Quote-start

Wireless woes

Quote-end

3 May 20th, 2005 

16 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Good quality, easy to configure, plenty of features

Disadvantages:
Did not get the speeds expected

Recommendable No:

Detailed rating:

Speed

Reliability

Ease of Installation

Ease of use

Value For Money

Pookie_Rabbit

Pookie_Rabbit

About me:

I back in the world of Ciao after a years break. Maybe this time I will stick around a bit longer. A...

Member since:13.07.2001

Reviews:40

Members who trust:4

In recent weeks I seem to have spent time on nothing but setting up Wireless networks, so here goes, another review.

First a bit of background on why I am looking at this model of router and also why you may be looking at such a requirement. Around a year ago I was asked to find a Broadband solution for a number of our remote users and at the time chose the Netgear DG834G (please see my review on this model for full information). Having bought around 100 of these models we have now had 5 fail for various reasons. At this point I thought it would be prudent to have another look at some of the other models available. As well as this Netgear model I have also been looking at the Linksys WAG54G (again a separate review).

What I was hoping to achieve from this review was something slightly less technical and shorter than my previous reviews. If you do want more detailed information on the more technical aspects of this model then just take a look at my DG834G review - it has pretty much exactly the same features apart from the supposed increase in speed, which as you will see later is far from guaranteed.

If you have broadband at home at the moment chances are you will have merely been sent an ADSL MODEM by your service provider which plugs into the USB port on your PC or laptop. There is nothing wrong with this unless you want any of the following features (and it should be noted that all are possible via other methods noted after each feature).

Allow multiple machines to access your Broadband connection - You could actually achieve this in another couple of ways. Obviously you could plug any other machine into the supplied MODEM one at a time and this can also be achieved by 'sharing' your Internet connection via Windows 2000 or Windows XP. Not ideal methods by a long way though.

Have firewall protection - A firewall protects you from outside intruders and a software version is included in Windows XP (but no other versions of Windows). You can get third party firewalls however many packaged with anti-virus solutions.

Have Wireless access to your Broadband connection - Again possible if you use Internet sharing with Windows XP and Windows 2000 and have wireless cards in each machine.

Internet access control - Within the router you can use various filtering options allowing parental control etc. Again you could buy third party solutions or use some of the built in options within Internet Explorer.

If you feel the need for any of the above features or would just like to simply things by combining them then read on. If you have no need for the above then save yourself some money and stay with the configuration you currently have.

I will continue on then by looking at each of the features available and how you would use them. First of all then lets take a look at allowing multiple machines use one Internet connection with this router.

When using the router for multiple machines you have a choice of two different methods, physical cable or wireless. You can of course use a combination of the two.
The router allows four physically cabled connections and the package includes one network cable to do this. To use this method you will need a network card/connection in your computer. If you don't have a network card in your machine you can buy one pretty cheap, however you might find easier to buy a wireless network card instead. As I said you get one cable so you may need to buy more if required.

The second and arguably better option would be to use wireless. Again you would also need wireless adaptors on your client machines.
Now lets take a quick look at the Wireless options of this product. One of the greatest confusions when looking at the different models of routers are the different (theoretically fastest) speeds the routers can run at, often signified by standards. The main ones are as follows.

802.11b - runs at a maximum of 11 Mbps
802.11g - runs at a maximum of 54 Mbps
"Super G" - runs at a maximum of 108 Mbps

Now the first point is you wont see many routers on sale that only run 802.11b anymore anyway. The second point is the speeds. If you are running Broadband/ASDL you are more than likely getting a maximum download speed of 2Mbps on your line. In other words the bottleneck on most Broadband Internet connections is going to be the connection itself - not the wireless.
However as well as speed each standard claims to give you better wireless coverage. You should also remember that you would also need to use a similar standard of client wireless adaptor (i.e. the one on your desktop PC or laptop) if you want to reach the theoretical maximum speed. So if you used a router with 802.11g and a laptop with 802.11b you would get a maximum speed of 11 Mbps not 54 Mbps. Therefore in theory with this router and a client also running "Super G" you should get a maximum speed of 108 Mbps.
And for me this is where the problem lies with this product. At no point have I actually managed to reach this speed. When using this router with a combination of a Netgear WH511T card in my laptop I have never reached any speed above 54 Mbps. On checking the Netgear support web site it mentions that you can only achieve this speed by using channel 6 on the router (there are 11 channels available). This is not mentioned anywhere else. For me it still didn't work anyway. I am certainly not claiming here that you cannot get this to work - only I could couldn't with equipment that should have worked.

Don't get me wrong - this is a good product. Like the DG834GT it is easy to configure via a web interface and you should have no problems getting it up and running with the enclosed instructions. So far I have found it nothing other than reliable.

Visually the model is pleasing. It is a reasonable size, white with silver on the front display. The only other complaint I have is again a lack of an on/off switch. The DG834G also suffers from this. To add insult to injury the power cable has now been moved from the far left at the back of the router to the left in from the aerial which makes it harder to get at. The aerial incidentally is slightly smaller than on the DG834G.

In conclusion then I really can't give this router any more than 3 stars. In a way this is a little unfair. If you can get the speeds it claims (and therefore the extra coverage distance) then you have a 4 star product. The DG834GT though tends to be around £20 or £30 more expensive than the DG834G and WAG54G.
As I said earlier I am not sure what great advantages the extra speed brings at this point in time. If you need the extra coverage for wireless then fair enough. I will continue to try and get this product to work at "Super G" levels and if I succeed and find it was down to my incompetence I will update this review and give the product the extra star it may deserve.

If you have any questions or comments on this review please feel free to leave them.
 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

NETGEAR RangeMax Dual Band Wireless-N Router WNDR3300 - wireless router

NETGEAR RangeMax Dual Band Wireless-N Router WNDR3300 - wireless router

Wireless router - External - 4-port switch - IEEE 802.11g, IEEE 802.11b, IEEE 802.11n (draft 2.0), Fast Ethernet, Ethernet, IEEE 802.11a

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 79.40

Belkin N Wireless Modem Router - wireless router

Belkin N Wireless Modem Router - wireless router

Wireless router - External - ADSL, ADSL2+, ADSL2 - 300 Mbps - 4-port switch - Ethernet, Fast Ethernet, IEEE 802.11n (draft), IEEE 802.11b, IEEE 802.11g, IEEE 802.11n (draft 2.0)

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 40.00

NETGEAR DG834G 54 Mbps Wireless ADSL Firewall Router - wireless router

NETGEAR DG834G 54 Mbps Wireless ADSL Firewall Router - wireless router

Wireless router - External - ADSL, ADSL2+ - 54 Mbps - 4-port switch - IEEE 802.11g, Fast Ethernet, IEEE 802.11b, Ethernet

User reviews (33)

Buy now for only £ 7.99

Belkin N1 Vision Wireless Modem Router - wireless router

Belkin N1 Vision Wireless Modem Router - wireless router

Wireless router - External - ADSL2+, ADSL2 - 300 Mbps - 4-port switch - IEEE 802.11g, IEEE 802.11b, Fast Ethernet, Ethernet, Gigabit Ethernet, IEEE 802.11n (draft)

User reviews (7)

Buy now for only £ 18.47

NETGEAR WGR614 54 Mbps Wireless Router - wireless router

NETGEAR WGR614 54 Mbps Wireless Router - wireless router

Wireless router - External - 54 Mbps - 4-port switch - Flash: 4 MB - Ethernet, Fast Ethernet, IEEE 802.11g, IEEE 802.11b

User reviews (8)

Buy now for only £ 24.75

Belkin Wireless G Gaming Adapter - bridge

Belkin Wireless G Gaming Adapter - bridge

Bridge - External - 54 Mbps - IEEE 802.11b, IEEE 802.11g, Fast Ethernet, Ethernet

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 25.00

Comments about this review »

ma_siddiqui 07.01.2007 14:59

good review...but i have few questions....pls check your guestbook...thanxxx

TomlinsonSE 21.05.2005 14:40

Great Review. Sue

thespurs 20.05.2005 16:30

Nice review. Not something that I have a need for to be honest

Compare prices for NETGEAR DG834GT 108 Mbps Super G Wireless ADSL Router - wireless router »

1 to 2 out of 2 offers for NETGEAR DG834GT 108 Mbps Super G Wireless ADSL Router - wireless router   sorted by: Price 
Netgear DG834GT 108Mbps Wireless ADSL Modem Firewall Router with 4-port 10/100 switch

Netgear DG834GT 108Mbps Wireless ADSL Modem Firewall Router with 4-port 10/100 switch

Five products in one, the DG834GT combines an ADSL modem, router, 10/100 LAN switch, 108 ... more

Mbps Super G access point and SPI Double Firewall.
 It gives you untethered continuous connectivity
to your network resources and the Internet and
allows you to sh...

amazon electronics

Postage & Packaging£4.87
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon electronics


More reviews »

NETGEAR DG834GT 108 Mbps Super G Wireless ADSL Router - wireless router - review by sear69

Advantages: It is wireless
Disadvantages: none

NETGEAR DG834GT 108 Mbps Super G Wireless ADSL Router - wireless router - review by sear69 sear69 03.07.2007 (03.07.2007) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of NETGEAR DG834GT 108 Mbps Super G Wireless ADSL Router - wireless router

NETGEAR DG834GT 108 Mbps Super G Wireless ADSL Router - wireless router - review by ucjtckc

Advantages: Looks Stylish, Easy to set up, comprehensive accesories supplied
Disadvantages: Poor Performance, Auto 108MB mode very poor

NETGEAR DG834GT 108 Mbps Super G Wireless ADSL Router - wireless router - review by ucjtckc ucjtckc 20.01.2006 (22.01.2006) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of NETGEAR DG834GT 108 Mbps Super G Wireless ADSL Router - wireless router

NETGEAR DG834GT 108 Mbps Super G Wireless ADSL Router - wireless router - review by codiak

Advantages: Very Relaible
Disadvantages: Drops out if your ADSL has a low SNR ratio

NETGEAR DG834GT 108 Mbps Super G Wireless ADSL Router - wireless router - review by codiak codiak 02.05.2006 (17.05.2006) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of NETGEAR DG834GT 108 Mbps Super G Wireless ADSL Router - wireless router

NETGEAR DG834GT 108 Mbps Super G Wireless ADSL Router - wireless router - review by malmo12

Advantages: 108 mbps speed and 100mbps built in modem
Disadvantages: overheating and poor range

NETGEAR DG834GT 108 Mbps Super G Wireless ADSL Router - wireless router - review by malmo12 malmo12 22.10.2006 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of NETGEAR DG834GT 108 Mbps Super G Wireless ADSL Router - wireless router

NETGEAR DG834GT 108 Mbps Super G Wireless ADSL Router - wireless router - review by samwest2008

Advantages: Small and neat and easy to set up
Disadvantages: Had to be hard reset

NETGEAR DG834GT 108 Mbps Super G Wireless ADSL Router - wireless router - review by samwest2008 samwest2008 21.06.2007 (21.06.2007) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of NETGEAR DG834GT 108 Mbps Super G Wireless ADSL Router - wireless router



Are you the manufacturer / provider of NETGEAR DG834GT 108 Mbps Super G Wireless ADSL Router - wireless router? Click here