A large rock on a Small Island
Advantages You may learn more than you thought you knew.
Disadvantages None
Detailed Rating
| Would you read it again? | |
|---|---|
| Story | |
| Characters | |
| Readability | |
| How does it compare to similar books? | |
| How does it compare to other works by the same author? |
This is a fiction book which could quite easily be non fiction.
Based mainly in Britain, partly in Jamaica it encompasses the difficulties two couples from both of these Islands could have experienced during the post war period.
Each of the four main character's personalities, thoughts, likes and dislikes shine through with brilliancy in writing that makes one stop to re-read the similes and metaphors that make up their lives, thoughts and actions. 'Her eyes were as black as apple pips'
The novel jumps between the 'before' and 1948 with each chapter headed with a character. Each character talks as if they are telling you their story.It begins with Hortense arriving in London alone - her husband Gilbert who promised he would meet her was not there. She had given him the money to go to London promising her he would find accommodation for both of them. She arrives at Queenies house with a 'trunk the size of the Isle of Wight' which later Gilbert asks her whether she has her mother inside it.
Hortenses' high ideals of London are shattered as she is shocked at the low standard of the accommodation; all her dreams are dashed by the sight of the room she is to share with her husband.Gilbert puts his side of the story in the next chapter showing a sensitive man who has high ideals and dreams but realises that life is not a bed of roses. He appears to find it difficult to communicate with his wife.
The book then takes us on to 'before' and through each character we learn how their lives were before 1948.As the novel unfolds each character and event is plausible it shows the high hopes of Jamaicans and the harsh reality of the prejudice in Britain at that time - and not only by the British people but by the Americans in Britain as well.
This part I found particularly interesting as my own experience as a young girl gave me a deep insight to the prejudice against Jamaicans and the fight they had for their self respect during the 1950's in London. Something I found as a young child awful and something I could never understand or accept.The characters in the book reminded me of people I had met during those years and I could see the white gloves that Hortense would wear and the baggy suit Gilbert wore.
I found the way the characters discussed the cleanliness and habits of each others' cultures quite amusing and this took me back personally to my own childhood experiences. As Bernard could quite easily have said in this novel - Different cultures, you see, they are not like us, you see.
Bernard, Queenies husband reminded me of many men whom I knew as a child. To me the plot was quite simple but the writing and characters were brilliant.
I did wonder at one point where these characters were leading to and left the book for a few days but I felt compelled to finish it. I am glad I did as the ending was…?
I found the writing purely magical and impressive; I can understand why it was a winner of the Orange Prize for fiction as well as the Whitbread book of the year.
Teacherofhooch
Attention, this is the first review from this author
Instead of giving a negative rating, consider:

Help this member by giving your advice

Report fraud (for example plagiarism) or other issue with the review to the Ciao support team
Add your comment
justathought 12/07/2008 21:03
Brilliant review of a brilliant book. Have an E. Coming from an ethnic minority made me relate to this book more than other people I know who've read this - interesting to know of someone who can relate to the events directly x
bohoangel 13/06/2006 14:40
Claiiiree 17/12/2005 00:41
wordskill 05/12/2005 22:32
|
trade edition paperback, vg+ |
amazon marketplace books
|
Shipping: £2.80 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days |
|
trade edition paperback, vg+ |
amazon books
|
Shipping: Free! Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours |
|
Pages: 544, Edition: Reprint, Paperback, Headline Review |
amazon marketplace books
|
Shipping: £2.80 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days |
|
Edition: First Printing, Paperback, Review |
amazon marketplace books
|
Shipping: £2.80 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days |
Nice review, I've not heard of this one, I will certainly look out for this one