Discerna 4

Discerna

Add to my Circle of Trust

Subscribe to reviews

About me:

Member since:26.03.2003

Reviews:124

Members who trust:53

Quote-start

True Love in a False Paradise

Quote-end
15.08.2003

Advantages:
Good storyline, interesting characters, humour/feel - good factor, hidden meanings open to interpretation

Disadvantages:
Some of the make - believe a bit over the top

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Would you read it again?

Story

Characters

Readability

How does it compare to similar works?Quite good

How does it compare to works by the same author?Quite good

29 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful See ratings
exceptional by (6%):
  1. hasbok
  2. reginabelga
  3. Baskin
very helpful by (91%):
  1. sit2020
  2. clairearnold
  3. VickyVickster
and 46 other members
helpful by (4%):
  1. Piers85
  2. herby30

View all ratings

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Share this review on Google+

I first saw a production of the Tempest when I was far too young to understand the language or appreciate the plot. I recall that I was frightened by the opening scene that (if acted well) portrays very vividly the terror of shipwreck. I was then bemused by the attempts of the adults with me to explain the whole idea of spirits that could be conjured up by magicians to control the winds. These same adults were the ones responsible for my rational upbringing through which, by the age of seven, I already knew to disregard fairies and the like as childish things. I had no understanding of drunkenness so the humour of the later scenes involving drunken sailors was completely lost on me. I think I would have been horrified by the treatment meted out to the slave, having no sense of historical perspective in which to place this. I was too young also to appreciate the romantic storyline of love at first sight being blind to all obstacles in its path. I remember being vaguely reassured that it was a happy ending and content with the explanation that it was all make-believe, if more than a little puzzled by the extent of adult interest in it.

Returning to this play through adult eyes I find it much more interesting. The overall message is a feel-good one: that in the final analysis love and forgiveness triumph over hatred, plotting and revenge. In choosing this theme, Shakespeare wisely kept to a safe non-sectarian Christian message, unlikely to cause offence to either Catholic or Protestant audience members. In choosing to explore the use of spirits and magic in a remote island setting, Shakespeare also avoided much explicit reference to established religion. The play was written in 1611 in the reign of James I. The stability of Elizabeth I’s reign had come to an end. Shakespeare, himself, was an old man as is the central character of the play, Prospero.

The plot

Prospero is living on an island with his daughter, Miranda, served by a spirit, Ariel, and a slave, Caliban. Once the Duke of Milan, but usurped in that position by his brother Antonio and forced into exile, Prospero invokes magic to lure his adversaries to the island and into his power with the intent of righting the wrongs of the past. Antonio is shipwrecked together with Alonso (King of Naples), his brother Sebastian and his son Ferdinand. Sebastian is ambitious and plans to kill Alonso so that he can become King of Naples. When Miranda and Ferdinand fall in love, however, the united future of Milan and Naples looks assured, and the futility of all the various plots, past and present, among the older generations becomes apparent. In parallel with this storyline, it emerges that Caliban has a prior claim to the island that Prospero has seized, and is seeking revenge. His attempts towards this provide humour and he is in due course pardoned by Prospero who by the end of the play is intent on relinquishing his powers and retiring.

The Virginia Connection

For me, the most interesting aspect of this play is the number of parallels that can be drawn with real events that occurred in and around Virginia at that time. In 1611 news from the new colonies would be circulating at many levels within society. Returning adventurers would have to account for massive disasters; many of their crews would relate their own versions of encounters with the savages in distant lands. Spin would be applied to save face or “heads would roll” (literally in those days). Many of the explanations would undoubtedly include magic spirits to account for ill fortune. It would be hard to know what to believe. It is known that Shakespeare referenced an account of the 1609 journey to Virginia that resulted in a shipwreck in the Bermudas but I think it highly likely that he had access to other contemporary accounts whether written or word-of-mouth. Is it possible that Shakespeare already knew that among the savages encountered, a father and daughter: Powhatan and Pocahontas would stand out in history? Powhatan had already been crowned as a vassal king with allegiance to James I, although it is clear from accounts of the proceedings that he did not understand the ceremony. Captain Smith whose life Pocahontas is said to have saved, was already back in London, describing her exceptional intelligence and her all-powerful father, in stark contrast to any previously held views of “savages” almost certainly represented in the Tempest by the ugly, uneducated Caliban.

Gossip at the time included the idea that previous settlers in Virginia who had gone missing might have been absorbed into native communities. This was supported by a sighting of a relatively white native child and must have aroused very many mixed feelings. Shakespeare could not have foreseen that only 3 years later, Pocahontas would marry John Rolfe, an English settler and that she would accompany him on his return to England in 1616.

The pre-nuptials

Within the play there is an entertainment in the form of singing and dancing of nymphs to celebrate the love match. I found this section quite tedious to read, but in a performance it gives the producer a lot of scope for imaginative and stunning visual effects. The play seems designed to be performed on the night before the solemnisation of a wedding which begs the question whether it was originally written with a particular wedding in mind. Some commentators have suggested Frederick V as a candidate although his wedding did not take place until 1613. While it is possible to view this section as a celebration only of the union of Miranda and Ferdinand, it is more likely that it was intended as a wedding masque.

Old age and other themes

Towards the end of the play, once love and freedom have triumphed, we are left to ponder just how much of what we have seen was in any sense “real” and to reflect with Prospero (and with Shakespeare) on the outlook of diminished powers in retirement and old age. Were my parents right when they assured me that this was a happy ending? I’m not so sure.

As with much of Shakespeare’s work, there are timeless themes within the play that still hold a relevance to today’s audiences. Questions that remain unanswered over the centuries: To what extent should any individual wield power over another?; To what extent should one culture enforce itself upon another? To what extent should youth respect the wisdom of age? Shakespeare doesn’t offer solutions, only observations. We get to see characters acting foolishly and others acting wisely. We have the freedom to judge and act for ourselves. Prospero, at the very least, shows us how to accept our personal limitations with dignity.


.


  Write your own review

Share this review on Google+

  Next review »

Rate this review »

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

Rate as exceptional

Rate as somewhat helpful

Rate as very helpful

Rate as not helpful

Rate as helpful

Rate as off topic

Write your own review Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful. Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful.   Report a problem with this review’s content

Comments about this review »

Piers85 21.08.2007 12:56

excellent detailed commentary, i must read it again!

hasbok 27.03.2006 00:28

an outstanding review, superb.

reginabelga 28.01.2005 14:45

Excellent critique. A professor could not improve this review. It covers all aspects of the play plus interesting and thought-provoking historical background. I didn't appreciate it when I had to study it. I thought it was a load of nonsense and that Shakespeare was losing his touch. But then I was struggling with the language; let alone Shakespearean use of language. Do do some more and enlighten us all.

Add your comment

max. 2000 characters

  Post comment

Compare prices »

1 to 15 out of 15 offers for The Tempest - William Shakespeare   Sorted by: Price 
The Tempest - Penguin Classics

The Tempest - Penguin Classics

Status: New - Pages: 112, Paperback, Penguin Classics

8 more offers (£2.14 to £6.80) from this merchant

amazon marketplace books

 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace b...
Postage & Packaging£4.01
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
amazon marketplace books

Product Information »

Product details

EAN 9780743482837, 9781854598097
ISBN 0743482832, 1854598090
Type Play
Title The Tempest
Author William Shakespeare

Show all Product Information

More reviews »

The Tempest - William Shakespeare - review by MI9to5

Quote-start Whip up a Storm Quote-start

very helpful

The Tempest - William Shakespeare - review by Bryn_Pearson

Quote-start Kings and monsters Quote-start

very helpful

The Tempest - William Shakespeare - review by lil_devilg

Quote-start Anarchy Rules... Quote-start

very helpful

The Tempest - William Shakespeare - review by crapitoche

Quote-start sorry... Quote-start

very helpful

The Tempest - William Shakespeare - review by dave27

Quote-start Underrated Quote-start

helpful

Review Ratings »

This review of The Tempest - William Shakespeare has been rated:

"exceptional" by (6%):

  1. hasbok
  2. reginabelga
  3. Baskin

"very helpful" by (91%):

  1. sit2020
  2. clairearnold
  3. VickyVickster

and 46 other members

"helpful" by (4%):

  1. Piers85
  2. herby30

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.



Are you the manufacturer / provider of The Tempest - William Shakespeare? Click here