do give a more dramatic effect.

I have started wearing contact lenses in the last few months and was very pleased to discover that my favourite mascara has been ophthalmologically tested and is suitable for contact lens wearers. I have not had any problems with it when I have had my contacts in, and my eyes are very sensitive and I have had problems with other mascaras.

This mascara does also come in a waterproof version, which I have not tried, mainly as I find the normal one is waterproof enough for my needs. I wouldn't advise going swimming in it or wearing it to events where there is a high possibility of you crying e.g. a wedding, it would be best to buy the waterproof version. I find the normal one can withstand a fair amount of moisture before it starts to smudge. On the occasions where I have cried whilst wearing it I have found that if you can avoid rubbing it or touching it until it has dried then it doesn't run everywhere, and aside from the red puffy face you couldn't tell you have cried by looking at the state of the mascara. When wet it will come off on anything it touches, so best to dab your eyes with a tissue, but the normal version does not claim to be waterproof. When I remove my contacts I find that my eyes tend to water but my mascara never smudges.

Every so often I buy a different mascara to see if it is any better, convinced that the latest product will be better as it’s more advanced, or that as I am now no longer a student and I can afford a more expensive product it will therefore be superior. But none are ever as good as this mascara. I like the fact that it doesn’t clump or make my lashes stick together, and that it doesn’t flake off and irritate my eyes.

In summary this is fantastic mascara, easily the best I have tried and I would definitely recommend it. I like to replace my mascara every 6 months to avoid infections, and the tube easily lasts the 6 months without becoming all dry and crumbly. It is a bargain at £4.99 so even if you do try it and for some reason don't like it you haven't lost much. It gives good definition to all of your lashes and makes them look longer and fuller. Quite frankly if the effect wasn't any good I wouldn't keep buying it. 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Maybelline Define-A-Lash Mascara Skin Doctors Eye Circle
Maybelline Lash Stylist Waterproof Mascara Very Black Skin Doctors Eye Tuck 15ml

Skin Doctors Eye Tuck 15ml

Eye Make-up, Face Cream / Treatment - Eye Care

User reviews (3)

Buy now for only £ 24.45

Maybelline Lash Expansion Mascara BeneFit Bad Gal Lash Mascara

Comments about this review »

debmercury 15.03.2009 11:22

Well reviewed~I like this one :o) x

MizzMolko 11.01.2009 15:22

I used this once but it came out clumpy on my lashes and haven't bothered with mascara since! Eleanor x

tune57 20.04.2008 23:14

Well reviewed I'm a fan of this,

Compare prices for Maybelline Great Lash »

1 offer for Maybelline Great Lash   sorted by: Price 


More reviews »

Maybelline Great Lash - review by ShoppingGirl

Advantages: Cheap, sexy, cult status.
Disadvantages: Just try *removing* it!

Maybelline Great Lash - review by ShoppingGirl ShoppingGirl 04.11.2002 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Maybelline Great Lash

Maybelline Great Lash - review by ilusvm

Advantages: bold, gives volume and length, clump-free, no flaking, long lasting, cheap!
Disadvantages: is quite bold if you dont like that sort of thing

Maybelline Great Lash - review by ilusvm ilusvm 14.11.2008 (14.11.2008) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Maybelline Great Lash

Maybelline Great Lash - review by miniloopie

Advantages: Fairly cheap, waterproof, goes on well
Disadvantages: Er, pink packaging!

Maybelline Great Lash - review by miniloopie miniloopie 22.10.2002 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Maybelline Great Lash

Maybelline Great Lash - review by yazoo88

Advantages: Cheap, cute bottle
Disadvantages: Rubbish brush, bad quality, doesn;t make a difference to lashes

Maybelline Great Lash - review by yazoo88 yazoo88 26.01.2009 (26.01.2009) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Maybelline Great Lash

Maybelline Great Lash - review by Sarah01

Advantages: It comes in a PINK tube:)
Disadvantages: It's not always in the sale!

Maybelline Great Lash - review by Sarah01 Sarah01 31.03.2002 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Maybelline Great Lash



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Maybelline Great Lash? Click here