Troy

Advantages: See review
Disadvantages: See review

...Troy was a breath-taking film with a brilliant plot (admittedly based on a legend), amazing characters and some amazing special effects. Story The story was well written and believable, however, it is based on a historical legend and is not the work of the makers of the film, so while I liked it, I can't give anybody credit for it. The story was also refreshing in that the good guys lost, which is original. 4/5 Characters/ performances This film had an amazing set of characters portrayed by some truly gifted actors such as Brad Pitt and Orlando Bloom. There was a nice mix of brave, selfless heroes and some twisted villains. However, the film also impressed me in that it didn't see characters in black and white as many films do and there was good within evil and evil within good. There was also something to look...

anakha6 18.11.2008 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average helpful
Review of Troy (DVD)

'Troy' An epic tale of Greece and Troy

Advantages: Epic storyline, Brad Pitt fans will enjoy!
Disadvantages: A little long winded in parts

...Review of ?Troy? 2 Disc Special Edition DVD The DVD I am reviewing the 2 disc special edition of the DVD. The movie was produced in 2004 by Warner Bros. Pictures. The movie received mediocre praise from the critics for the retelling of Homer's ?The Iliad?. The storyline is fairly loosely based on The Iliad, and Hollywood has used it's artist license to add to the tale. The Special Edition consists of the 2 discs, one being the actual movie and the other a very interesting mixture of special effect techniques used in the production, an analysis of the battle scenes, a 3D animated guide to Greek myths and a look at the design of the sets used and the comparisons between Greek temples and ruins of the time. ASIN: B0002TR7OG The DVD has a runtime of 156 minutes, has subtitles in Danish, English, Finnish, German, Hebrew...

brittle1906 30.08.2009 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average helpful
Review of Troy (DVD)

Helen of Troy

Advantages: Gives a Slightly Different Version of Events
Disadvantages: Is A Bit Long

...The story of Troy is a well known one and I think this is one of the better versions out there although by no means the best. The film opens with a few scenes of different characters in the movie as the narrator, who we later learn is Menelaus, tells that what is to follow are the true events surrounding the great Trojan war and the downfall of the mighty city of Troy. We then see a young Cassandra running to her parents King Priam played by John Rhys-Davies and Queen Hecuba played by Maryam D'Abo. The Queen has just given birth to a baby son who has been named Alexandros. However Cassandra warns them that this child will bring about the destruction of Troy unless they kill him. Both parents believe wholeheartedly in Cassandra's predictions and so arrange for Alexandros to be left atop a hillside to die. However a passerby finds...

Merced 27.08.2007 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average helpful
Review of Helen Of Troy (DVD)

Troy

Advantages: An enjoyed few hours
Disadvantages: None

...For power and honour, two worlds will go to war, thousands will fall in pursuit of the glory. A nation will burn to the ground, and all for love... This is Homer's story, a Greek writer and philosopher from 800BC, his famous Iliad, which is a mixture of Homer's opinions, mythology and fact. Troy is a movie written by David Benioff, and loosely based on Homer's epic tale. A two and a half hour epic (UK: 163 min / Germany:162 min cut version, and is directed by Wolfgang Petersen, who is himself, no stranger to blockbuster movies, with such movies as, The Perfect Storm, Outbreak and Air Force One, among his successes. Now if you have lived under a rock all your life, and have no idea what the Iliad is, then first I will tell you a little about it, so that you will have a better understanding of the review. In the Iliad, a plague is...

Paradis 05.10.2004 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average helpful
Review of Troy (Special Edition) (DVD)

Disaster of Troy

Advantages: great film, brilliant special effects, sound acting
Disadvantages: feature split over 2 discs!, dodgy accents

...hand combat, everything sucks you in and the battles become wholly enjoyable and entertaining. Adding to this are the performances of some of the main characters. Eric Bana creates a true hero for a film that is full of legends. He succeeds at persuading the audience that all he does is for the honour and loyalty of both his family and his country. Bana's skill is mirrored on the Greek side by that of Cox. A big fan of what he has achieved in the past I can say I was not disappointed with his input into 'Troy'. Yet again he portrays the perfect bad guy who the audience just cant wait to come undone. Yet the performance of Pitt leaves much room for improvement, his performance is severely shadowed by that of Bana. He appears to be the token American hero in this Hollywood epic. DVD Features Idiotic cannot describe it. What...

Darko3B 29.06.2008 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average very helpful
Review of Troy (Two Discs) (DVD) (DVD)

If at first you don't succeed, Troy, Troy again

Advantages: Nice costumes
Disadvantages: Dodgy accents, dodgy effects and acting more wooden than the horse

...When prince Paris of Troy romances Helen out from under the nose of her husband Menelaus, he gives Menelaus? brother Agamemnon the perfect excuse to declare war on Troy. With a fleet of a thousand ships, Agamemnon thinks a swift victory is assured, but he has not counted on the cunning and tenacity of the Trojans and in particular Hector, brother of Paris. So he has to do some wheeling and dealing to get the great Greek hero Achilles to fight for him, despite Achilles loathing for his king. Wolfgang Petersen, who first made his name with the character-centric TV series ?Das Boot? has made his Hollywood fortune with a series of spectacular but hollow films like ?The Perfect Storm? and ?Airforce One?. ?Troy? follows in those same sorry footsteps. Instead of sticking to the story set down in Homer?s ?Iliad?, Petersen and co-scribe David...

afy9mab 15.06.2004 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average very helpful
Review of Troy (Special Edition) (DVD)

The story of Troy - not the Iliad

Advantages: An epic film telling an epic story, Plenty of eye candy with Pitt, Bloom and Bana
Disadvantages: It is long - drawn out in parts

...Troy I feel compelled to write a rviewabout this film. I know there has already been 27 reviews written on Ciao but please bear with me. The film has received a lot of critism since its release. The first thing I would like to say on its behalf, is that it does not claim to retell the story of the Iliad. It states quite clearly at the close of the film that it was INSPIRED by the Iliad. Maybe it should have stated this at the bgining of the film, then it would not have led to any misunderstandings or false expectations. The film tells the story of Troy which can be summerised as follows. Paris, the younger son of Priam - King of Troy, falls in love with and steals away Helen, the wife of Menalaos. The Greeks led by Agamemnon, brother of Menalaos, launch a thousand ships to claim her back. They beseige the city of Troy and many...

MAFARRIMOND 10.06.2004 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average helpful
Review of Troy (Special Edition) (DVD)

TROY review

Advantages: fantasic battle scenes and great to watch
Disadvantages: few bad choices and decisions made by the director

...This film has a certificate 15; this is because of the violence throughout the film and slight nudity. I don?t think that the nudity in it is too bad, but there is a lot of violence involved in the battles so the certificate rating was acceptable. It has a running time of 163 minutes, which is ok if you like fighting but I do think that too much was crammed into this amount of time. The film itself is a tale of love and war in ancient Greece; it came to the screen in all its grandeur in the epic-scale adventure. It is set in 1193 BC in Paris. The main thing you need to know about the film is that Prince of Troy (who was played by Orlando Bloom), fell in love with Helen, who is Queen of Sparta (played by Diane Kruger). But this beautiful woman Helen is married to King Menelaus (played by Brendan Gleeson). While Helen isn...

crazy-craig 15.07.2007 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average helpful
Review of Troy (Special Edition) (DVD)

Troy

Advantages: It fulfills its purpose very professionally
Disadvantages: It has minimal individuality

...INTRODUCTION 2004 was a curiously strong year for historical epics. With King Arthur, Troy and Alexander appearing within months of each other there was no lack of enthusiams for fans of this genre, although others may question these big budget conglamorations as being nothing more than the producers wish to ride the post-Lord of the Rings wave. As it was, none of these modern epics managed to pull through the consciousness of the audiences the way The Lord of the Rings did and either were lambasted by all or quietly faded away from memory. In that latter group is Wolfgang Petersen's Troy, the epic retelling of the fall of Troy, with the ever marketable Brad Pitt as Achilles and the equally charming Orlando Bloom of LOTR fame as Paris, with Diane Kruger as their love interest Helen and Eric Bana as Hector. With the usual CGI effects...

berlioz 29.03.2005 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average very helpful
Review of Troy - Various Artists

J noticed that Troy is "Yort" backwards.

Advantages: good entertainment
Disadvantages: I was at the front in the cinema and that sucked.

...BACKGROUND ********************* Your French slave, once again, is at your service and forced himself to go and see Brad Pitt in the cinema? To make things worse, I had to seat at the front of the screen on the left side. That sucked real bad, and furthermore, the picture was jumpy and blury. I was so close to the screen that I could have watched the movie without my glasses (=binoculars). Anyway, I still managed to see the movie. So here is my review... PLOT ********* The King Agamemnon is thursty of power and greed. He is conquering most of Greece, thanks to one of his best men, Achilles. However, Achilles is quite stubborn and hard to control... Agamemnon's brother, the king Menelaus of Sparta is married to one of the most beautiful women of greece, Helen. After the celebration of peace between Sparta and Troy, The young...

monsieur.Joda 01.06.2004 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average helpful
Review of Troy (Special Edition) (DVD)