Quote-start

Smart Energy Solar Water Heating System

Quote-end

4 Apr 29th, 2004 

21 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
More hot water than you know what to do with !

Disadvantages:
Very complex controls .

Recommendable Yes:

nikmacve

nikmacve

About me:

Member since:25.03.2004

Reviews:4

Members who trust:1

My Smart Energy experience started with an invitation to have a salesman visit me to show me their wonderful solar water heating system. I took them up on it, because I like the idea of sustainable energy sources. The salesman duly turned up and gave me the usual pitch - discount applicable only if you sign up today, you can earn money back by recommending friends or talking to potential customers, and so on: nothing new there. As part of his presentation he claimed that the system would pay for itself in seven to eight years, a ludicrous statement disproved in about thirty seconds' work using his own figures and a calculator. However I was already convinced that solar energy was the way to go and my other half was even keener. So we signed up.

We were to have two panels on the front and two on the back of our east/west facing house, and our existing hot water tank was to be replaced with a single tank in the attic. There are other possible configurations involving storage tanks and a heating tank and the best configuration will depend on the size and layout of the property. The sun collectors are glass tubes filled with a glycol solution and when the temperature in the collectors exceeds the temperature in the water tank by a specified number of degrees, the heat is transferred to the water. The whole kit and caboodle is controlled by an electronic gizmo which looks simple but turns out to be very complicated indeed. There is also an immersion heater for when there's not enough sunlight to heat the water properly. If you move house within two years of having the system installed, the company say they will move it to your new property for you and it's guaranteed for ten years.

Before we could have the system installed we needed some work done in the attic - this was something we were doing anyway so the installation provided a bit of an incentive to get on with it! Because of this, having purchased the system in May the year before last, we didn't actually get it until August the same year. My partner stayed at home waiting for the workmen, two of whom arrived on time, rapidly and professionally erected their scaffolding, put the collectors in place on the roof, installed the tank and associated plumbing, cleared up and went away again. Then we had to wait for someone else to connect it all up and make it work. And wait. And wait through three missed appointments. The connector-upper managed to keep the fourth appointment, about three weeks after we first expected him, and two days later the system was all connected and working.

The panels look quite nice on the roof, the tank is discreetly situated in a corner of our attic, the plumbing looks like Spaghetti Junction and the control panel is on the landing, displaying the temperature in each collector and in the tank.

As I said, it was then the end of August and the sun was shining. By the time I got up in the morning there was more than enough hot water for me to have a bath, should I so wish. The collectors use UV light and on a sunny summer day we literally have more hot water than we know what to do with. On a cloudy day the water is cooler and on the more miserable winter days the system raises the water temperature to barely lukewarm and we need to use the immersion heater. Still, heating water from lukewarm to hot is faster and cheaper than heating it from cold. You can, of course, use a timer to switch the immersion heater on to give you hot water in the morning. But I am writing this at the end of April, and by the time I wanted hot water at 8am today, the tank was up to 59 degrees - too hot to comfortably hold your hand under.

Shortly afterward the installation was completed, we discovered a minor leak in the Spaghetti Junction and an overflow pipe that terminated over the ceiling of our spare room. We sent Smart Energy some digital photos of these little problems, and the company sent a man to fix them within a matter of days.

Eighteen months on, our system has worked wonderfully with two exceptions, neither of which were serious problems. A a few months ago, when we finally got the ceiling in the attic up, the temperatures in the collectors were getting high but the heat was not being transferred to the water. The pressure in the collectors had fallen, but my partner found how to adjust it by reading the manual Smart Energy give you when they install the system - one small tweak of a lever and everything was fine again.

A few weeks ago we noticed that again the heat was not transferring. This time we called Smart Energy and they sent someone round within a few days of the call. "Someone had been fiddling with the control panel", and having spent a couple of hours re-programming the system so it was even more efficient than before, the nice man advised us to leave it well alone. The control panel is not intuitive and is too complex for the manual to explain. I admit to "fiddling" but I was not aware of having changed anything, only trying to see if there was anything obvious wrong. Because of the direction our house faces, it's best to transfer the heat as soon as possible. Two of the four panels are always facing the sun - and if the heat is not taken out of the collectors they get too hot, forcing the system to shut down until they cool which obviously only happens when the sun goes away, ie at dusk.

The switch for the pump is located where it could easily be mistaken for a light switch. I assume that our builder mistakenly pressed a button he shouldn't have on the way down from the attic, but am not sure that's what happened. It might be an idea to fit a cover so nobody accidentally "fiddles"!

We are pretty happy with our Smart Energy system. It will take many years to pay for itself but we feel that by using this technology we are making our small contribution to saving the planet. I note in passing that Smart Energy have not sent any potential customers to visit us, but they have been helpful when we've needed them to be and other than the hiccups with the initial installation we have no complaints about the service we have received and certainly none about the system itself. As regards actually purchasing a system, do what you would normally do: look around, evaluate the products, do your own research and take the sales pitch with the usual pinch of salt. We did less of this than would have been ideal but have ended up with something which works very well indeed.  

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Addis Smart Bin Freeplay Indigo
FreeLoader Battery Charger Addis King Size Flip Top Bin
Rubbermaid Slim Jim Recycling Container Bin Addis Roll Top Bin Composite Plastic

Comments about this review »

oldwasp 22.04.2006 15:40

sounds like a lot of money to pay out

Martinscholes 24.08.2004 10:40

Thanks. We are thinknig of this and I have seen a similar system in use at the CAT in Wales.

koonekoone 29.06.2004 12:02

Hi there, Having had an installation of similar type I have since found out why we had problems. Smart Energy states it is proud to have achieved ISO9001:2000. This is a quality standard that makes sure the company and its employees work to a high standard in all its dealings. Smart Energy has only bought a license for this from QSA which is on their flyer, it does not guarantee that they will work to these standards. BEWARE !!. These systems can be bought for less than half the price of Smart Energy systems check out Thermomax on the web. Rgds



More reviews »

Smart Energy Solar Water Heating System - review by AndrewsHappy

Advantages: Little lower gas bills, satisfaction your helping to save the planet
Disadvantages: Pushy sales man, unjustifiable high price, kit not high quality.

Smart Energy Solar Water Heating System - review by AndrewsHappy AndrewsHappy 30.05.2008 (30.05.2008) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Smart Energy Solar Water Heating System

Smart Energy Solar Water Heating System - review by magicziggy

Advantages: none
Disadvantages: HARD SELL and sales techniques used by con artists and scammers

Smart Energy Solar Water Heating System - review by magicziggy magicziggy 04.09.2007 (04.09.2007) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Smart Energy Solar Water Heating System

Smart Energy Solar Water Heating System - review by KH206cc

Advantages: Cheap, Efficient and Good for the Environment
Disadvantages: Expensive to Install

Smart Energy Solar Water Heating System - review by KH206cc KH206cc 04.06.2004 (04.06.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Smart Energy Solar Water Heating System

Smart Energy Solar Water Heating System - review by cwink_99

Advantages: Good for the environment, reduces fuel usage.
Disadvantages: Finding a decent company to work with.

Smart Energy Solar Water Heating System - review by cwink_99 cwink_99 13.10.2004 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Smart Energy Solar Water Heating System

Smart Energy Solar Water Heating System - review by allisterj

Advantages: none
Disadvantages: expensive, constant breakdowns, dreadful aftercare, cheap components

Smart Energy Solar Water Heating System - review by allisterj allisterj 25.08.2004 (26.08.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Smart Energy Solar Water Heating System



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Smart Energy Solar Water Heating System? Click here