JOHNV 4

JOHNV

Add to my Circle of Trust

Subscribe to reviews

About me: Counting down to light mornings and better weather in the spring. Yes I know it's several months away...

Member since:13.07.2000

Reviews:843

Members who trust:226

Quote-start

A haunting tale of war and friendship

Quote-end
28.06.2011

Advantages:
Moving story of relationships in war

Disadvantages:
Slightly difficult to get into

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Would you read it again?

Story

Characters

How does it compare to other works by the same author?

ReadabilityGood

How does it compare to similar books?Very good

79 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful See ratings
exceptional by (7%):
  1. Jake_Speed
  2. pennywa
  3. Alyson29
and 3 other members
very helpful by (91%):
  1. cornishchic
  2. Wee_Jackie_163
  3. ryeb
and 71 other members
helpful by (1%):
  1. Brooke3

View all ratings

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Share this review on Google+

First published in 1971, ‘Strange Meeting’, which takes its title from a poem of the name by war poet Wilfred Owen, is a novel about relationships during the Great War. As Susan Hill says in an Afterword, written for publication in the 1989 reprint, it is not a book whose ‘subject is war and the pity of war’, so much as about human love, two survivors among thousands ‘who were slaughtered in a war perhaps more futile and meaningless than any other in history.’

The story

At the beginning we meet John Hilliard, a young subaltern, lying awake in a military hospital, recovering from a shrapnel wound received on the western front. For three weeks, he has been afraid to go to sleep, and is speaking to Dr Crawford, whom he has known since childhood. He then returns home briefly on sick leave back in England, but it is an uncomfortable experience and he finds it hard to adapt to the old way of life there. Neither his sister, to whom he had been very close, or their parents have any real idea of the horrific conditions he has been enduring in the trenches. In no time he is longing to get back to the western front. When he does, he finds that his batman and many others whom he knew have been killed. Moreover the group's Commanding Officer, Colonel Garrett, has aged greatly under the stress of war, and has taken to drinking heavily.

Hilliard now finds himself sharing a room with a new officer, David Barton, as they await a call back to the front. The inexperienced Barton has had comparatively little experience of the war, and has never yet seen a dead body. When he and Hilliard see the wreckage of a German plane crash and the men who were killed as a result, he is naturally very shocked. Gradually his letters home to his own family convey how he is becoming hardened by everything at the battlefront, the misery and suffering he sees all around him. He complains that they are drones, not fighting men.

As the officers arrive at their billets, they learn that a new recruit, Harris, is virtually paralysed with terror and refuses to come out from the cellar. They talk him out of his fears and persuade him to come outside. Within minutes a shell falls on the billets and Harris is killed at once. The officers left behind are torn between guilt at inadvertently sending him to his death while arguing that he is fortunate in that he has been spared life in the trenches, possibly leading to more mental agony and a slow lingering end.

The book is largely concerned with human relationships, and beyond this, little happens. From one point of view, maybe it falls a little flat in that there are no really cataclysmic events beyond what we might call the sordid fog of the war itself. However there is no shortage of atmosphere. When the men go to Feuvry, they find there is barely a building left intact in the town after it had been shelled and occupied by the Germans soon after the outbreak of war. All that remains are piles of rubble and holes in the ground, fragments of broken children’s toys and furniture, pieces of chairs sticking out from the debris, rusted spring coils from sofas – all sad reminders of an apparently once secure and peaceful existence brutally shattered.

As for the rest of the story between Hilliard and Barton, is it simply the tale of a friendship forged in times of great adversity, or is it any more than that? The author leaves a certain amount to the imagination. There is an interesting underlying theme in the contrast between Hilliard’s formal, rather chilly family and Barton’s much closer siblings. The former evidently has an emotional vacuum which cries out to be filled.

Finally

I’d recommend this book with reservations. For me it was a little hard to get into, before I became acquainted with the characters. Ultimately it is quite a moving and powerful if somewhat difficult story, certainly a penetrating one in its analysis of relationships and feelings of guilt at sending men to their deaths, boredom, apprehension, and fear.


Pictures of Strange Meeting - Susan Hill
Strange Meeting - Susan Hill Susan Hill
Susan Hill
  Write your own review

Share this review on Google+

 

Rate this review »

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

Rate as exceptional

Rate as somewhat helpful

Rate as very helpful

Rate as not helpful

Rate as helpful

Rate as off topic

Write your own review Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful. Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful.   Report a problem with this review’s content

Comments about this review »

LadyValkyrie 23.10.2011 14:12

Hmm, one I'd like to read just to see what I think of it.

Revo9 01.08.2011 12:50

Nice review, seems an interesting book.

jonathanb 21.07.2011 09:27

Not exactly an uplifitng read by the sound of it, but a valuable reminder of how horrific life (and death) was in the trenches.

Add your comment

max. 2000 characters

  Post comment

Compare prices »

1 offer for Strange Meeting - Susan Hill   Sorted by: Price 

Product Information »

Manufacturer's product description

John Hilliard, a young subaltern returning to the Western Front after a brief period of sick leave back in England ...

Product details

EAN 9780140036954
Type Fiction
Genre Historical Fiction

Ciao

Listed on Ciao since 09/06/2009

Show all Product Information

Review Ratings »

This review of Strange Meeting - Susan Hill has been rated:

"exceptional" by (7%):

  1. Jake_Speed
  2. pennywa
  3. Alyson29

and 3 other members

"very helpful" by (91%):

  1. cornishchic
  2. Wee_Jackie_163
  3. ryeb

and 71 other members

"helpful" by (1%):

  1. Brooke3

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Products you might be interested in »

Spartacus: Rebellion - Ben Kane

Spartacus: Rebellion - Ben Kane

(+) Perfectly paced, leading the reader in
(-) Some of the nasty scenes are a bit too vivid...

User reviews (2)

Buy now for only £ 5.75

Shakespeare's Mistress  - Karen Harper

Shakespeare's Mistress - Karen Harper

(+) Historical fiction based on known facts about Elizabethan life and theatre.
(-) None for me.

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 1.02



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Strange Meeting - Susan Hill? Click here