hiker 5

hiker

Add to my Circle of Trust

Subscribe to reviews

About me: Still trying to sort out the electronics, but at least back on line and catching up with some of it. Looking forward to the next big trip. Lx

Member since:28.03.2003

Reviews:593

Video reviews:1

Members who trust:86

Quote-start

Unknown and Yet Well Known

Quote-end
06.05.2012

Advantages:
Detailed, Highly Personal, Deeply Moving

Disadvantages:
None

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Degree of Information

How easy was it to read / get information from

How interesting was the book?

How useful was it?

Would you read it again?

Value for money

37 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful See ratings
exceptional by (32%):
  1. Coloneljohn
  2. Mildew82
  3. fizzytom
and 9 other members
very helpful by (68%):
  1. Amazingwoo
  2. MAFARRIMOND
  3. catsholiday
and 23 other members

View all ratings

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Share this review on Google+

The 1914-18 War has many epithets: the First World War (a title it acquired while it was still being fought), the Great War, most evocatively (and falsely) the War To End All Wars…

Nearly a hundred years after it first began, it still haunts the European sensibility like no other conflict before or since. Partly, this is because it occurred at the dawn of mass media, it was the first time that such widespread reporting of what was actually happening as it happened occurred. Reporting that didn't just reach governments and military families, but which touched everyone in the country. The war was being fought in a foreign land, but everyone at home would sooner or later be somehow involved. Partly it is the vivid destruction of a landscape over broad swathes of western Europe. The images of the destruction are inescapable. Mostly though, it is because of the sheer scale of loss in human terms. Over 5 million deaths among the allied servicemen and a further 3 million from the central powers, with a further 13 and 8 million respectively wounded – many of whom would die later of those wounds.

Some 16 'nations' were involved – and that is treating the British Empire as a single nation, and Austro-Hungary similarly.

There many were other 'firsts' about the First World War that stay in our minds. Technology and science were moving on a pace at the dawn of the 20th century and the military as always were in the vanguard. This war saw the first widespread use of poison gas, the first (and not always effective) use of tanks, of planes, and yet, oddly, it also became the most stagnant stationary wars ever fought. Both sides became dug in, in foul unliveable trenches, holding battle lines that scarcely shifted a few miles for the whole long experience.

It is also the earliest war from which their remains a solid archive of personal material – letters home, personal documents and mementoes, kept by the families. It is the earliest war that we can still "touch" on a very personal level.

It also gave us our modern rituals of remembrance.

Born out of that war were the Cenotaph – Britain's national memorial to its war dead – our still-honoured keeping of Armistice Day (and the adjacent Remembrance Sunday), the poppy as a symbol of Flanders fields and other places of similar bloodshed and, in Westminster Abbey, the Tomb of the Unknown Warrior.

The unknown soldier who lies buried among the good and the great probably is a soldier. Great efforts were made to ensure that he would be a warrior (potentially a soldier or an airman or a sailor) for reasons that Hanson explains, but (as he also allows) other requirements pertained that imply that almost certainly 'a soldier' lies buried in the Abbey.

Whoever he was in life, that Unknown was the only one of the near one million British war-dead to be returned to his homeland and his state funeral some two years after the end of the war brought the entire country to a standstill, and marked the beginning of a 'pilgrimage' that continued for days and was to be repeated for years. Only the outbreak of a new World War would see a shifting to the public response.

We will never know who he was, that was part of the point, so that he could 'just possibly' be any mother's son, widow's husband, orphan's father, bereft's brother… but Hanson goes back to the war to show us not just who he might have been, but also who any of the American unknowns might have been, any of the Germans (although unlike the allies they did not take up the symbolism). Hanson picks three warriors, 'unknown' in the wider scale of things, but who can be known through the testimony of their own letters home and the memories of those who survived them: Alec Reader, George Seibold and Paul Hubb stand in for the millions of others.

Walking with them through the carnage was a padre, David Railton, who survived the conflict and was the originator of the idea for the abbey burial. He too is intrinsic to Hanson's telling of history.

And the view they give us on the war is breathtaking, moving, and above all intensely human.

Alec Reader was four months short of his eighteenth birthday when he went to war in August 1915, signing up to the Prince of Wales Own Civil Service Rifles. Being technically under-age wasn't going to matter at a time when boys as young as fourteen were lying to get into the army. Later in the war, he would come to take a different view. He would live through the worst of the trenches but eventually be claimed on the Somme, just as a clerical oversight was slowing down his possible transfer out of the front lines.

Paul Hubb was a 23-year-old from Stetten-im-Remstal down near the German/Swiss border. Limping from a childhood accident that left him with one leg shorter than the other and short-sighted enough to need glasses didn't keep him from the front. He was working as a legal clerk when war was declared, but consummate with his position in society (as the son of a teacher, and fledgling member of the legal profession) he signed up immediately to the First Company of the 247th Infantry Regiment. He too would see the worst of the worst of the Somme and Passchendaele… he would be seriously injured in his inaugural visit to the lines, but return to struggle on. His jubilant all-for-the-fatherland tone slows and slides into depression as the long slog continued through until 1918. He'd have known the war was lost by the time he fell at Maricourt.

George Seibold was a newly-married 23-year-old when he joined the fight. As an American he'd have been well away from the horrors for the first three years of the war, but by 1917 the States had been moved to commit. Coming from a well-off family with Washington connections he'd have had a stellar political career in any other time. He'd already been to officer training school when the US declaration was issued in April 1917, but with the draft still being drawn up he didn't wait but volunteered for the Aviation Section of the Signal Corps. Aerial warfare was in its infancy but while it avoided the horrors of the trenches, it carried with it stresses and mental strain no less equivalent. The average "air-life" of pilots was reckoned at 48 hours. Seibold was last reliably spotted in the air. It's known roughly where his plane went down, and there is a witness report that might refer to him on the ground, but unconfirmed.

These three – and the padre that walked amongst them – are Hanson's guides to a very personal experience of war. He gives us only as little of the battle-plan and progress as we need to understand the context. For the most part he relies on the eye-witness testimony of these four (no doubt supported by letters and memories of others who fought and likely died along-side them). It's not so much a history book as a portrait of war. Images and thoughts. Impressions.

There are moments of humour, bleak as you'd expect, but also glimpses into the almost-taboo areas of triumphalism and a simple quest for adventure that drove them to go in the first place. It's significant that the author's chosen representatives are among those who went willingly and early, whose lives were freely given. And in the case of Seibold in particular the sheer exhilaration of flying seems to have been reason enough.

With the wealth of material available it's no surprise that a writer would choose those who could write a good letter and there is no shortage of the lyric and picturesque description of battlefield lulls among the fear and torment of action. There is also the self-analysis of the callousness of attitude that cannot help but creep in, when fallen fellows are used to prop up a trench wall or provide a semi-stable footway through glutinous mudfields. But it's the mundane details that linger. The similarities of thought on the two sides of the divide. And the differences: while Reader was writing home asking for money and socks, Hubb was scavenging from the battlefield to send food back to his starving family.

The Unknown Soldier would be a worthy read if it ended when all of our protagonists were dead. The most moving sections are yet to come. The final quarter of the book is given over to what happened after the Armistice: the campaigns to bring them home (or not), the construction of the Cenotaph and David Railton's notion of a single body to lie honoured for all of the fallen – a tradition that has been taken up around the world. The details of the selection of the Unknown Warrior, and the description of the Armisticetide in 1920 when he was brought home and lain to rest with all due ceremonial, "the Great Silence" of the day and the "Great Pilgrimage" that followed are both interesting and deeply touching to one who is several generations away from it all.

Highly recommended.

"Lest We Forget"

~

Published in paperback under the Corgi imprint of Transworld

668 pages, including a 29-page index, 26-page bibliography and 91 pages of notes.

Additionally there are 16 pages of photographic montages

ISBN 978-0-552-14976-1
Cover price £8.99

~

© Lesley Mason
hiker @ Ciao.co.uk
6.5.12

  Write your own review

Share this review on Google+

 

Rate this review »

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

Rate as exceptional

Rate as somewhat helpful

Rate as very helpful

Rate as not helpful

Rate as helpful

Rate as off topic

Write your own review Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful. Write a review and you will earn 0.5p per rating if other members rate your review at least helpful.   Report a problem with this review’s content

Comments about this review »

Coloneljohn 19.05.2012 09:36

Excellently reviewed. John

catsholiday 10.05.2012 20:39

What a very sensitive review of this book

Mildew82 09.05.2012 13:25

Sounds a fabulous read of a grim topic!

Add your comment

max. 2000 characters

  Post comment

Compare prices »

1 to 2 out of 2 offers for The Unknown Soldier - Neil Hanson   Sorted by: Price 

Product Information »

Manufacturer's product description

Of all the million British dead of the First World War, only one - the Unknown Soldier - was ever returned to his n...

Product details

Type Non-Fiction
Genre Biography
Title The Unknown Soldier

Ciao

Listed on Ciao since 30/07/2009

Show all Product Information

Review Ratings »

This review of The Unknown Soldier - Neil Hanson has been rated:

"exceptional" by (32%):

  1. Coloneljohn
  2. Mildew82
  3. fizzytom

and 9 other members

"very helpful" by (68%):

  1. Amazingwoo
  2. MAFARRIMOND
  3. catsholiday

and 23 other members

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.

Products you might be interested in »

The Two of Us - Sheila Hancock

The Two of Us - Sheila Hancock

Non-Fiction - Biography - ISBN: 0747570205, 0747577099, 1582344175

User reviews (7)

Buy now for only £ 1.20



Are you the manufacturer / provider of The Unknown Soldier - Neil Hanson? Click here