SHOPPING > Software > Operating Systems > Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium > Reviews

Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium

from (49 offers)

Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium

Quote-start

The Buena Vista Social Club

Quote-end

4 Oct 1st, 2007 

27 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Latest OS, some nice features, looks and feels a lot nicer

Disadvantages:
Compatibilty, still some bugs, possible system shock, need a decent spec machine

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Instructions / Help

Ease of use

Ease of Installation

Reliability

Value For Money

ayanayuk

ayanayuk

About me:

I'm someone who has seen both the highs and the lows of consumer life... Starting a new life in Not...

Member since:16.08.2001

Reviews:90

Members who trust:8

When it comes to operating systems I tend to stick to what I know. I don't rush out and buy the latest OS for at least 2 years. It took me until 2004 to bother with XP. My main reason is I tend to get comfy with an operating system usually around the same time that a new one comes out. The only real exception to this was the upgrade from Windows 98 SE to 2000 and that was only because I was given an installation disk. My other reason is it gives the peeps who make the OS time to iron out the bugs (and believe me - even the most robust operating systems in the world have bugs). So it was kicking and screaming that I ended up with Vista. And I mean literally kicking and screaming...

As I mentioned in my review about my Vaio, it's been tech update time at Ant Towers and one of the things that got updated was the processor on my motherboard (I'm still getting earache over this because the previous processor was less than 6 months old) and I slammed 2 new graphics cards in, and a bit more memory. Anyway within 2 days of this XP threw an enormous hissy fit. Typically mid-project. After being unable to locate the XP install disk (which turned up a week later) I had no choice. I decided that I may as well go the way of 64-bit Vista (my machine is 64-bit).

Now here is an important bit of advice. This one saves you money. A new Vista disk costs you in the region of £180. You can buy an upgrade disk, but this assumes you have a copy of XP or 2000 to upgrade from. If, like me, your copy of XP is missing or the restore partition on your HD is missing then you've got problems. You HAVE to buy the full version (full versions are better as well, but I'm digressing). To save money go to a computer hardware store (Microdirect, Computer Plus or whatever, but NOT a highstreet store) and ask for an OEM (other equipment manufacturer) copy of Vista and a really cheap power supply. Now you have to buy a power supply due to Microsoft's terms-of-service in regards to OEM versions. The OEM version of Vista sets you back around £80 and the power supply will be about £15 so the total is £95. By reading this review you could have saved yourself £85! :)

So anyway, I get home and start installing it. Now once you've seen one Microsoft install you've seen them all. The only difference with this one is that it's been tarted up a bit. All in all, including drivers for my hardware I was looking at around an hour and a bit. The initial install takes about 40 minutes, but always add a bit more time because there will always be something that needed drivers (in this case the graphics cards).

So reboot and off we go and see what it's like. Well it's certainly more swish. Microsoft have been taking lessons from Apple in the interface design. As a rule I'm generally against making an interface more complicated than it needs to be because it's another layer of things that can go wrong, but this improvement impressed me. Windows now has something called Aero (we'll ignore that Macs have had this sort of thing for ages). If your graphics card supports it and you have over 128Mb of graphics memory then you are treated to this visual feast (if you don't you're stuck with the 'Classic' view). It means that interface looks better, the windows have semi-transparent borders and you have something called Flip 3D (be warned that the Home Basic version does NOT have this). Flip 3D is the new improved version of ALT+Tab. By pressing the Windows key and Tab you get a 3D version of the windows you want to scroll through. Some people like it, some hate it. With me it's down to how I feel at the time. Another nice effect is when you hover your mouse over the task bar you get little thumbnails of the window you're hovering over (I used to have this on XP, but only because I bought a copy of WindowBlinds which has this feature). This can be very interesting if you have media player playing a video as it updates in real time.

The 'start menu' has had a slight revamp. Now when you go to the 'all programs' section you don't have to click on it. Leave your mouse there and the view switches to list all your programs. You can click it if you're in a rush, but I tend to leave it. This is a vast improvement for anyone who has a load of programs installed as it means that you don't have that stupid expanding thing any more that was easy to max out, especially on lower screen resolutions.

Something else Microsoft have included is the side-bar. One of my pet-hates is these things. I do admit that they occasionally have their uses, but I just don't like them. Once again this is down to personal preference, and it can be customised with 'gadgets'. Gadgets are basically add-ons for the side bar. Anything from stock-tickers, to weather forecasts to analogue clocks can be added. I think Microsoft have tried to stop the customiser software market in it's tracks by adding these and to be honest I do think they're making head way.

Anyway, tartery does not make a decent operating system. Is it any good?

Well security wise it's a bit of a nanny. Pretty much everything you run will throw up something called the User Account Control box. This is basically a check that you have tried to run something and it's not a nasty evil program. Open your browser - are you sure? Let's check e-mail - do you really want to do that? How about writing a letter to Aunt Fiona in Filey using Word - would you like to open Word? YES ALREADY! ENOUGH! I can understand why Microsoft thought this feature would be handy, but after a while it just gets so annoying. Thankfully it can be turned off and I can see a lot of people doing this sooner or later.

The firewall has had a total overhaul and you can now set up various rules and policies. It's meant to be more secure and easier to use, but I have it turned off because I use a third-party one. The fact that you can now set-up inbound and outbound rules etc is a good thing though.

Vista also comes with something called Defender. Once again this is something that I use a third-party application for, but the idea is to spot malware and spyware. I really can't say how good it is, but I've heard mixed reviews about it. If you're on a tight budget then stick with it (hey - it's free!), but otherwise consider but otherwise consider buying an antivirus product with one already built in. Why? Because you have to!

Vista doesn't come with any form of antivirus product installed. In these times you can't afford to be without an antivirus product. They're absolutely essential and worth their weight in gold. If you object to shelling out for one then both AVG (www.grisoft.com) and Avast! (www.avast.com) offer a free version. The Avast! one even comes with a load of extra stuff too so I'd go for that.

Windows explorer (what you use when you go hunting for files) has also had a massive overhaul so expect some system shock when using that. At first it takes a bit of time to figure it all out, but read the help sections and it all makes sense eventually. I've had Vista for about 6 weeks and I'll be honest, I took a brief excursion onto an XP enabled machine a week or so ago and I do prefer the Vista version than the previous one. Once you get used to it, you'll probably love it.

One place that Vista fails is compatibilty. So much has been altered in this version that a lot of applications that worked fine on XP either mess up or will just not work at all. You do have the option to use compatibility settings, but even then this is a mixed bag. Also if you have a treasured piece of hardware that you're hanging onto you may be disappointed. Drivers (especially for the x64 version) are currently lacking. Even hardware that claims to be Vista compatible sometimes isn't.

Where this is displayed most evidently is with graphics cards. If you don't have a Vista certified graphics card then you can kiss goodbye to any hope of watching high definition video. Apparently Windows knocks down the resolution and while it may well be better than DVD quality it still feels like it's a kick in the teeth.

The programs that come bundled with Vista are mainly just updates or upgrades of common programs that came with Vista. You have the usual notepad, word pad and calculator et all. They're nothing to write home about. Windows does now come with a DVD maker though so you can zap all your home movies on to DVD.

Speaking of DVDs this is where I had a major problem. Windows now "formats" DVDs to it's own filesystem and at first this confused the heck out of me. This basically means that any blank DVD you insert will be formatted to this format that is unreadable by anything except Vista. I would have preferred it if you had the option to this as opposed to it being turned on by default, but this was another thing I had to change, especially as I occasionally need to port data to other machines that aren't on my network and that don't run Vista.

Oh and not to mention the fun and games that were had when I couldn't even burn data to a DVD. This apparently is a common problem and I ended up having to alter registry values because the default ones don't work. I know what I'm doing here, but for a novice then it's totally out of the question.

So, would I recommend Vista? In some ways yes, and in some ways no. Yes from the point of view that it looks nicer, it feels nicer and is generally the latest operating system. No from the point of view that there are compatibility issues and still a fair few bugs that need ironing out.

If you decide to buy a new computer then you don't have much choice, Vista is now more or less pre-installed on everything. If you're just thinking about getting it then do think hard about it. I'd personally wait until the first service pack has been released or you're totally sure that all your hardware works with it. If your machine is over 18 months old then stick with XP until you upgrade. 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Microsoft Windows 7 Professional

Microsoft Windows 7 Professional

(+) Far More fast and stable than vista
(-) still used alot of memory usage

User reviews (3)

Buy now for only £ 102.92

Microsoft Windows XP Home Edition w/SP2 Complete package

Microsoft Windows XP Home Edition w/SP2 Complete package

Microsoft Windows XP Home Edition SP2, Microsoft Windows XP Home Edition, Microsoft Windows XP, Microsoft Windows XP Home Edition SP1, Microsoft Windows XP Home Edition SP1a - for PC - English - Quantity: 1, 3 - 1 user - CD-ROM

User reviews (52)

Buy now for only £ 16.99

Microsoft Windows 7 Home Premium

Microsoft Windows 7 Home Premium

(+) Easy to use, Aesthetically pleasing, User friendly
(-) Not enough variation from vista, no desktop button

User reviews (6)

Buy Now

Microsoft Windows XP Professional w/SP2 Complete package

Microsoft Windows XP Professional w/SP2 Complete package

Microsoft Windows XP Professional SP2 - for PC - English - Quantity: 1 - 1 user - CD-ROM

User reviews (7)

Buy now for only £ 88.55

Microsoft Windows 7 Ultimate

Microsoft Windows 7 Ultimate

(+) all is unbelieveble
(-) no comment

User reviews (4)

Buy Now

Microsoft Windows 7 Anytime Upgrade, Starter to Home Premium (PC DVD)

Comments about this review »

redeyes22 01.10.2007 15:07

great review xxx aggy

IzzyS 01.10.2007 13:27

Good review. I'm new to Vista too, just got a new laptop with Home Premium pre-installed a couple of days ago, ive used all Windows OSs since 3.1 but it still takes a bit of etting used to the new ones.. im sure it'll take me a week or so to find all the different features and so on... it took me a while to figure out how to find Wordpad since I couldn't spot how to get to 'accessories' within the start panel, oh well got there in the end lol (for anyone wondering, just type 'wordpad' or the name of the program or fle you want intothe search bar on the bottom left in the start bar) I think Vista is an improvement, its snazzy though the compatibility issues are a worry... anyway good review!

tigerthecat 01.10.2007 11:56

My new computer came with Vista and it took my a while to get used to, exceptional review.

Compare prices for Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium »

1 to 5 out of 49 offers for Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium Show all offers   sorted by: Price 
Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium OEM/OEI DSP - 64-bit Edition SP1 (PC DVD)

Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium OEM/OEI DSP - 64-bit Edition SP1 (PC DVD)

OEM WIN VISTA HOME PREM 1 PK 64 BIT ON DVD EN

amazon software

Postage & Packagingfree Super Saver Delivery
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 24 hours...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon software
Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium OEM/OEI DSP - 64-bit Edition SP1 (PC DVD)

Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium OEM/OEI DSP - 64-bit Edition SP1 (PC DVD)

OEM WIN VISTA HOME PREM 1 PK 64 BIT ON DVD EN

amazon marketplace software

Postage & PackagingFree!
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 24 hours...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace s...
Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium 32 Bit (OEM)

Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium 32 Bit (OEM)

Microsoft Windows OEM disks with product key, as used by system builders.

digital-sunrise.co.uk
Postage & Packaging£0.00
AvailabilityNext day
 Visit Shop  >
digital-sunrise.co.u...
Windows Vista Home Prem SP1 32-bit English 1pk DSP OEI DVD

Windows Vista Home Prem SP1 32-bit English 1pk DSP OEI DVD

OEM - Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium SP1 32 Bit (1 Pack)

amazon software

Postage & Packagingfree Super Saver Delivery
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 24 hours...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon software


More reviews »

Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium - review by shaaza

Advantages: Tight security new entertaining games, Fast search
Disadvantages: annoying when it always asks you if it should proceed into opening programmes

Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium - review by shaaza shaaza 02.10.2007 (02.10.2007) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium

Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium - review by lea20

Advantages: Looks better than XP, more secure
Disadvantages: Slow at times, still not every program works!!!

Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium - review by lea20 lea20 05.04.2009 (05.04.2009) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium

Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium - review by Martyn79

Advantages: Speed, Durabliity, Function, less memory use & ease of Use
Disadvantages: Some product in-compatible

Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium - review by Martyn79 Martyn79 01.02.2008 (01.02.2008) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium

Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium - review by DC-DanielColeflax

Advantages: easy to use, set up, extra features, the list goes on and on
Disadvantages: few slight glitches-few minor impracticalities, nothing major

Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium - review by DC-DanielColeflax DC-DanielColeflax 22.12.2007 (22.12.2007) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium

Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium - review by zobo77

Advantages: - New useful features - Interface
Disadvantages: - Stability - Price

Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium - review by zobo77 zobo77 27.05.2007 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium? Click here