ImogenW 3

ImogenW

Add to my Circle of Trust

Subscribe to reviews

About me:

Member since:15.12.2000

Reviews:154

Members who trust:116

Quote-start

I gave up

Quote-end
09.01.2001

Advantages:
G2

Disadvantages:
See above

Recommendable No:

Detailed rating:

Value for money

Quality of journalism

Quality of features

Quantity of advertising

Price45p

7 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful See ratings
very helpful by (85%):
  1. DaC_87
  2. Astragali
  3. kfingleton
and 8 other members
helpful by (15%):
  1. knight_of_the_soundtable
  2. superflous_drivel

View all ratings

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Share this review on Google+

actually buying the Guardian a few years ago. I still read it because we get it at work, but I just wouldn't spend my money on it these days, despite it being the paper that probably comes closest to my own political views.

Why don't I like it? Well, first of all, on a technical basis, I can't stand the layout. I find it really, really hard to read. They've tried to use all sorts of feature page design tricks like leaving lots of space and arty use of pics in the news pages, and to my mind it just doesn't work when you've got so much text and so much space, and so little to pull it into a unified whole. It also means they've cut down on the number of stories covered, which makes their news coverage at least quite narrow.

I also have a problem with the editorial focus. It irritates me no end when people elevate the Guardian above papers like the Daily Mail on the grounds that one has more 'impartial' coverage than the other, because it's crap. Both work in the same way, by selling their reader's prejudices back to them, and the Guardian is as unquestioning of stories that fit its philosophy as is the Mail. The Guardian will give prominence to environmental and race-issue stories, just as the Mail will publicise those involving children and health scares. It's just a question of catering to your market. And as I say, the Guardian covers proportionally fewer stories than other papers, which only exacerbates the effect. As for the areas that you'd expect the Guardian to be good at, I find their foreign coverage in particular a real disappointment. Although they have a few superb individual correspondents (Maggie O'Kane and John Aglionby in Indonesia, for example), generally it's all taken from the wires and really marginalised within the paper.

I also object to the tone of the paper. Basically I think they've got hideously smug and self-righteous since the whole Hamilton and Aiken things, making out like they're establishment watchdogs or something. And they're not. TO base this on the Hamilton thing is especially objectionable, as they only got that story because Mohammed Fayed decided to tip all the necessary papers in their lap. All they had to do was publish.

Their saving grace, in my view, is G2, simply because it's a great format and it's nice to have a tabloid thing to read on the tube. The stories can be alittle predictable, but it does enables them to have a vastly superior jobs section.

  Write your own review

Share this review on Google+

« Previous review   Next review »

Rate this review »

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

Rate as exceptional

Rate as somewhat helpful

Rate as very helpful

Rate as not helpful

Rate as helpful

Rate as off topic

Write your own review Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful. Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful.   Report a problem with this review’s content

Comments about this review »

GoodShop 15.01.2001 21:19

Don't really agree with you - I think the Daily Mail is far more guilty of pandering to it's readers prejudices. Yes, the Guardian layout is crap, but the content is good. Foreign news is a weak point though - so we agree on that. Generally, I prefer the Indy (especially for foreign news) and am a big fan of the World service. The Guardian is brilliant on a Friday though - 'the editor' is superb (especially for busy people) and G2 has all the film and music reviews on a Friday too. Now the Indy main paper with G2 inside would be my ideal paper!

jason.rowe 09.01.2001 19:53

Well constructed opinion. I quite like the Guardian and buy it now again, but you are right they do pander to their readers views, similar to the Daily Mail but maybe not as self-righteous. A very good point. As for the news coverage, I think they cover more than the Daily Mail on average, but I cannot compare them to other broadsheets as I don't read them often enough.

LostWitness 09.01.2001 12:07

Imogen - thanks for your comments on my Bristol opinion. Nope - not a student but have been living in Bristol for a few years now.

Add your comment

max. 2000 characters

  Post comment

Similar offers for The Guardian »

1 to 3 out of 695 similar offers for The Guardian Show all similar offers
The Guardian Book of Kakuro - The Guardian

The Guardian Book of Kakuro - The Guardian

Title: Guardian Book of Kakuro Binding: Paperback Author: The Guardian Publisher: ... more

Cornerstone

 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace books
Postage & Packaging:  £2.80
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...

The Guardian - Marliss Melton

The Guardian - Marliss Melton

Pages: 348, Paperback, James-York Press

 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace books
Postage & Packaging:  £2.80
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...

The Guardian [DVD]

The Guardian [DVD]

The Guardian offers satisfying entertainment with a no-nonsense combination of Hollywood ... more

formula and good old-fashioned star power. While
honouring the men and women who serve as rescue
swimmers for the U.S. Coast Guard, this
predictable yet appealing drama is a well-crafted
showcase for Kevin Costner and Ashton Kutcher, who
bring welcome depth and dimension to their
formulaic roles. It's basically Top Gun for the
Coast Guard, with Costner playing a legendary
rescuer haunted by recent tragedy and the
impending break-up of his marriage, and Kutcher as
the hot-shot recruit whose bravado is tested when
Costner takes over a grueling 18-week basic
training course, where a 50% attrition rate
ensures that only the best will make the grade.
There's nothing particularly inventive about Ron
L. Brinkerhoff's screenplay, but it's
intelligently written and well-directed (by The
Fugitive helmsman Andrew Davis) as it shows how
seasoned veteran and troubled but talented trainee
build mutual respect while sorting through the
trauma of accidents that left each of them as sole
survivors, tormented by self-doubt and guilt.
Bolstered by a strong supporting cast including
Neal McDonough, John Heard, Sela Ward and Clancy
Brown, The Guardian is a bit on the long side (137
minutes), but it never feels slow, and a romantic
subplot (with Kutcher wooing a schoolteacher
played by Melissa Sagemiller) blends nicely with
thrilling ocean-rescue sequences--incorporating a
seamless blend of CGI and footage shot in a
750,000-gallon water tank. Music fans will welcome
the scene-stealing appearance of veteran singer
Bonnie Bramlett as the owner of a jazz/blues club
near the training base, where The Guardian serves
up yet another staple of its genre: the barroom
brawl. Although Hurricane Katrina prevented The
Guardian from being filmed in New Orleans in 2005,
real-life footage during the closing credits makes
it clear that the Coast Guard was essential in
Katrina's aftermath, and this rousing drama pays
overdue tribute to those who risk there lives (to
quote the Coast Guard's motto) "so that others may
live." --Jeff Shannon

 Visit Shop  >
amazon dvd
Postage & Packaging:  £1.49
Availability:  Usually dispatched within 24 hours...

More reviews »

Review Ratings »

This review of The Guardian has been rated:

"very helpful" by (85%):

  1. DaC_87
  2. Astragali
  3. kfingleton

and 8 other members

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.



Are you the manufacturer / provider of The Guardian? Click here