The Battle for Chalk and Cheese.
Jan 5th, 2005
Advantages:
-
Disadvantages:
-
Recommendable:
Yes
Detailed rating:
Degree of Information
How interesting was the book?
How useful was it?
Would you read it again?
Value for money
more
 steerpyke
About me:
Moving house...back soon.
Member since:13.02.2004
Reviews:399
Members who trust:136
Review rated by 33 Ciao members on average: very helpful
An eminent military historian, Brigadier Peter Young, once told an audience that 'not much happened in Wiltshire during the English Civil War," an odd statement to make when you consider the destruction of an entire Parliamentary army on the hills above Devizes, seven sieges, four towns stormed and countless skirmishes. Tony MacLachlan sets out to put the record straight by researching the role of the county during the war, forgotten vaults and archives were exhumed, public records and libraries became his home and the physical scares of grapeshot and musket ball on the old buildings of Wiltshire were brought to light. Underneath the tarmac and concrete the ghosts of this revolution still have something to say to us. Wiltshire has always been a divided county, the land of Chalk and Cheese, on which the saying is based. The chalk down lands provide rough grazing for sheep and so is linked to the wool trade and clay lowland is the home of dairy farmers, whose milk makes the cheese. Through out the ECW, Wiltshire was also very divided
politically, some MPs being staunch Royalists, others supporters of the Parliamentary rebels. In many towns where two MPs were to be found very often there would be one of each persuasion. This is the scene that is set at the opening of this book.
In August 1642, Charles I raised his standard at Nottingham declaring the start of the war and very soon Wiltshire would feel the force of that action. By the first frosts of winter, Marlborough had fallen to the Royalists, and actions at Devizes and Malmesbury saw the towns change hands many times in quick succession. MacLachlan demonstrates that although these were not the large and eye catching events that we remember history for, they were very significant to the movement of both sides armies and contributed hugely to the shape of the war. Many towns, after changing hands, were fined by the victors for allowing themselves to have been occupied by enemy troops in the first place, this was seen as collaboration. The upshot of this is that the towns were bankrupted by the constant change of occupying forces as both sides were using this method to raise funds. By 1643, war seemed to have receded from the county when the armies of Hopton and Waller appeared on the horizon. After an initial battle at Lansdown near Bath, these two skirmished with each other all over the county finally ending up in a full on contest at Roundway Down above Bath. Although the Royalists were the eventual winners, what is brought to light here is the human nature of civil wars. Hopton and Waller had been close friends before the start of the conflict and Hopton in particular was heart broken to have to face his former friend, and even wrote a letter to him to say as much, but duty had to be done. The nearby Battles at Newbury are covered in similar detail and the siege of Old Wardour castle that came towards the end of the war.
Even though the warfare is covered in great detail, using letters and diary descriptions of the time to help set the scene, where MacLachlan triumphs is in showing who it affected the normal person. Although wars tear away menfolk from the home and civil wars in particular pull apart family values as father fought son and friend fought friend, there was still a certain normality to be held on too. Armies of these times were not permanent fixtures, men moved from civilian to recruit and back to civilian many times, often changing sides as need arose. Seasons still passed, farms still functioned, businesses still operated and for many, even in these turbulent times, life went on as normal. It is this angle that sets the book above others on the subject, the war did not affect every one, and to many it was a time of opportunity. It was said that every county had its own civil war, and this is as true of Wiltshire as of any other county in England. Modern wars are often fought between people from all over the world who are not necessarily from the region that is being contested. The people in this war are neighbours, local landowners and their workers, people who in peace time would have sat in the same church pews, that is the nature of civil war. Most of the conflicts detailed are accompanied by easy to follow maps of the various actions and there are many photographs of the places as they are seen today. Other interesting statistics, such as the lists of MPs and their allegiances help make sense of who was who, and who they fought for. If you have an interest in this period, then this book will fill in many gaps regarding the ECW that until now have bee over looked. If you are from the English west country then this book is also a fascinating read, as almost every town in the area was involved in the war in some way. This book adds a great deal of the human element to a subject that is often dealt with in statistics and heroics, the thoughts of young soldiers, their families and the politicians and leaders of the time bring this exciting period in Wiltshire's history to life.
Compare Prices
sorted by Price
Products you might be interested in
|
|
06.01.2005 09:33
It really sounds a fascinating read, and like it contains a lot of interesting info. I enjoyed the review. Mandy.xx
06.01.2005 08:25
great stuff, the Civil War is something we never get to hear about usually.
05.01.2005 22:07
Well written review x