mart6011 5

mart6011

Add to my Circle of Trust

Subscribe to reviews

About me:

Member since:07.07.2001

Reviews:15

Quote-start

Great story

Quote-end
23.07.2001

Advantages:
Great book, easy to read, mostly accurate

Disadvantages:
Some Cold War cliches

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Degree of Information

How interesting was the book?

How useful was it?

Would you read it again?

Value for money

How easy was it to read / get information fromEasy

2 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful See ratings
very helpful by (100%):
  1. Pborowiec
  2. jelightfoot
  3. From_The_Continent
and 9 other members

View all ratings

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Share this review on Google+

I spotted this book while drinking coffee at Waterstones. Since it is pretty boring just to seat there doing nothing and since I have "history" as one of my "weak" spots I decided to give it a go. The first impression?
The book is gripping! Once you opened it it is impossible to get out. I spent two hours reading it and lots of money for coffee before I realized that I am definitely buying it.

So here is my opinion. The story is well presented both from military and the human points of view. Historical evidence from the thick volumes of military history comes through the intimate soldiers letters and personal accounts of the great battle.Indeed the scale of this battle is incredible - Germans lost almost quarter million of soldiers killed and wounded. The suffering of PoWs and civil population was out of scale, if there is any scale for brutality. Well that is a history, but the book is much more than just another historical account. It is simply brilliantly written.

This book also blows up some common misconception. The first one - about effectivenes of the German war mashine. It simply was not. The level of chaos in Wermacht was incredible - the airlift promises that were not realistic at all, the lack of strategic thinking from german commanders, although it has a lot to do with the personality of Hitler, who succesfully eradicated any trace of free thought in OKV. There are some misconceptions about Russians - their readines to the winter warfare was not great, although there is an explanation for this - most of the new equipment went to the fresh armies, that were to smash the Kessel, where as the defending armies were left to scavenge from their dead.

Sadly, the author repeatedly uses some Cold War propaganda cliches. For example, Russian troops continuously portrayed as semi-alcoholic (!!! as in the book!!!). Well...Russians do drink. And in any army in this kind of conditions there are some alcoholics simply because battle stress is unbearable. However - germans, at least at the begining of the battle are portrayed as clean shaved and russian army is just a bunch of semi-drunk barbarians. And of course there are the documents to prove it. For example, poisoning of some people who drunk an antifreeze liquid. Was it true? It certainly was. But the figures the author mentions - several tens of soldiers - are NOT compared to the number of troops at all. And there was more than half a million russian troops. I am leaving for you to work out the percentage of alcoholics in the russian army and the validity of this clichee. And another detail - Russian troops were served with vodka ration - 100 gramms per person per day. Imagine the immence cold plus the stress of the battle and try to understand - the soldiers WERE NOT drunk! Well i guess I am getting emotional here, but those little flaws in the text are very noticable because the text is EXTREMELY GOOD.

  Write your own review

Share this review on Google+

« Previous review   Next review »

Rate this review »

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

Rate as exceptional

Rate as somewhat helpful

Rate as very helpful

Rate as not helpful

Rate as helpful

Rate as off topic

Write your own review Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful. Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful.   Report a problem with this review’s content

Comments about this review »

SnotSlut 23.07.2001 19:38

Not my choice of reading material, an informative opinion nonetheless - Simone.

gennymutant 23.07.2001 16:15

Sounds like a very worthwhile read. I'll have to keep an eye out for it. Thanks! - Dione

babsbaby 23.07.2001 15:36

Good informative op. Thank you. Barbara

Add your comment

max. 2000 characters

  Post comment

Related offers for Stalingrad - Anthony Beevor »

Amazon UK 832 Ratings

Amazon UK

Find "Stalingrad - Anthony Beevor" New and Used on Amazon. Free UK Delivery on orders over £25.

 Visit Shop  >
Amazon UK

Product Information »

Product details

Type Non-Fiction
Genre History
Title Stalingrad
Author Anthony Beevor
ISBN 0140249850
EAN 9780140249859

Show all Product Information

More reviews »

Review Ratings »

This review of Stalingrad - Anthony Beevor has been rated:

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Products you might be interested in »

Saving The World's Wildlife WWF The First 50 Years - Alexis Schwarzenbach

Saving The World's Wildlife WWF The First 50 Years - Alexis Schwarzenbach

(+) Interesting history of a global organization
(-) The book didn't have the expected focus on WWF's work with wildlife

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 12.99

Seven Pillars of Wisdom - T. E Lawrence

Seven Pillars of Wisdom - T. E Lawrence

Non-Fiction - History - ISBN: 1905432771, 1873141173, 1873141149, 1850790310, 088029258X, 0854000283, 0848805623, 0385402392, 0224604007, 0224013416, 022400896X

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 5.61



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Stalingrad - Anthony Beevor? Click here