Wow, I actually got something from the Premium Fund this month! :-o! 634 ratings given but 750 rati...
Wow, I actually got something from the Premium Fund this month! :-o! 634 ratings given but 750 ratings received.. I must do better. :(
Member since:29.08.2008
Reviews:51
Members who trust:14
Carlos Ruiz Zafón is a spanish novelist, who has been living in LA for 15 years. He released Shadow of the Wind in Spanish in 2001, meeting with wide success, selling more than millions of books worldwide.
' The city is a sorceress, you know, Daniel? It gets under your skin and steals your soul without you knowing it....'
I was drawn to the book that I saw standing in Waterstone's, the cover looked so mysterious and almost-philosophical that I felt compelled to purchase this. It was a great blind purchase based on the book cover which I do not regret at all.
This book is set in 1945, Barcelona is still wiping off the dust from the cruelties of the civil war and WW2, a young boy called Daniel Sampere who is a sensitive and thoughtful soul, who is shown by his father 'The Cemetery of Forgotten Books', hidden in the heart of Barcelona. It is a labyrinthine library where they store obscure and forgotten works of authors from not long ago. He is given a gift of one book, any book in the entire place. He is drawn towards a book of 'The Shadow of the Wind' written by Julian Carax. The young boy becomes mesmerised with the book and becomes his favourite book.
The book combines many genres from Gothic
mystery to romance, with hints of Victorian-19th century literature style embedded in Zafón's writing style which I found rather a breeze to read through when getting into it; people at first might find it a challenge to get into the book but gradually, it becomes much easier to read. Zafón doesn't seem to have a weak genre and handles the range of scenes very well; putting in a few emotional pages which did touch me successfully.
It all starts with a very young mother-less boy who strives towards his father for guidance on how to deal with his mother's death, as he worries he no longer can picture her face, which sets the tone of the book; he is lost and naive. The book revolves around his comfortable life, helping his father selling books in a small bookshop, he falls in love with a book-keeper's daughter which was doomed before it even started. The book keeps track of the high and lows of Daniel's life, the trials and obstacles he must tackle. He has learnt from his short experiences very well and becomes a level-headed young man. He becomes fixated with 'Shadow of the Wind' and its curious disappearance of the author when he is confronted with a shadowed figure smoking a cigarette on a balcony who offers Daniel a large sum of money for the books. Who was he, why did he want the books, why are they being destroyed?
The plot does seem a little thin but Zafón has successfully used the 'horse and carrot' routine very well. He feeds us, the reader, little bits of information as he goes along, increasing the suspense that we just have to carry on reading! This has lead to a fantastically dramatic book, he has introduced so many characters that they all interweave into the plot which made the suspense even worse as we try to figure out the mystery. Towards the end, we begin to realise that Zafón has expertly put together the plot so well; we find out what exactly happened to Carax and recognise that actually, Daniel has followed in his favourite's author footsteps without realising.
In the middle and the end of the book, despite me enjoying it, it did feel really rushed as if Zafón had a set number of pages and he tried to cram all the action in, which made the pace seem too quick than it should have done, which could have been more effective than it was. I suppose it may be that the start of the book was rather slow that we got into it, then it suddenly changes pace for the good or the worse, I am not sure.
Zafón has crafted the characters with much love and care that when I was reading the book, he made the characters seem one-dimensional at first but after through several scenes/episodes he does explain why this character has come to be so. I particularly enjoyed it when he did a very thorough description of Julian Carax's mother, who was stuck in a marriage she didn't like with a cold and unfeeling husband and explained how it came to be like that, and displayed the mother's suffering in an extraordinary detail that left me wanting to hear more about the mother. He has created such a fantastic range of characters, every one of them had an interesting story to tell, whether it was something they'd been through or the development of how they became to be, like for example, I liked how he developed Clara and Daniel's relationship. It was approached delicately, and on the side he explores the character Clara so well. He does write about the human condition so well that I was able to connect with some of the characters.
I did initially have low expectations due to the original language of the book had been translated into English and I have been victim to badly translated books- Henning Mankell and similar books. However, Lucia Graves has done a fantastic job on the translation, it is near enough perfect.
At 506 pages, this is not a book that you can just get through in couple nights, this requires commitment to finish it!
*Shortlisted by Richard and Judy Book Club In the back of the book, the author has included a very good guide that includes maps of the areas that are described in the book, which does make the book more special, he makes notes of where certain characters lived- Nuria Monfort's apartment, Cemetery of Lost Books, Daniel's bookshop and many other places. This is a very special addition to this book!
In all, it is a very captivating read that will grab your attention with its very dramatic plot, characters seemingly shallow but with rich depth and personality; it will keep you up nights, no matter what you do. If anyone is interested, there is a prequel to this book called The Angel's Game which was released quite recently.
====================================
Pictures of The Shadow of the Wind - Carlos Ruiz Zafon
The Shadow of the Wind - Carlos Ruiz Zafon
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
I think I could tackle this - I don't agree with Malu either - how can you juudge how good a book is or whether or not to read it, based on how many pages it has, for goodness sake!! xxxxx
Rampant_Ross 25.07.2009 23:40
Sounds good, don't think i could be bothered to read it though.
Advantages: A truly exceptional book; impossible to put down Disadvantages: Sleepless nights sitting up delving further into the mystery of Julian Carax
Advantages: Gripping plot, interesting period of history (to me) Disadvantages: Poor characterisation, repetitive writing, assumes in depth knowledge of period