Yes, I'm still bobbing around here somewhere, I'm just insanely busy with one thing and another. Fee...
Yes, I'm still bobbing around here somewhere, I'm just insanely busy with one thing and another. Feel free to visit my homepage (I'll update it soon - promise!)
Member since:23.07.2000
Reviews:215
Members who trust:102
Have you ever read a book that pulls you in so completely that you become completely attached to it? When you read it, you feel good about yourself, but when you finish it, it's somewhat depressing – something is missing from your life. This, however, just causes you to read it all over again! This is what I found with the Tolkien classic 'The Lord Of The Rings'. But now can you imagine the same book, but in a fully radio-dramatised form? All your imaginings brought to life before your very eyes, um, ears?
- The roots of obsession
My love of 'The Lord Of The Rings' unsurprisingly started with me reading the book. Sure, it took me an age to do it, but I was so totally enthralled by the whole thing that I just kept reading and reading until I reached the end. I felt so terrible when I'd actually finished it, I realised I needed some sort of fix, and after I'd read every appendix, prologue and epilogue I could find, I came to the radio dramatisation. I'd heard bits of it before, and loved it, but I'd never actually listened to it all the way through. My father, a fellow Tolkien lover, had recorded the BBC's adaptation when it was first aired on Radio 4, and I decided it was time to listen all the way through. I was amazed. This version captured everything I'd ever known about the book, and more, and it's a testament to its quality that I've listened to it so many times since. It wasn't until just over a year ago when I discovered the existence of a CD version of the adaptation, and I knew one day I would have to have it. Sure, it wasn't exactly cheap, but it would certainly be worth it. Thanks to Ciao and Dooyoo, this day came sooner than I had expected, and after saving £80 of my earnings, I was able to purchase my very own copy. And so a little part of my history was made.
- The story
The book, written by John Ronald Reuel Tolkien, was completed in 1949. It is the follow-up to the comparatively small book 'The Hobbit', and tells the tale of a small hole-dwelling folk and their adventures in the lands of Middle Earth. Those who have read 'The Hobbit' will know of the small golden ring discovered by Bilbo Baggins (a hobbit), and hidden
away from the disgusting and loathsome creature called Gollum. This ring forms the key concept in 'The Lord Of The Rings', where the true nature of the ring is discovered, and Bilbo's heir, Frodo is sent to destroy it, for the sake of the whole of the land of Middle Earth. I can't say much more about the story without spoiling it for everyone who hasn't read it, but let's just say that they're a lot more to it than just that!
- The adaptation
It must have seemed like an almost impossible task when Brian Sibley and Michael Bakewell were faced with the challenge of dramatising a thousand page book like 'The Lord Of The Rings'. Not only that, but it is such a popular book, that any mistakes would cause uproar, and so they had to get it just right, or they'd be trouble! Brian was the one that initiated the project – he'd had another idea for a radio dramatisation, and the BBC turned him down for that, but was asked what other books he might like to dramatise. After reading LOTR and becoming a huge fan, this was one of the books he put on his list of possible projects. And so the story began.
The story was split into 26 thirty minute episodes, although this is trimmed down to 13 longer episodes for the CD version – two episodes being merged on each CD. There's no noticeable join, and each CD finishes in an appropriate way, and, more often than not, with a tense cliffhanger. The CDs are arranged in such a way that each has around five or six tracks, which, in a way, represent 'chapters' of the story – each CD and track is appropriately named relating to the part of the story it contains. There is no gap between each track – the action crosses over between them – it's just a good way of splitting the CD up, and most helpful if you haven't the time to listen to a whole CD all at once.
Also included in the CD version of the adaptation is a CD of the music from the story (that's 14 CDs now!), a large scale map as drawn by Tolkien in the book, and a booklet explaining a little of how the adaptation came about. It contains all sorts of interesting fact, such as the way Christopher Tolkien (the son of the author) was sent the manuscripts for him to check over, and how he sent back a tape with all the Middle Earth pronunciations for the series! It makes quite a good read, and has sections written by both Brian Sibley and Jane Morgan (the director), so you get a real insight into how it all happened.
- Who played who?
According to the booklet, some of the casting was a lot easier than others – take a look at some of the main characters and see if you recognise anyone!:
» Frodo Baggins (Ian Holm) The main character in the story, and Holm's diverse portrayal shows both the purely hobbit-like and more adventurous side of the character. » Gandalf the Grey (Michael Hordern) Gandalf the wizard needed an old but wisen voice with an authority, but also a kindly tone at times. Hordern manages all these, and sounds exactly as I would expect Gandalf too. This is probably one of the best castings. » Bilbo Baggins (John le Mesurier) The hobbit from the book's predecessor, and a familiar voice if you don’t know any of the others (Wilson from Dad's Army if you don't know!). » Samwise Gamgee (William Nighy) Loyal but the kind of person who is likely to trip over his own feet if he's not careful, Nighy plays Sam brilliantly. » Gollum (Peter Woodthorpe) Apparantly, Woodthorpe played Gollum in an animated version of LOTR, and he was immediately picked up for this version. The untrustworthy sneaky and pathetic creature that is Gollum is given life by Woodthorpe's portrayal. » Aragorn (Robert Stephens) Stephens gives Aragorn a practical but slightly noble tone, which is exactly what is required.
- Atmosphere's everything
With this sort of dramatisation, it makes a big difference to make it seem real. This requires a good amount of authentic sound effects, and, to a certain extent some quality music. The LOTR dramatisation has both. As you can imagine, it's quite difficult to describe sound effects, but I'll do my best! The battle scenes have lots of roaring and shouting, and the clash of steel against steel, while some of the more moody scenes, like those in Mordor and Moria have a deep rumbling throughout, making it a lot more foreboding. Horses actually sound like horses, rather than just two coconut husks, and you certainly know when something is evil! However, I thought the sound effects for Shelob the spider were a bit off, and, as craiggy_boy informed me, made her sound a bit like Mr. Blobby! Not that we remember such things…
The music is equally important, and composed by Stephen Oliver. The main theme is superb and very well suited to the tone of the story – I always get a tingle of excitement when I hear it, which shows its quality. Most of the incidental music is superb, but I find the music that plays a main part in the story – the actual songs – are, for the most part, a little annoying because of their operatic style. They work for what they are, and can't really be avoided, but I wasn't that keen on them in the book, so it doesn't help when they turn up here! The more poetic rhymes of Bilbo and Frodo, such as 'The Road Goes Ever On', are much more listenable, but the choir-boy 'Seek The Sword That Was Broken' is too ear-piercing for my liking! Well, if you DO like the music, it's pretty much all on the separate music CD, which is nice to listen to once in a while.
- Packaging
The collection itself is packaged in a small A5 size folder type arrangement, inside a black cardboard sleeve. Inside the folder (it's like an A5 pad turned on it's side), there are 16 cardboard wallets, each with a small picture and a caption on it in gold, and these contain the 14 CDs, as well as the fold-out map and booklet. It's all quit nicely presented, although I handle it with much care – I'd kill myself if it got damaged! Each CD itself is black with gold lettering, telling you the name of the episode and each track name too.
- Emotional attachments
The main problem I have with LOTR is the emotional attachments I form with it! The start of each episode is greeting with a rush of adrenaline on my part, and the last few minutes of the story have never failed to bring a tear to my eye. Yes, I know I'm soft, but that's the way I am! I'm pulled deep into the story, feeling anxiety when there's trouble, joy when something good happens, and excitement when there's an action scene. I've felt little like it. And there are few parts of the story that bring me more joy than the reading of the verses that follow, spoken superbly by Michael Hordern:
"Three Rings for the Elven-Kings under the sky, Seven for the Dwarf-lords in their halls of stone, Nine for Mortal Men doomed to die, One for the Dark Lord on his dark throne, In the Land of Mordor where the Shadows lie.
One Ring to rule them all, One Ring to find them. One Ring to bring them all, And in the darkness, bind them. In the Land of Mordor where the Shadows lie."
- Spot the missing bit
Any LOTR veterans will notice the absence of the character Tom Bombadil in this adaptation. For those who don't know, he comes and saves Frodo in the Barrow Downs between Hobbiton and the small town of Bree. It causes some uproar when people found out, but really, it is one of Tolkien's older characters that he just squeezed into Middle Earth for no real reason other than he wanted the character in the story – it doesn't really fit in that well, but people miss him anyway. Just so you know!
- Summary
Overall, I would kidding myself if I gave this any less than 5 stars – while it has it's downfalls, these are duly outweighed by the immense advantages of the product. Sure, I spent £80 on it, which is a bit steep, but when you think about it, you get 14 well presented CDs for that price, and the simple fact that I bought it at this price should tell you just how good it is. Some of the songs can get annoying sometimes, but these are easily avoided, and the superb characterisations and detail brought to the story make it all the more worth the while. This is a superb version of Tolkien's classic book, and one that I will continue to listen to for years to come – well worth the price.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
What a beautifully written op. I am a bit of a newcomer to Ciao, still only a greenie, but am finding my way about. I have done a review on this very same thing, it was my first ever op. I enjoyed reading yours, nice to see a fellow enthusiast. I love all things Tolkien. My copy of this audio book cost me more than £80 though. I think it was about £107. So you were wise to wait to buy it. Does your heart leap when you start to read it? Or listen to it? It takes my imagination, and runs away with it. If you want to chat about Tolkien, pop into my guestbook sometime, and we can have a good old yarn over a pipe full of "Old Toby", ciao for now, Aussieme1106 xx
Advantages: It's a superb story told Superbly with a huge cast. Disadvantages: It's expencive and rare, but it's worth paying alot for and searching alot for
Advantages: True to a fantastic story, excellent actors, great music Disadvantages: Finding time to listen, might surprise those who only know the film
Advantages: A traditional narrative envoking a relaxed mood this audio collection remains true to the book Disadvantages: The over dramatic portrayal of Gollum would scare as many adults as children!