Quote-start

A Rose by Any Other Name

Quote-end

5 Feb 27th, 2001 

24 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Scent, flowers, foliage, prickly .

Disadvantages:
Prickly !

Recommendable Yes:

Aspen

Aspen

About me:

Member since:04.11.2000

Reviews:146

Members who trust:160

You may think of single red ones. You will certainly think of large-flowered, carefully manicured ones. You will probably think of powerfully scented, old fashioned rambling ones. And rightly so, for these cultivated roses well deserve their prime spot in our gardens.

But this is a big family, and I would like to draw your attention to some which rarely make the limelight.

The breakdown of this category inspired me to this. The Hybrid Teas are listed, along with Floribundas, Patio Roses, etc. Then there’s this topic – Rosa. Being the botanical name, all varieties really fall under this heading. So I reckon, in these circumstances, for “Rosa”, read “The Rest”.


ROSA RUGOSA

Sometimes known as the Ramanas Rose, Rosa rugosa is widely planted as hedging. It can grow up to 1.5 or 2m high, and produces masses of prickly stems. It suckers freely, and so in a fairly short time, produces a spikey thicket which will deter the most persistent intruder, drunk, or wandering doggy. It is therefore a good choice for boundaries. However, it cannot be clipped successfully in to a formal hedge shape, and is probably more suitable in rural areas, or as a back garden hedge.

Rugosa is as tough as old boots. It is a favourite hedging plant in the wilds of Caithness, where it grows and thrives in an environment where anything standing still is rapidly caked in salt from the sea-spray. Or would be, if the wind let up long enough to allow anything to stand still. Despite originating in S E Asia, Rosa rugosa will absorb anything our climate can throw at it, wherever in this island you may live.

Rugosa itself has pink flowers; Rugosa alba has white flowers; and Rugosa rubra has red flowers. All have a long flowering season, and the flowers are followed by the biggest rosehips of all the family. These hips are quite unusual, being round and flattish, rather than cylindrical like most of the relatives. They are shaped, in fact, not unlike an early neep. (Didn’t think I’d manage to slip a neep into this one!)

It is deciduous, of course, and so nothing special to look at in winter, after the birds have had the hips. But it remains a functional hedge, all the same.

It is parent to many hybrids, and cultivated shrub roses in particular, like Roseraie de l’Hay and Frau Dagmar Hastrop. It is also used as a rootstock by nurserymen, for grafting less vigorous varieties.


ROSA PIMPINELLIFOLIA

Also known botanically as Rosa spinosissima, and commonly as the Scotch or Burnet Rose, this has to be the prickliest of a pretty prickly family! It only grows up to about a metre, and does not sucker as profusely as rugosa, but it too will make a good informal hedge. The stems grow erect, and the leaves are a very dark green. The flowers, which appear in profusion in may and June, are usually white, but can sometimes be pale pink. The hips are quite small, but are unusual in being a very dark maroon, and indeed often black.

Pimpinellifolia is also the parent of many hybrids, one of the better known being Rosa pimpinellifolia Lutea, which has a lovely single yellow flower.


ROSA RUBRIFOLIA

Or Rosa glauca, but sadly without a common name to my knowledge. But it definitely ranks highly among my favourites. Roses are grown, of course, for their flowers. Rarely are they considered as foliage plants. Well, consider this!

Rubrifolia has reddish-violet stems, which are almost thornless. These stems carry a remarkable foliage, which is glaucous-purple in full sun, and greyish with a mauve tinge in shade. I wish I could describe these colours so that you can visualise them! The bright pink flowers are a bonus, and this is a wonderful foil plant for the back of a border.


ROSA WICHURAIANA

This one is sometimes known as the Memorial Rose, and is a little bit different. It is low-growing, and semi-evergreen. Its trailing stems can grow up to 6m long. It is excellent ground cover, as the stems will root at intervals as they spread. Use it to cover a scruffy bank, or try growing beside an old tree stump, which it will clothe in no time at all. It produces clusters of white flowers in late summer, and they are highly fragrant.

Wichuraiana is the parent of that very well known rambling rose, Albertine, which holds an RHS Garden Merit Award.


And talking of ramblers, I’d better not ramble too much longer. I guess only die-hard gardeners will have persevered this far, and I don’t want to be responsible for anyone dozing off.

So I’ll just give a brief mention to a couple more, which are worthy of note.


ROSA VIRGINIANA

This one justifies its inclusion here for its autumn colour. The leaves turn first to purple, then to orange, crimson and yellow, though not necessarily in that order!


ROSA RUBIGINOSA

This is Eglantine or Sweet Briar. Do not overlook it just because it’s a native. Both flowers and foliage are wonderfully aromatic, and if you have room, it makes a fragrant but impenetrable hedge.


So when you think of roses, don’t just think of Floribundas, or Hybrid Teas, or even Cadburys. Open your mind to a whole new rose experience!
 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Floribunda Rose

Floribunda Rose

(+) plenty of flowers
(-) not as good quality as hybrid teas

User reviews (3)

Buy Now

Bay Laurel (pyramid)
Hybrid Tea Rose

Hybrid Tea Rose

(+) Beauty and perfume
(-) Thorns

User reviews (2)

Buy Now

Chilean Potato Tree
English Rose

English Rose

(+) Repeat flowering, wonderful scents
(-) Hard to choose which one to buy

User reviews (3)

Buy Now

Bean - Organic Dwarf

Comments about this review »

Lynda04 01.03.2001 19:40

Lovely op, I have Albertine!

bandoo 27.02.2001 19:52

You rose to this challenge expertly - how many more puns can we find ? Lots I'm sure. My gardening expertise is non-existent so I am now using you as my own persoanl gardener ! Thanks for all the info - next time I want my husband to buy me roses I will be more specific. HB

Saltire 27.02.2001 18:45

I never realised there was so much to know about roses! Thanks for that informative and well written op :-)



Similar »

Roses - review by micksheff

Advantages: Beautiful Looking Flowers, Fragrant, Easy To Grow
Disadvantages: Lots of Pests And Diseases

Roses - review by micksheff micksheff 14.02.2007 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Roses

Mixed Breed/ Non-Pedigree - review by jdt1

Advantages: Loyal and Loving
Disadvantages: Powerfull and Strongwilled

Mixed Breed/ Non-Pedigree - review by jdt1 jdt1 11.05.2004 (11.05.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Mixed Breed/ Non-Pedigree

Roses - review by Sunnysmiles

Advantages: variety of colour
Disadvantages: attracts bees

Roses - review by Sunnysmiles Sunnysmiles 24.07.2006 (24.07.2006) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Roses

Shrub Rose - review by Minha

Advantages: Great variety of flowers
Disadvantages: Lots of thorns!

Shrub Rose - review by Minha Minha 02.05.2004 (02.05.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Shrub Rose



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Rosa? Click here