... So what can I add that is new to any former reviews? The answer lies simply in the fact that this is, and will continue to be my favourite book of my lifetime. If this sounds a sweeping statement so be it, but I have read the book about fifteen times, possibly more, I get my old copy down ... Read review
Advantages: The Best book of all Time. Disadvantages: none for me.
...but was put off by the fact that it’s been reviewed seventy-eight times so far. So what can I add that is new to any former reviews? The answer lies simply in the fact that this is, and will continue to be my favourite book of my lifetime. If this sounds a sweeping statement so be it, but I have read the book about fifteen times, possibly more, I get my old copy down at least every two years since the first time I read it some thirty years ago. I ... ...by constant reading, one is the centenary version to commemorate the anniversary of Tolkiens’ birth with fifty full colour illustrations by the artist Alan Lee who worked on the epic film with Peter Jackson.
This was given to me as a Christmas present and at £50 will be rarely read as I intend to pass this down through my family. You could offer me £1000 for the book and I would keep it despite being short of money, such is the value I place ... more
Introduction *********************
I have been longing to review this book for some time now, but was put off by the fact that it’s been reviewed seventy-eight times so far. So what can I add that is new to any former reviews? The answer lies simply in the fact that this is, and will continue to be my favourite book of my lifetime. If this sounds a sweeping statement so be it, but I have read the book about fifteen times, possibly more, I get my old copy down at least every two years since the first time I read it some thirty years ago. I have three copies of the book, two much battered and worn by constant reading, one is the centenary version to commemorate the anniversary of Tolkiens’ birth with fifty full colour illustrations by the artist Alan Lee who worked on the epic film with Peter Jackson. This was given to me as a Christmas present and at £50 will be rarely read as I intend to pass this down through my family. You could offer me £1000 for the book and I would keep it despite being short of money, such is the value I place on it. I first read the book in December 1975 and it took me a week to read it, only pausing because I was working full time and had a baby daughter to bring up on my own. It completely captured my imagination, which as an avid reader was saying a lot about the book. Over the years since then I have taken it out to read for many reasons. The first few times were because I was so enthralled that I felt I had missed many of the meanings of the whole book. After that it became a familiar journey in times of trouble, depression and a longing to escape into fantasy. I have championed the book when people put it down as a mere “fairy tale”, this is unlike myself as I rarely enter into debates on any issue but those that stir up my feelings, such is the power of the book.
Overview
To get the most from the book you really need to get a feeling for the realm in which Tolkien placed the setting. I am oversimplifying this because there are many supporting books, which even I found heavy going to read. Tolkien started to write the background long before he wrote the book itself. “The Hobbit” had delighted so many people when it was first published in 1937 that he was asked to write more about “Hobbits”. At that time he was working on a deep study of “Middle-earth “ and the elfish language. Middle-earth is the setting for both “The Hobbit” and “Lord of the Rings”, it’s people consisted of “High Elves”(the ones which had come from across the sea), The race of Numenor (Men with long lives), dwarves, hobbits, and wizards. On the dark side were Sauron (a bit like the devil) orcs, creatures that existed before the new races arrived and some surprising forces for both good and evil.
The Storyline
It would be confusing to describe this as a “plot” because even Tolkien himself found that as the story developed he found he was going deeper into the “Elder Days” which had been his original idea for a sequel to “The Hobbit”. In his forward to LOTR he quotes the immortal lines “The tale grew in the telling”, referring to how the story took a form of it’s own.
At the start of LOTR the world of middle-earth is beginning to face a war of such proportions that had never been seen since the days when Sauron, the dark force of evil, had been temporarily banished when an army of elves and men had beaten him back in the hope of killing him forever. However, the one ring that Sauron forged secretly to take over the people of middle-earth had not been destroyed as the Elves had begged Isludor, the king of Gondor to cast into the “Mount of Doom” where it had been forged with most of Sauron’s might. Instead he had taken the ring as an heirloom for his family, an act that was to betray him to his death.
By unhappy chance it had been found afterwards by Smeagol, later to be called Gollum, a sad tale of a young man not so very different than hobbits, who was consumed by the power of the ring to corrupt any good to evil. The ring eventually passed to Bilbo, the main character in “The Hobbit”. When Bilbo had celebrated his eleventy-first birthday he gave the ring to Frodo his adopted heir. Gandalf, the wizard has many misgivings over the ring but it’s not for many years that he finally discovers this is the “One ring”, lost by Sauron who is now gathering armies of fell creatures to end the world of men and elves. Frodo escapes the very same day when Sauron’s “Ringwraithes”, undead men, finally visit “The Shire” to bring the ring back to their master. On the long journey from the “Shire” Frodo and his companions escape the clutches of the Ringwraithes and eventually arrive at the house of Elrond a high elf that was at the battle when Sauron’s defeat was halted.
At the council of Elrond many races come together, men, elves, a dwarf and the hobbits. Thus becomes the “Fellowship of the Ring”, when Frodo sets out with eight companions to take the ring to Mount Doom in the land of Mordor where Sauron dwells. Only by casting the ring into the fiery depths will Sauron be defeated. There follows a tale with many setbacks, heroic actions and above all the power of the “one ring” to corrupt the owner. The reader is introduced to each character and their background. The “Hobbits” are small people about half the size of men, they live in rural harmony and appear the last type of folk that would enjoy or participate in any “heroics”. But in the heart of the meekest of Hobbits lies a seed of courage that will prevail. “Aragorn” is the last in line of the heirs of Gondor, now a ranger that roams throughout the land keeping trouble at bay. “Boromir” is the son of the steward of Gondor, a man with his own agenda. Proud and haughty but with the blood of the ancient kings in his veins. Legolas is an elf from the realms of the ancient forests and a prince in his own right, Gimli is the son of Gloin, a dwarf that also has ancient blood-ties. Gandalf is a wizard, known mostly for his expertise with fireworks, but once again a force to be reckoned with. The rest of the fellowship is made up of hobbits, Sam, the loyal friend to Frodo, Merry and Pippin, two little hobbits that feel out of their depth but in the end are called upon to heroic deeds.
We follow the fellowship as their journey begins, firstly through many adventures until the fellowship goes their separate ways. Frodo and Sam take on the task of casting the ring into the very heart of the enemy’s stronghold. Merry and Pippin are captured by orcs and are pursued by Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli. Gandalf’s task is one that takes him to brink of death and beyond. The reader meets new people and races all in a race against time to halt the defeat of middle-earth against all odds. There are many battles fought that stir the blood and keep the reader in constant suspense. Following through the story is the love interest between Aragorn, the last king and Arwen, the elf and the glory of her people. However the story turns out the elves are a race that soon will leave middle-earth for the ancient shores from where they originally came. To say more would spoil the book for the few who may not have read it, Tolkein kept all options open when he was writing the book, he had a good idea of the ending but the journey there took him and his readers through many a dark passage until the end.
My own Thoughts.
If the book had not been made into a blockbuster film this would be my conclusion not my own thoughts. Many people have seen the film by now and yet have not read the book, so this is my own musings on the book itself. If you have seen the film and not read the book then you are missing out on the best book that has ever been written. The films themselves kept fairly faithful to the book, but if you want to know more about the characters, the story or the setting than you should really read the book. I won’t say it is an easy read, at over a thousand pages many readers would be daunted by such a long book, so why should you read it?
Despite being a distinguished academic, Tolkein wrote an epic fantasy story in the simplest of terms. The characters are believable and not once does the author make the reader feel that he/she is beyond their depth in reading the book. There are times when Tolkien writes long songs and tales about the elfish “waking dreams, “ this is a part of the book that many may skip, but to me the folk law was an essential part of the elves characters, they are above the mortal realm and that is one point that stands out as a counterpoint to the simple way of the hobbit lifestyle. Hobbits have their roots in the earth; they are ordinary people, much like the peasants of olden times but without the poverty and poor health. Tolkien paints a picture of rural life at it’s best when people lived simply off the land and enjoyed a lifestyle of ordinary pleasures such as eating, drinking and idly gossiping. Bilbo and Frodo were considered odd because they could both read and write and sometimes met with elves.
In contrast you find the friendship with Gandalf, a rather special bond that sets the two hobbits apart, in this I see the sometimes vision of trying to aspire to something more than the background of peasant farmers. Sam is one such character, a gardener to Bilbo and later to Frodo, but a faithful companion to the end despite his “humble “ background. It’s never hard to identify with such folk, you can picture yourself as an elf, a hobbit, a wizard, a man with destiny in ever fibre of his being. Each time I read the book I can be a different person and escape the life I’m living for a short while, for me this is the ultimate in being carried away with my imagination.
The book will stand the test of time whether or not you are interested in ancient tales there is something here for everyone to enjoy. The idea of good against evil is not a new one, but Tolkien wrote about many things in the book, some that pass you by on a first reading. The Ring of Power seduced many to their deaths that is one point that has rarely been raised before modern times and Tolkien started the book in 1936, a year before “The Hobbit” had been published. At the time when he first started writing it there was not the emphasis on corruption of power that holds true in this day and age. Many critics have suggested that Tolkein was writing about the war years when, in fact, he started the book before the war. The war only held up the completion of the book. One thing that comes through is the advance of industry that the author was aware of from the age of ten. It’s in the book in some part but never takes away the grandiose theme of the “smallest of people “ making a huge difference in the larger scheme of things, a thought to ponder on when this world of ours is getting more and more battered by freak weather, the decline of the rain forests, the advance made of recycling. It almost seems like Tolkin was a prophet in his own way.
If Tolkien meant a message behind the book it doesn’t really detract from the book, this is a simple tale that anyone with an ounce of romance in their soul can read simply as a tale of courage against all odds, the everlasting truth that man can overcome anything with a will to do good.
I’ve read it as a story, I’ve read it when everything seemed bleak and too much effort, it uplifts me, it inspires me, above all it entertains me in an age when entertainment is about which celebrity has the highest profile, I know which one I prefer, do you?
Prices: - For an ordinary copy of LOTR you can expect to pay between £10 and £ 20, depending on the version. My own copy is on offer at £35, a bargain for those that want a copy to hold on to.
Despite the glowing review I’ve given the book I have not said how much I enjoy it, so for those that in any doubt, do you want to know more about the characters? Have you seen the film but hesitate because the book seems too long? You can buy it in three books that seem easier to read, but it’s false economy for once you start to get into the book there will be no hesitation, you will feel compelled to read until your eyes ache.
I love the book, in his forward Tolkien says that many people found some chapters dull others found the same chapters to be the highlight of the story, each to their own I say. I would not miss out any chapter as each reveals a little more about either the characters or Tolkiens’ amazing world. At the risk of boring you to death I will leave you with the rings’ message and ask, ‘can you really not be stirred by such a book?’
“Three rings for the Elven-kings under the sky Seven for the Dwarf-lords in their halls of stone Nine for Mortal men doomed to die, One for the Dark Lord on his dark throne In the land of Mordor where the shadows lie. One ring to rule them, One ring to find them. One ring to bring them all and in the darkness bind them, In the land of Mordor where the shadows lie. ‘
Advantages: One of the most loved books in English literature. Disadvantages: None if you are willing to accept Tolkien's sub-creation.
Before reviewing the Lord of the Rings I need to make a number of opening comments for no better reason that they need to be said. Initially I am aware of how many times this work has been reviewed and I earnestly hope I can bring some fresh perspectives to those who have gone before me (all 80 of you at the last count). Next I would just like to make it clear that I love these books like a treasured possession, they are close to my heart and my ... ...years to adulthood. In reality the books remain at that right hand corner of my bookshelves at home, easily accessible and ready to be read again when the mood takes me. So far this has occurred at least 5 times and I can honestly say that the Lord of the Rings has been my companion through the majority of my literate life.Every time I read it I find something new during my escape to Middle Earth. Lastly and perhaps most importantly, this review ...
britum2000 22.09.2006 (23.09.2006)
· Read full review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful Review of The Lord of the Rings - J.R.R. Tolkien
Advantages: great and fantastic fairytale, one of the best books ever written Disadvantages: a lot of fighting and war
The Lord of the Rings is a marvellous and great book which has been read with enthusiasm by several generations since it was first published almost 50 years ago.
J.R.R. Tolkien started to work on this book as early as in the 30s of the previous century, and he has re-written large parts of it after World War II.
It is unbelievable, but I have read "The Lord of the Rings" for the very first time this year - but certainly not for the last time.
... ...wanted to read the sequel during my summer vacation this year. In total, the three volumes have more than 1,300 pages (plus several hundred pages of appendices).
But once you have started to read, you can't put it away, you just want to continue to the end without any breaks.
Having received a GBP 20 gift certificate from amazon.co.uk, I ordered the paperback version of all three volumes in one box (the books itself were GBP 15.99 but including ...
Michael-S 18.09.2001
· Read full review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful Review of The Lord of the Rings - J.R.R. Tolkien
Advantages: Rich in detail, wonderful and engaging story. Disadvantages: Restricts the imagination for the reader, Poor female characters, Too much pointless material
...having got a third of the way into the first volume I just gave up, bored to tears. But after moving house at the end of the last year the dusty copies found their way from the top of my bookcase and I vowed that I was going to read them if it killed me. I started them again last week and have managed to finish them in just seven nights, at a thousand pages with a life to lead too aren’t you impressed?
The word epic could have been invented for ... ...clear of the ‘classics’ as I find then hard going and I read as a means of enjoyment not intellectual challenge. I did however enjoy the film and have yet to read a book that wasn’t far superior to the film. Also I couldn’t wait another year to find out what was going to happen.
This is the tale of the great ring forged by the evil lord Sauron in the fires of mount doom. Sauron bound the majority of his power in with the ring and when it was lost ...
michaird 08.01.2003
· Read full review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful Review of The Lord of the Rings - J.R.R. Tolkien
...so dwarfs all to get the treasures from the mountain. And on the way they have bout a thousand different troubles and situations like 3 trolls who were really hungry, many spiders who were really hungry too, orcs an wolves who were also as hungry as anyone else and wanted to eat the poor hobbit with his dwarf friends. But on the way they have a very important adventure. The hobbit (whose name was Bilbo by the way) gets lost in the caves in the mountains. ... ...the floor he found something and put this something in his pocket (gypsy!!). The he heard someone screaming “My precioussssss, losssst…” and went to check it out. It was a creature called Gorlum who has lost his ring. They play a little riddle game. If Bilbo wins – Gollum will show him the way to the exit. If Gollum wins, he will eat little hobbit. And the last riddle that Bilbo asked is “What’s in my pocket?” ...
Netming 31.05.2002
· Read full review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful Review of The Lord of the Rings - J.R.R. Tolkien
Advantages: everything Disadvantages: it got over...
The English-speaking world is divided into those who have read The Lord of the Rings and those who plan to read it – Sunday Times
A Story Magnificently told, with every kind of colour and movement and greatness – New Statesman
Another Monument to the incredible imagination of Tolkien – The Sunday Telegraph The Lord of the Rings deserves all this praise and much more. I am not going to use the abbreviation LOTR for the book as ... ...before it’s publication in 1937. The first volume was “The Fellowship of the Ring” was published in Great Britain on 29 July 1954. The second volume “The Two Towers” was published on 11 November 1954 and the final Volume “The Return of the King” was published on 20 October 1955. With this release, all the three volumes were published in a single book – The Lord of the Rings.
Plot – A separate ...
mysticguy 16.04.2002
· Read full review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful Review of The Lord of the Rings - J.R.R. Tolkien
Would you read it again?
Story
Characters
Readability
How does it compare to ...
How does it compare to ...
Similar reviews »
Reviews which might be of interest for "The Lord of the Rings - J.R.R. Tolkien"
Advantages: A brilliant, brilliant story Disadvantages: Absolutely none
to trailers, interviews with the stars and the making of the films. There are also exclusive downloads and the chance to join the Fellowship to get e-mail updates. Best for: those wanting sneak previews or to find out about the next instalments.
“www.tolkien.co.uk tolkien.co.uk> HarperCollins, the publisher, was so swamped by Tolkien-related queries that it launched this site dedicated to the author. - Best for: current book editions, box sets, limited-edition print runs and audio versions. The website includes a biography of Tolkien, Q&A chat forums with his biographers, competitions and downloadable first chapters from The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings. Fans can also access Tolkien's maps and illustrations of Middle-earth. Contact: Editor for JRRTolkien, HarperCollins Publishers, 77-85 Fulham Palace Road ...
Advantages: once you get the boring stuff out of the way, the book is good Disadvantages: too much description
I am going to talk about the very first lord of the rings book, The fellowship of the ring part one. This book, has a great deal of adventure in, and doesn't lack in description. If anyone has read this book, im sure they would agree that this book may have a bit tooo much description in.
Description is good, but when you get too explaining every blade of grass to the last detail you may get bored. Even though i wanted to quit reading it so bad, i kept going because i know it does get better.
You go on this wonderful adventure with Frodo Baggins from Bag end. Along with Sam, his loyful companion. You meet loads of interesting characters on the way including, Tom who is like the god of all land, sea and sky in the area were he lives. And tom one day stumbles across the poor hobbits in a spot of bother and helps them out.
You ...
Advantages: True to a fantastic story, excellent actors, great music Disadvantages: Finding time to listen, might surprise those who only know the film
Before Peter Jackson?s remarkable film trilogy, if you didn?t want to plough your way through the mighty tomes that make up J.R.R.Tolkein?s ?Lord of the Rings?, the only option available was the BBC Radio 4 radio adaptation, which was first broadcast in 1981. Fortunately, this is one of the finest pieces of radio drama ever made, with a host of star names playing the roles.
VERY QUICK PLOT OVERVIEW
The second age of middle earth is drawing to an end, which marks the passing of the age of elves and the coming of the age of men. The last struggle of the old order is to ensure that the One Ring of power made by the elves? great foe, Sauron, is destroyed, even if this ensures the doom of the elves. Unfortunately, destroying this ring is not an easy task, but it falls to Frodo to carry it out. Frodo is a hobbit ? hobbits are small ...
Product Information for "The Lord of the Rings - J.R.R. Tolkien" »
Product details
Type
Fiction
Genre
Fantasy
Title
The Lord of the Rings
Author
J.R.R. Tolkien
ISBN
7203632
EAN
9780007203635
Manufacturer's product description
Four-volume paperback boxed set containing J.R.R. Tolkien's classic masterpiece, together with The Lord of the Rings: A Reader's Companion, an annotated guide to all three parts of the Book of the Century. Since it was first published in 1954, The Lord of the Rings has been a book people have treasured. Steeped in unrivalled magic and otherworldliness, its sweeping fantasy has touched the hearts of young and old alike. One hundred million copies of its many editions have been sold around the world, and occasional collectors' editions become prized and valuable items of publishing. Now, to celebrate the 50th anniversary of its first publication, the text has been fully restored with almost 400 corrections - with the full co-operation of Christopher Tolkien - making it the definitive version of the text, and as close as possible to the version that J.R.R. Tolkien wanted. In addition to now having the definitive version of the text, this paperback set also includes a companion volume, The Lord of the Rings: A Reader's Companion, a unique annotated guide to the text, which will enhance the reader's enjoyment and understanding of the book of the 20th century.
Compare The Lord of the Rings - J.R.R. Tolkien to other similar Fantasy Books »
Similar products and search queries by other users »
The JRR, The Lord JRR, The of JRR, The the JRR, The Rings JRR, The Lord of JRR, The Lord the JRR, The Lord Rings JRR, The of the JRR, The of Rings JRR, The the Rings JRR, The Lord of the JRR, The Lord of Rings JRR, The Lord the Rings JRR, The of the Rings JRR
Are you the manufacturer / provider of The Lord of the Rings - J.R.R. Tolkien? Click here