Advantages Can fund helpful projects to reduce poverty
Disadvantages I have my doubts ...
I’ve been debating with myself for a while about how to write this op. How can I best put across my mixed feelings about child sponsorship?Before I start, I’m going to lay my cards on the table, so you know where I’m heading with this op. I have sponsored a child (with ActionAid) since I was a young child myself. All my family do it, from my younger brother right up to my granny. I’ve also seen first-hand how the money is spent, because for the last few years, I’ve worked for a well-known international charity in Africa and Asia. I’ve met some of the children that you sponsor and seen some of the projects that your money helps fund. I can see the good side, but I have also seen the bad side, and it makes me all a little bit uncomfortable.
WHAT IS CHILD SPONSORSHIP?
Child sponsorship is an important way of charities getting regular flows of money. It is rare that the money goes directly to the child or their family. Instead, it goes to help their community.
There are definitely benefits to child sponsorship. Your money will pay for basic essentials in the community that your child lives. So, for example, my child was often ill because there was no clean water, but in the last year my money helped build a well and sanitation system. The benefits are numerous and well-known.But what are the drawbacks? Why do so many people who work for international charities have doubts about the whole ‘industry’ of sponsoring a child? What is it about child sponsorship that makes me uncomfortable?
AN ADMINISTRATIVE BURDEN?
Running a child sponsorship programme takes a lot of resources – to identify children, to take photos, write little descriptions of the child, to send letters from the child, to check and deliver your post to the child. Paying for regular information about your child will leave a lot less money for actual delivery of services and aid. And all of this is for the benefit of you (the donor), rather than the child.
CREATES LOCAL ENVY?
Although the children do not actually receive the money themselves, they can receive letters and parcels from their donor families. This can create feelings of envy when some receive more than others, and may actually be divisive. I remember visiting one African community where local children had been sponsored by PLAN. One child was describing how he had never received a letter from his sponsor, but his friend got monthly letters, cards, photos, and small presents. His friend’s donor even had plans to visit. Although of course he was grateful for being selected for the scheme, he felt jealous of his friend and thought it was unfair that he got nothing.
JUST TREATING THE SYMPTOMS RATHER THAN THE CAUSE OF POVERTY?
Many would argue that poverty and inequality is deeply entrenched. It is the big issues that really count – unfair trade systems, debt, AIDS, corruption and the like. Child sponsorship is like sticking a plaster on a gigantic wound, because it only treats the symptoms rather than the causes of poverty. ActionAid has tried to rebrand itself in recent years and are moving away from their image as child sponsors to a campaigning organisation that addresses why people are poor in the first place and what is holding them back. How to do this? Write to your MP and ask them to lobby Blair to give more money to the Global Fund to Fight AIDS, TB & Malaria (the UK is currently giving far below its fair share). Email Patricia Hewitt (UK Secretary of State for Trade and Industry) and ask her to drop her support for agreement on investment at the WTO, which if it goes ahead will cause lasting damage to the lives of poor people. If you want more information about why you should do this and how to do this, visit: www.actionaid.org.uk
The debate within charities continues about whether child sponsorship is a waste of money or whether it is a vital revenue. Does it perpetuate harmful stereotypes of the Third World as dependent? Or is it a genuine partnership and bond? I think I would have to conclude by saying that I think it is a clever marketing gimmick, but the only effective way of helping people out of poverty is to tackle the root causes.ADVICE IF YOU DO SPONSOR A CHILD
I'd be interested to hear your thoughts and opinions on child sponsorship - Is it effective? Is it even ethical?
Attention, this is the first review from this author
Instead of giving a negative rating, consider:
Help this member by giving your advice
Report fraud (for example plagiarism) or other issue with the review to the Ciao support team
Add your comment