Quote-start

Poor quality speakers

Quote-end

2 Aug 5th, 2008 

4 Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful

Advantages:
Drop in replacement for 5 inch car speakers .  Reasonable bass response

Disadvantages:
Tweeter breaks easily, distorts at volume .  Expensive for what you get .

Recommendable No:

Detailed rating:

How is the overall Sound Quality?

Bass Quality

Treble Quality

Midrange Quality

Value for Money

DCISmith

DCISmith

About me:

Member since:04.08.2008

Reviews:3

I bought 2 boxes of these speakers at £15 per box to replace the 4 much abused, 18 year old speakers in my car. Initially I was pleased with them, they weren't much louder than the speakers they replaced but they had slightly better clarity and bass.
After a month or so, one of the speakers developed a horrible high pitched buzz from the tweeter on certain notes. I checked to see nothing was caught in it and wrote it down to me over-driving them. It may be important to note that my stereo is a lowly 12watts RMS, I felt 90 watt speakers should be able to cope. However, for some reason the manufacturer refuses to follow the industry and measure their speakers in RMS.
After a further few weeks of not particularly loud music, the other 3 speakers developed exactly the same problem as the first, screaming on certain tones.
I borrowed a tone generator CD from someone and played it loud through all frequencies which seems to have reduced the screaming noise somehow, possibly having partially melted the tweeter or something. The noise is still there however it is less noticeable.
If you only listen to the radio in the background or something like that, these speakers would be fine. However, if you like music at moderate volume, avoid these speakers. 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Riesen L 20 AT

Riesen L 20 AT

Car Speakers - Pair of Speakers - Built-In - Round - Passive Speakers - 80 Watt - Diameter: 100

Rate it now

Buy Now

Pioneer TS-WX 22 A

Pioneer TS-WX 22 A

Car Speakers - Subwoofer - Built-In - Round - Active Speakers - 150 Watt - Diameter: 200

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 148.50

Riesen L 23 AT

Riesen L 23 AT

Car Speakers - Pair of Speakers - Built-In - Oval - Passive Speakers - 250 Watt

Rate it now

Buy Now

JBL GTO 8627

JBL GTO 8627

Car Speakers - Pair of Speakers - Built-In - Oval - Passive Speakers - 180 Watt

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 34.99

Riesen L 22 AT

Riesen L 22 AT

Car Speakers - Pair of Speakers - Built-In - Round - Passive Speakers - 180 Watt - Diameter: 150

Rate it now

Buy Now

Fusion EN-AB1120

Fusion EN-AB1120

Car Speakers - Subwoofer - Surface Mounted Speakers - Round - Active Speakers - 360 Watt - Diameter: 300

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 99.99

Comments about this review »





Are you the manufacturer / provider of Riesen L 21 AT? Click here