Should smoking be banned in all public places?

Community images

Should smoking be banned in all public places?

> Show product information

63% positive

164 reviews from the community

Sorry, we couldn't find any offers

Review of "Should smoking be banned in all public places?"

published 28/11/2002 | babajane32
Member since : 30/11/-0001
Reviews : 154
Members who trust : 0
About me :
Not for me
Pro Definately healthier
Cons Some won't agree
very helpful

"Smoking...who's right."


Chosing this catagory to put my op,was quite difficult.Whilst the debate of whether to permit smoking in public places or not is something I feel strongly about I want to go a little further into the subject of smoking,so I hope everyone will indulge me a little and read on a bit further.
Both myself and my husban are smokers,and have been for many years (more than 15 years).We have a daughter who is,like myself an asthma sufferer and we have two ther children.We live in a smallish house (3 bed terraced),and despite having air filtration units installed,windows open regularly, and smoking as much as possible outside the house... are still polluting our childrens atmosphere.
We both smoke 20 cigarettes a day and have tried on many occasions to give them up (unsucessfully).
That's our basic background,so now the scene is set..on to the debate.....

Smoking in public places?

I may be considered narrow minded,but in my mind there is only one right side to this,and that is the side that allows choice,and the right to that choice.
Not the choice to have a cigarette and inflict it on those around you, but the choice NOT to inhale anyones fumes,whether it be at home or in a public place.
As a smoker you can choose to have a cigarette,but as a none smoker you often do not have the choice to breath clean and smoke free air,all because another person chooses to pollute their own lungs!!
If it is possible to have an area for those who feel they want to indulge their "habit",yet still ensure areas for those who do not,then fine allow smoking.But if it's not practicle to have both then surely those who want clean lungs should have priority?
When smoke is inhaled the effects are semi-permanent and after prolonged exposure it is permanent.Yet when you are "forced" to breath smoke free air,it is not can always nip off somewhere else for a cigarette afterwards. interesting point.

Now it's time to consider a few other points about smoking....
When a handful of unfortunate(to put it mildly)people contracted CJD suspectedly from beef,the results were instant and profound.Beef was stripped from the shelves at an amazing rate.Bans were put in place on meat in a variety of ways and by many countries.
In view of this I fail to understand how a host of nations allow the sale of cigarettes,which are literally addictive,unhealthy,deadly consumables.
I have read many articles pointing at the expense to the nhs by smoking related desieses,yet none to point out the amount of the goverments revinue from the sale of tobacco.
There is something fundamentally wrong when cash income overrides the welfare of people,and feel had beef been taxed at a similar rate then it would never have been withdrawn from sale in any way.
Not being totally nieve I realise that the withdrawl of tobacco would have great financial implications on our goverment,and effects on existing smokers,but there are ways to adress this too.
Outlaw the sale of tobacco products,let those who are long standing smokers have a perscrition for patches or similar,and whilst they still need them cigarettes..(payable at the same as from the shops now).The goverments have time to adjust to the lost revinue..and indeed revinue from the sales of alcahol and such are likely to increase a little as bootlegging will decrease.
Ok there will be some redundancies in the tobacco trade,but the money people were spending on cigarettes will be spent on other things so other oporunities will open.
If the strain on the nhs is so great from smoking related illness the that too will decrease and money can be saved.
The true affects of the addictiveness of cigarettes is obvious to me...I love my children,understand how bad it is for theirs and my health and hate the smell,yet I still light a cigarette at the first sign of stress..


Yep,I am a raving hypocryte but,both people who don't smoke and our children have the right not to have their lungs poisened by this terrible habit,a habit that makes sensable inteligent people put thier lives and those around them at risk on a daily basis.

Community evaluation

This review was read 1281 times and was rated at
98% :
> How to understand evaluation of this review
very helpful

Comments on this review

  • dbirse published 04/04/2007
    Very good.
  • MHam published 01/11/2003
    I'd love to see them try and implement that! M xx
  • mrlovepantsuk published 26/06/2003
    nice op with some good points.
  • Did you find this review interesting? Do you have any questions? Sign into your Ciao account to leave the author a comment. Log in

Product Information : Should smoking be banned in all public places?

Manufacturer's product description


Listed on Ciao since: 22/03/2002