Home > Books > Fiction > Children's Books > T Children's Books
BE CAREFUL WHAT YOU WISH FOR... Review with images 46 of 46 Ciao Users found the following review helpful
Rating from whoopidoo 4 Stars ()

Advantages Humor, great for adults & children alike

Disadvantages Dissapointingly short

When 14 year old Meg’s Mother dies her world is turned upside down. Left in the care of an abusive stepfather she falls into bad company. After a bungled burglary goes disastrously wrong Meg finds herself hurtling down the tunnel towards life in the here after. Just one problem. Meg’s soul isn’t erring on the side of bad nor is it erring on the side of good. Totally divided - both capable of tremendous wickedness and overwhelming goodness Meg is in the unusual position of not being able to float upwards towards the Pearly Gates and, thankfully, not able to plummet downwards towards the fiery pits of Hell.

Wish Cover
With both Saint Peter and Satan fighting for sole ownership of her soul Meg has to return to earth to try and redeem herself. In ghost form she returns to the scene of the bungled burglary, to a not too happy to see her elderly gentleman. In order to get through the Pearly Gates Meg must prove she is more good than bad. She must make it up to the wrinkled old codger she tried to burgle. Meg must fulfil the Wish List.

And she aint got long.

I discovered Eoin Colfer when the girls were taking ages in the library one-day; stumbled across his fantastic Artemis Fowl series and was hooked. So, much to the librarian’s amusement, I am now regularly seen fighting with the youngsters over the newest books in the children’s section.

Needless to say when our small local library finally got this one in I was the proud first stampee. Completed in two hours to much chortling I really was sorry to put this one down. I find Colfer's ability to mix humour with some tragic scenarios really compelling. Let’s face it, who could have a 14 year old burgling a house and then killed within the space of two or three pages and yet manage to raise a chuckle at the imagery? You shouldn’t laugh - but you do. And heck - she does *try* to make it all better... just a bit late that’s all.

I found the humour itself to be quite adult in some places, not rude, just very dry, sarcastic even. I don’t think I would have ‘got it’ as a kid. There is still a lot of in your face slapstick comedy that younger children (and me) will love. So even if the other parts go flying over their heads the book still has plenty of funnies to keep them entertained.


The story is a really good yarn in itself but it’s great the way Colfer has entwined some morality and consequence within the explosions and death. Very well done. Ultimately the story is the age old battle of Good versus Bad. Which side will Meg fall on? Will Saint Peter be able to stop Beelzebub from sending one of his Soul Catchers to trip Meg up or will he let her decipher Good from Bad on her own?
More importantly will he ever be lucky enough to get a programmer up to the gates of Heaven to computerise his ancient ledger - or will he be eternally watching them all go to Hell, destined never to have his files to hand at the click of a mouse.

My only gripe with this book is that it could have done so much more. So many amusing characters were introduced that I would love to have seen again.

Detailed Rating

Would you read it again?
Story
Characters
Readability
How does it compare to similar books?
How does it compare to other works by the same author?

The Author

whoopidoo

Author's newest reviews

Rate this User Review

How helpful was this review to you? Rating guidelines

Attention, this is the first review from this author

Instead of giving a negative rating, consider:

  • Help this member by giving your advice

  • Report fraud (for example plagiarism) or other issue with the review to the Ciao support team

Activate low rating buttons

Add your comment

 Post comment  Post comment

JavaScript should be enabled to rate or post a comment.

Comments

Maybe you have a question about The Wish List - Eoin Colfer? Ask here
Previous page Next page Page 1 of 10 | 1 - 5 out of 46 comments
  • chick220 02/11/2006 19:25
    Rated this review as
    Very Helpful
  • mgcom 24/01/2006 21:01
    Rated this review as
    Very Helpful

    I loved this review. I think I know what I will spend the book tokens I got for my birthday :) - Mark

  • DavidBedford 03/09/2005 00:07
    Rated this review as
    Very Helpful
  • Pmshack99 05/08/2005 20:04
    Rated this review as
    Very Helpful

    this sounds like a fun concept for a book! paula x

  • d2me 12/03/2005 11:32
    Rated this review as
    Very Helpful
Previous page Next page Page 1 of 10 | 1 - 5 out of 46 comments

More reviews

for The Wish List - Eoin Colfer

Compare prices

for The Wish List - Eoin Colfer