Heya, hope you're all well.. I'm Claire and i'm 27 (booo). I just have to say that I hope I don't bo...
Heya, hope you're all well.. I'm Claire and i'm 27 (booo). I just have to say that I hope I don't bore you with my reviews haha. I also post on dooyoo. Take care, speak to some of you soon i'm sure. xx
Member since:19.08.2005
Reviews:39
Members who trust:32
I have been due for an upgrade since September, but am still waiting for the release of the phone I really want, I rang up to see if there was any release date set for it but was told there was still no date set, but would I like to charge the T Mobile G1 instead?! I haven't really been interested in this phone because of having read a few reviews, and looking the spec etc up myself, it just wasn't something that appealed to me. I said I'd prefer to just wait but the sales guy said I could try it for 7 days and if it wasn't to my liking, I could send back and there'd be no difference in my account status, so after a bit of persuasion, I agreed.
The phone is the result of a joint partnership between T Mobile (operator) and Google (operating system), however the actual handset is made by HTC who regularly make phones to be rebranded by T Mobile (and also Orange and O2) but also release phones in their own HTC form too. I've always found HTC to be of a good quality and reliable so although I wasn't particularly interested in this phone from looking at the specs, I still had high hopes for the performance.
The phone runs the much anticipated Android operating system; this is the first open source operating system for a mobile phone. A lot of people were saying that this was another in a long line of supposed 'I-Phone Killers' but was this to be the case? Having not ever used an I-Phone, I can't compare it to this but I can tell you of my own opinion for the week that I used the phone.
The phone arrived and I unpacked it, hoping it would be a decent phone, and wondering what would be included in the box.The box includes:
This phone is available in a choice of colours, black or white for the UK market, and I believe the US market also have a bronze one… I'm not sure why we don't have that option here but I am starting to feel that releasing the phone here was just an afterthought with this coupled with a point I make about American spelling of some words below. Incidentally, I have the white one.
It's not the smallest or the prettiest of phones, and is also quite 'plasticky' - I can deal with that for the right phone, but with the curve on the bottom of the phone, it makes it even more bulky and awkward in my opinion and to be honest I don't think it's necessary to have the curve up; plenty of other phones manage without one.
The screen move mechanism that allows you to view and use the phones keypad kind of moves out and then up but this is jerky and I feel will break sooner rather than later due to its design, they should really have just used a normal up/down motion as this would have worked much better design wise to me.
It has an expandable memory capacity, which makes it easier to store any photos or music etc that you want without running out of internal memory.
On first start up you are asked to either log in with an existing Google account, or forced to set up a new one, it's not such a big deal but I'd prefer to not have a phone that forces me to set up a new account just to use it if I'm perfectly honest. After the first start up you are greeted with a black screen with a simple font saying G1 in the middle, and the T Mobile logo underneath. There's no music on start up either, at least not on mine anyway!
You then come to the main front page with a clock on and a few icons, mine being 'dialer', contacts, browser, maps and web and walk. Please note that I did not spell dialler incorrectly; this is the way it is on the phone, a big error in my opinion since this phone is not only marketed for the US, but the UK and Europe also.
I had some difficulty both in finding out how to transfer my contacts and actually transferring my contacts data from my Nokia over the Google handset, in the end I just resorted to 'bluetoothing' them over from one phone to the other.
The user interface is meant to be a dream to use, and to some extent it is quite good but it's certainly not without some major flaws. It's a bit of a pain to get set up how I'd like it as there seems to be numerous sub menus that need exploring and I tend to lose where I am up to and end up frustrated. You'll probably also find that if you install a lot of games and applications (more about these later) that your menu bar gets very busy and it's not so easy to find the things you want quickly/easily. What would be better is if they had separate games and applications folders so that these third party downloads could be kept together, whilst still being easily accessible.
The touch screen is really unresponsive, I didn't expect this because of my good experience with HTC's previously released phones, which is leading me to think it could be the software that's lagging more than the hardware. I really have to hit it to get the phone to respond (well tap furiously) and regularly find myself touching the wrong icon on the touch screen because of this. I can honestly say it has not been the dream to navigate that I'd been lead to believe it was by the T Mobile employee who insisted I tried the phone whilst saying that he had the phone and it was the best phone he'd ever used.
They had the good sense to include both a touch screen AND a full QWERTY keypad but this is brought down by the fact that when texting or typing for any other reason you find that the ledge with the menu and call buttons at the bottom of the phone get in the way for both the typing experience, and also in the way you need to hold your phone. The buttons are also very small, close together and not raised very much which makes it difficult to type/hit the right keys and also really quite difficult to ascertain if you have pushed them or not.
The secondary functions on the keys are accessed by the 'ALT' buttons, although this isn't made obvious until you try it out yourself. This was a bit annoying but at least I worked it out quickly enough. The delete button would benefit from being a touch bigger, as would the space and shift buttons (on top of the normal letter keys).
The backlight on the keyboard doesn't light all the buttons as well as it should, I find the Q, menu, delete, shift and a handful of other buttons don't light up very well at all and thus make it difficult to see them properly; which defeats the object of it being there in my opinion.
There's also no way of typing text with phone in upright position using software built into the operating system like most phones of this type so it's rather annoying to keep having to turn it to type and no other choice but to contend with the bad layout of the QWERTY keypad which in all fairness *should* actually be my first choice of text input; and I feel it would have been much better if they'd had both options available to use. More effort is needed on all parts of the typing experience if they want this phone and operating system to be a success.
The headphones, as mentioned briefly above have a mini USB connection to connect to the phone, I really don't know why they chose to use this kind of connection and they haven't even included an adapter so that if you were to lose the headphones provided, or they were to stop working at least you'd have the ability to use other headphones you have? Would it have been so difficult to have used a normal 3.5mm jack so you can use any headphones with the phone? I think not. Also, having this set up also means that you cannot charge your phone whilst still listening to music, which can be a pain if your battery goes whilst on a train and you still want to be able to listen to music whilst you charge up; a situation I find myself in quite a lot really.
This leads me to my next point; the battery life is truly awful for this kind of phone as it's constantly connected to internet, which drains the battery in itself without any usage on top of it. A better battery should have been included as it is really needed here, no thought seems to have been given to this, which is a real shame as nobody wants to be charging up constantly, especially so in a time where fuel costs are soaring.
The phone has GPS and Google maps are pre-installed, these are great, the GPS finds you even whilst inside (unlike Nokia maps) and it has the ability to direct you from point A to point B easily and clearly. There are not enough areas with street view on to make this part worthwhile at this moment in time, maybe this will change in future.
The phone has an instant messaging function, which would be good if it allowed you to use your MSN or Yahoo accounts but alas it does not, it is labelled as Google chat and only allows you to use your Google account and thus Google contacts within it. Now I can only speculate here but I am guessing that not many people use this, I base this on the fact that nobody that I know uses this, and this makes it a useless function to me. I'm not entirely sure, but you *may* be able to find something on the android market to use your other messenger accounts with but I have yet to find something decent enough to make me want to use it.
Android Market is actually very good and a worthwhile addition to this phone; in fact I'd go as far to say this is the best thing I have found about the phone full stop. It's very easy to look through or install applications and games (apart from the unresponsive screen issue) although I feel it would benefit from a proper search function that you could type in a keyword, and also to order the results not only by popularity (how many times it has been downloaded) and date, but by user rating. I have found that Android Market has a fairly good selection of free games and applications which is a big bonus as to have to pay for each application or game you would like would work out to be very expensive.
Opera mini is available on Android Market and to me this is a must, as if you're anything like me, you won't get on very well with the standard browser. This is personal preference though and you may well like the browser it comes with.
I can't understand who this phone is aimed at, as there's not really any direction in it, it wouldn't suit business users in my opinion, it doesn't even seem to aim at general consumers that well, and to me it has a slightly bigger appeal to teenagers but then would they really be spending enough on a contract to be able to get this phone?
T mobile seem to be pushing it as I didn't actually want this phone, and I told them this but they said to try it and if no good to send it back, which I will be doing. I don't think these phones are the success that T Mobile thought or hoped that they'd be.
All in all, it's a phone that I could cope with at a push I guess, but I had the choice to try it out and send it back if I didn't like it, which is what I will be doing as there's no point in me keeping a phone that I have so many issues with. The Android operating system shows promise on its first outing and there are a couple of features that I will miss, but there are also a lot of things that need sorting, or smoothing out along with a more workable handset to make it the success I think it could be, in time.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Advantages: does everyhing you would ever want, and so much more! Disadvantages: battery is poor but its not the end of the world if you can charge it regularily.
spencej89 01.04.2009 (01.04.2009)
·
Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of T-Mobile G1
Advantages: ermm... very big screen easy to watch youtube... and the games are addictive.. esspecially snake3d Disadvantages: not alot of gagets, faulty
juiney123 21.06.2009 ·
Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: somewhat helpful
Review of Nokia 6600 Slide